BackgroundThis study examines the perspectives of students, teachers, and parents on the implementation of mobile phone restrictions in schools, policies increasingly adopted worldwide. While existing research sometimes suggests potential benefits, less attention has been given to how these policies are experienced by key stakeholders. By exploring the perceived advantages and disadvantages of school restriction policies from multiple viewpoints, this paper aims to provide a more comprehensive understanding of the implications of mobile phone restrictions in school settings.MethodsThis study was conducted with a large sample of middle and high school students (n = 1532), teachers (n = 124) and parents (n = 240) from four school districts (n = 6 middle schools, n = 7 high schools, n = 1 alternative K-12 school) in Washington State. Participants provided 3792 responses to open-ended survey questions exploring the “pros” and “cons” of phone restriction policies.ResultsThematic analysis identified ten key themes across the three stakeholder groups: academic outcomes, student self-regulation and well-being, communication, policy enforcement, accessibility, entertainment, student relationships, teachers’ job satisfaction and efficacy, personal property concerns, and a perceived lack of advantages or disadvantages.Among students, the most prominent themes were (a) perceived academic benefits, (b) communication drawbacks, and (c) mixed perspectives on impacts to self-regulation and well-being. For teachers, the most frequently reported themes included (a) challenges with policy enforcement, (b) academic benefits, and (c) improved student social interaction. For parents, the dominant themes were (a) communication drawbacks, (b) student self-regulation and well-being benefits, and (c) academic benefits.ConclusionOverall, these findings highlight the complex and often mixed perceptions of phone restrictions across students, teachers, and parents. While academic benefits were consistently noted, concerns around communication, student well-being, and policy implementation reveal important trade-offs. To gain a more comprehensive understanding of these impacts, it is essential to capture the perspectives of all stakeholders. Incorporating these diverse viewpoints can support the development of more balanced, effective, and context-sensitive approaches to managing phone use in schools.