Out-of-body experience (OBE) is generated by sensory disintegration. In virtual reality (VR), we can provide OBE to people by switching the first-person perspective (1PP) to the third-person perspective (3PP). Generally, 1PP is the choice for high body ownership and presence. Moreover, tactile feedback that is experienced from the 1PP can provide a higher immersive experience. However, whether the combination of 3PP and tactile feedback could affect the sense of embodiment in immersive environments is underexplored. Thus, we conducted a 2 × 2 (OBE: 1PP vs. 3PP × Tactile Feedback [TF]: with vs. without tactile feedback) VR study to discover the effect of OBE in the presence of TF. In our study, we examined OBE and TF through the five dimensions of the sense of embodiment: body ownership, agency, tactile sensations, location of the body, and response to external stimuli. We developed an application to replicate the rubber hand illusion (RHI) study with partial body tracking. We found significant results for both OBE and TF in different dimensions of embodiment. Specifically, we revealed that 3PP decreased the body’s sense of body ownership, agency, and location. Moreover, enabling tactile feedback induced tactile sensations and responses to external stimuli. In the remainder of this paper, we discuss our findings and limitations and provide directions for future studies on OBE in VR.
21 June 2021 in Behaviour & Information Technology
A virtual reality (VR) study was conducted both in our lab setting and remotely to investigate the effects of virtual hand appearance and tactile feedback on ownership, external appearance, and tactile sensation embodiment dimensions when participants were instructed to perform an assembly task in a virtual environment. Six experimental conditions that combine hand appearances (abstract, mannequin, and realistic) and tactile feedback (tactile and no tactile) levels were examined. The results of our study indicated that: (1) the more realistic hand had a stronger effect on tactile sensation and external appearance, while the mannequin hand was associated with a greater ownership effect; (2) tactile feedback was associated with a stronger effect on external appearance compared to no tactile feedback; (3) the realistic hand model in conjunction with tactile feedback significantly affected the tactile sensation of the participants; (4) the participants in the lab setting rated the external appearance of the realistic hand model higher than the remote participants; (5) the participants exposed for less than one hour per week to VR rated the tactile sensation in the presence of tactile feedback higher, while they similarly rated the external appearance of the virtual hand model in the presence of a realistic hand model higher when compared to those who were exposed for more than one hour per week to VR; and finally, (6) the younger participants rated the tactile sensation higher than the older participants in the presence of the realistic hand model. In this paper, we discuss our findings and provide design considerations for virtual reality applications that consider virtual hands and tactile feedback.
25 May 2023 in Computer Animation and Virtual Worlds
Summary: Midair typing has gradually become the potential mainstream of virtual reality (VR) typing, as it eliminates the setup of additional hardware devices and provides convenience for portable head‐mounted displays (HMDs). In midair typing, users type on a virtual keyboard while using their virtual hands. In addition to the lack of a dominant method for VR‐based midair typing, we still do not know the impact that different appearances of virtual hands could have on text input in VR. Thus, we picked a widely used midair typing method (i.e., the VR‐rendered QWERTY keyboard) and conducted a VR study to explore the effects of three hand appearances (i.e., abstract, mannequin, realistic hands) on typing efficiency in terms of typing accuracy, typing speed, and task load. Our within‐group study revealed that (1) the mannequin hand caused significantly higher performance on typing speed than the abstract and realistic hands, (2) the abstract hand caused significantly lower performance (more typing errors) on typing accuracy compared to the mannequin and realistic hands, and (3) participants rated the task load of using the abstract hand significantly higher than the mannequin and realistic hands.
We conducted a virtual reality study to explore virtual hand illusion through three levels of appearance (Appearance dimension: realistic vs. pixelated vs. toon hand appearances) and two levels of tactile feedback (Tactile dimension: no tactile vs. tactile feedback). We instructed our participants to complete a virtual assembly task in this study. Immediately afterward, we asked them to provide self-reported ratings on a survey that captured presence and five embodiment dimensions (hand ownership, touch sensation, agency and motor control, external appearance, and response to external stimuli). The results of our study indicate that (1) tactile feedback generated a stronger sense of presence, touch sensation, and response to external stimuli; (2) the pixelated hand appearance provided the least hand ownership and external appearance; and (3) in the presence of the pixelated hand, prior virtual reality experience of participants impacted their agency and motor control and their response to external stimuli ratings. This paper discusses our findings and provides design considerations for virtual reality applications with respect to the realistic appearance of virtual hands and tactile feedback.
24 January 2025 in ACM Transactions on Applied Perception
In virtual reality, creating intelligent virtual characters has been a long-lasting endeavor. However, while researchers have investigated several aspects of a virtual character’s intelligence, little attention has been paid to the impact of the implemented intelligence levels assigned to a virtual character during human–virtual character collaboration. Thus, we conducted a within-group study ( \(N=24\) ) to explore how three different intelligence levels (low vs. medium vs. high) assigned to a virtual character can impact how study participants perceive that virtual character and interact with the task they are instructed to complete. Specifically, for our study, we developed a jigsaw puzzle game and instructed our participants to solve it with the help of a virtual character. During the jigsaw puzzle solving process, we collected application logs related to how the participants executed the task and observed the virtual environment. Moreover, after each condition, we asked the participants to respond using a questionnaire that examined their social presence, how they perceived the character’s intelligence and compared it with their own, and how they rated the virtual character’s realism. Our results indicated that the different intelligence levels assigned to the virtual characters impacted participants’ responses on several variables, including co-presence, perceived intelligence, intelligence comparison, and character interaction and behavior realism. Moreover, based on the collected logged data, we found that the intelligence levels assigned to our virtual character significantly impacted the performance of our participants. Our results could be valuable to the research community for creating more engaging experiences with intelligent virtual characters for collaborative tasks in immersive environments.