This study was designed to examine diurnal variations in tear film break-up time (BUT) and maximum blink interval (MBI) and to assess two different ways of calculating these variables on video recordings of the BUT test interpreted with the help of especially designed software. The repeatability of interpreting BUT video recordings was also addressed. Twenty-six healthy young adults were enrolled after ruling out dry eye according to a battery of tests (ocular surface disease index, McMonnies questionnaire, Schirmer test, phenol red test and corneal staining). BUT and maximum blink interval were determined on video-recordings of the BUT test conducted over a day in four sessions (9.30 am, 12.30 pm, 3.30 pm and 6.30 pm). In each session, the test was repeated three times to give three videos in which three BUT and MBI values were obtained by a masked observer. BUT and MBI were determined by averaging the three measurements and by averaging only the two closest measurements. Finally, two further experienced observers re-examined the videos to assess the repeatability of the BUT measurements made. No diurnal variation in BUT was observed regardless of whether three or two video measurements were averaged. Significant correlation was detected between BUT and MBI. Inter-observer repeatability was better when BUT times were no longer than 15 seconds. Tear film BUT was not influenced by the time of day and moderate to strong correlation with MBI was observed in all four sessions. The software-assisted method proved useful and identified the need to clarify the BUT end-point and to limit the test to 15 seconds to improve observer repeatability.

The measurement of tear film osmolarity has been suggested as a gold standard in the diagnosis of dry eye. Many tear film physiological variables oscillate during the day. This review summarises current clinical knowledge regarding diurnal osmolarity variation in the tear film. A critical analysis is presented in respect of of sample size and characteristics, differences in the diurnal osmolarity variation on healthy versus altered tear film conditions or environment, and time of day and number of measurements undertaken. A comparison of 21 studies was made for studies in which one of the main objectives was to analyse the variance of tear film osmolarity at different time-points in a day on human cohorts. Tear film osmolarity appeard to be somewhat influenced by the time of day in healthy subjects and patients with ocular surface disease, or altered by environmental conditions. Both healthy and non-physiological tear film cohorts showed variations in results depending on the study: no variations during the day or statistically different values at some point in the day. These differences could be in the middle of the day or between the beginning and the end of the day, with higher values in the morning than in the afternoon, or even the opposite situation. The possibility of diurnal variations in tear film osmolarity should be considered by the clinician since the time of day when the tear film measurements are made can be critical in making the right diagnosis. Future studies in the diurnal variation field may have to use a well-established range of measurement time-points and a larger group of healthy subjects and and subjects who have a tear film altered by pathological or environmental conditions.