The basic components of qualitative data analysis are systematically organized and described. The authors propose a system centered on a database architecture with four elements that correspond to the fundamental types of information collected in the research process: (1) characteristics of the sources where answers to research questions are sought, (2) primary information collected from the sources, (3) secondary information generated to assist in the interpretation of the primary information, and (4) characteristics of the coders who generate the secondary information. The authors describe a process for constructing each of the four database elements, including criteria for inclusion of data in each element. The proposed system supports the use of quantitative and qualitative approaches to evaluate qualitative coding schemes, to assess intra- and intercoder agreement, to recognize meaningful patterns in qualitative data, and to describe the underlying symbolic and sociocultural systems reflected in the data objects.
Local communities sometimes face severe shocks, such as the COVID-19 pandemic or economic recession, which inflict widespread harm, intensify injustice and test the ties that bind people together. A recent “Springboard” theory proposes a way to spring forward toward an equitable, thriving future by altering priorities among four structural drivers of population well-being: the extent of vital conditions, equity, urgent services capacity, and belonging and civic muscle. To explore the strategic implications of the Springboard theory, we developed the Thriving Together Model, a system dynamics simulation model that lets users play out alternative investment priorities and track changes over a decade as they try to maximize the number of people thriving and minimize suffering. The prototype model is exploratory, subject to further refinement and empirical support, but it has already sparked creative conversations among hundreds of changemakers who have interacted with it through an interactive theater. This paper presents the model’s structure, illustrative results, and tentative insights. The Thriving Together Model extends Ostrom’s Nobel Prize-winning work on shared stewardship by offering a general explanation about how stewards of a divided community can heal through a traumatic shock and spring forward toward a future with greater well-being and justice.
In America and around the world, one’s chances for well-being depend on systems that are not yet built for everyone to thrive together. Knowing that life expectancy and life evaluation are far below their full potential, with stark injustices by race/ethnicity, we ask: how can the United States make a great stride toward multiracial well-being?. This study explores potential impacts of a federal plan for thriving people and places. We estimate the likely effects of 68 recommendations using ReThink Health’s Thriving Together Model (TTM), revised with new data and new features including a multisolving ratio that accounts for greater cost-effectiveness when a proposed action advances multiple goals at once. The TTM is a previously published system dynamics model that simulates changes over time when community assets (both funding and in-kind resources) are invested in four drivers of population well-being (i.e., Vital Conditions, Belonging and Civic Muscle, Fairness in System Design, and Urgent Services Capacity). All drivers work together through a dynamic structure that influences individual states of thriving, suffering, and life expectancy (overall and by race/ethnicity). The model specifies three reinforcing dynamics, including an “expanding the pie” loop that can increase available assets and improve all four well-being drivers over time. Results reveal a plausible scenario over 25 years in which thriving could rise 20 percentage points, suffering could drop 2.5 percentage points, and average life expectancy could grow by 2.6 years – all from equitable progress across racial/ethnic groups. Every subgroup improves, but the greatest gains would likely be among Black and Hispanic Americans. Sensitivity tests confirm that the model’s conclusions are robust across identified uncertainty ranges. The federal plan points the way toward a just transition for multiracial well-being. It does not require new appropriations or authorities: only the will and wherewithal to bring these recommendations to life.
What inspires people to become better stewards of the systems that shape our lives together? This chapter explores the power of shared stewardship, with an emphasis on routine practices and personal courage needed to accept loss when navigating toward an equitable, thriving future. ReThink Health’s fieldwork reveals three clusters of essential stewardship practices: Connecting Across Differences, Creating Transformative Opportunities, and Learning and Adapting. All have inner, spiritual dimensions that enable people to move beyond fragmented, narrow self-interest toward wider interdependence. Reflective engagement and close accompaniment are pivotal, based on insights from stewards themselves. The authors offer a memorable formula that highlights the exponential power of relationships and the imperative to fit across contexts. The chapter concludes with introspective questions that guide stewards to find within themselves the courage to let go of outdated mindsets and habits as they become better ancestors in an intergenerational movement to thrive together.
1 December 2020 in American Journal of Public Health
American Journal of Public Health (AJPH) from the American Public Health Association (APHA) Commonsense Questions to Move Beyond Health Care at All Costs, an article from American Journal of Public Health, Vol 110 Issue 12