This article engages with the field of social work's role in humanitarian and criminal legal responses to sex work in the United States over the last century. Our historical review reveals that, through interdisciplinary collaboration in the criminalization and rehabilitation of sex workers, social workers have contributed to the transformation of “prostitution” from an issue of sex workers’ rights to a psychological, criminal legal, and medical phenomenon. This has exacerbated the harm and stigma experienced by sex workers. In exploring social work interventions on sex work from the Progressive Era through the rise of neoliberalism, this article places its modern iteration, prostitution diversion programming, within the context of social work's carceral history with sex workers. We choose these periods not for their chronicity, but rather for the salient themes in these historical interventions that characterize modern diversion programming: power and control, punitive service provision, patriarchal rescue, and carceral feminism. To align with social work's mandate for social justice and client self-determination, this article offers policy and practice implications grounded in the decriminalization of sex work and divestment from the police and courts. Alternative service approaches spearheaded by sex workers are explored and placed within the context of labor, racial, gender, and immigration justice.
6 December 2021 in Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly
Research on China’s volunteerism highlights the state as a major force in mobilizing volunteer participation. Nevertheless, limited quantitative research exists documenting the extent to which Chinese volunteers are connected to the state system. Using a nationally representative dataset, the 2012 Chinese General Social Survey, this study examines how an individual’s employment affiliation with state-controlled institutions influences their probability to volunteer. The results show that the Chinese government not only directly mobilizes employees of the state system to volunteer but also has significant influence over the general population’s volunteering. This influence is mainly through the existence of Chinese Communist Party chapters in every corner of society, as well as the state’s direct and indirect control over social organizations that organize volunteer activities. We thus question the extent to which volunteerism in China is truly voluntary and call for more critical analysis of this issue.
18 June 2020 in Human Service Organizations: Management, Leadership & Governance
Using a nationally representative dataset, this paper examines the nonprofit/for-profit difference in the gender pay gap specifically within the human services field. This industry-specific analysis is necessary because nonprofit organizations are concentrated in these fields. Unlike the conventional finding (based on economy-wide analyses) that the gender pay gap is smaller in nonprofits, this study does not find a significant nonprofit/for-profit difference in the gender pay gap within the human services. In addition, it examines the nonprofit pay differential for both female and male human services workers relative to their for-profit counterparts and finds an overall wage premium for nonprofit men.
16 March 2021 in VOLUNTAS: International Journal of Voluntary and Nonprofit Organizations
With a clear agenda to reform the public service system and promote a service-oriented nonprofit sector, the Chinese government has been building a local service system by contracting with nonprofit organizations (NPOs) at the community level. Through the competing institutional logics perspective, this article examines the challenges that NPOs experienced and their responding strategies. The study found that bureaucratic logic, managerial logic, professional logic, and guanxi relations logic coexisted in the service field and each had different expectations of NPOs. In juggling the various requirements of these competing institutional logics, NPOs faced three major challenges: powerless status, legitimacy crisis, and accountability dilemma. Nevertheless, they were committed to the community and demonstrated agency in addressing these challenges. The strategies they used included using an intermediary platform to reduce power imbalance, compromising to share legitimacy with neighborhood committees, establishing professional identity, building community, and meeting both upward and downward accountability.
27 June 2023 in Human Service Organizations: Management, Leadership & Governance