Biomass estimation offers insight into aquatic ecosystem processes and represents a powerful tool for measuring biomass in communities. However, the accuracy of this estimate depends considerably on the sample preservation method and biological traits of species. We quantified the effect of commonly used preservatives (70% ethanol, 4% formaldehyde, freezing), preservation time and initial body length on the estimation bias of body length, wet mass and dry mass in two mayfly species with dorsoventrally flattened (Rhithrogena carpatoalpina) and cylindrically elongated (Habroleptoides confusa) bodies. Freezing caused the largest relative bias in the length estimates (up to 18%). Both ethanol and freezing led to significant underestimation of wet mass of preserved animals (up to 26%). The most severe biases were observed in dry weights, where all preservation methods reduced body mass by up to 89%. Importantly, initial body mass influenced the bias caused by preservation, and the larger animals were less affected by mass losses. In contrast, larger individuals were subject to greater length reduction. Additionally, the length–mass relationship for R. carpatoalpina, based on fresh mass of living animals, was significantly different from relationships based on preserved animals. Overall, formaldehyde caused the least biased estimates of length and biomass in both examined species. This case study indicates that direct measurements of unpreserved individuals or length–mass equations based on fresh material are likely the best ways to avoid severe underestimation of biomass in aquatic insects. However, more studies covering a broader range of taxa are needed to reach general conclusions.
Body mass underpins many ecological processes at the level of individuals, populations, and communities. Often estimated in arthropods from linear morphological traits such as body length or head width, these relationships can vary even between closely related taxa. Length–mass relationships of mosquito (Diptera: Culicidae) larvae are poorly known despite the importance of this family to disease and aquatic ecology. To fill this gap, we measured ontogenetic changes in linear traits (body length, head width, and thorax width) and dry and wet masses and estimated length- and width–mass relationships in larvae of 3 culicid species inhabiting different niches: the tropical Aedes albopictus (Skuse, 1894), the temperate Culex pipiens (Linnaeus, 1758), and the snowmelt Ochlerotatus punctor (Kirby, 1837). We compared our results with published length–mass allometries of other aquatic dipteran larvae. We showed that thorax width and body length, but not head width, reliably predicted body mass for our 3 species. The length–mass allometry slopes in aquatic dipterans varied considerably between and within families but were independent of phylogeny, specimen handling, preservation techniques, and data fitting methods. Slope estimates became less precise with decreasing sample size and size range. To obtain reliable estimates of the allometric slopes, we have thus recommended using data on all larval stages for intraspecific allometries and a wide range of species for interspecific allometries. We also cautioned against the indiscriminate use of length–mass allometries obtained for other taxa or collected at lower taxonomic resolutions, e.g., when using length–mass relationships to estimate biomass production at a given site.
The lack of reliable data on length-mass relationships, essential to obtain accurate biomass estimates, limits our ability to easily assess secondary production by aquatic invertebrates. In the absence of published equations from similar habitat conditions, authors often borrow equations developed in geographic regions with different climate conditions, which may bias biomass estimates. A literature overview of published size-mass relationships for Portugal and Sweden highlights the need for further data within these biogeographic regions. We increased the number of equations available to Southern and Northern Europe, developing 18 new length-mass relationships for two families and 10 genera in Portugal and Sweden. All equations were published for the first time for these countries, except the genus Asellus. Our length-mass relationships were obtained from specimens collected on a one-time sampling of eight ponds in Portugal and five ponds in Sweden during late spring in 2023. Dry mass (DM) was modelled as a function of body length (BL), using the natural log-linear function with a power model (ln DM = ln a + b × ln BL). The equations obtained were compared with linear mixed models testing the fixed effects of “body length” and “country”, as well as their interaction. A comparison of the equations developed in this study showed country-specific differences for all taxa, expect the genus Caenis, indicating a low potential transferability of the equations between Southern and Northern Europe. In contrast, the comparison of the equation obtained for A. aquaticus in this study with an equation published for this taxon in Sweden showed great similarities, suggesting a high transferability. Recommending caution in the borrowing of published length-mass equations, that can differ drastically between different geographic and climatic regions, especially at larger sizes, we provide a series of guidelines and good practices in this field.
Riparian forests play a crucial role in aquatic ecosystems by regulating light, temperature, channel stability and nutrient cycling. However, these forests are highly vulnerable to invasion by alien plant species, which can alter leaf litter inputs and decomposition dynamics, thereby impacting freshwater ecosystem functions. This study explores the decomposition rates of native black alder (Alnus glutinosa) and two riparian invaders, Japanese knotweed (Fallopia japonica) and Canada goldenrod (Solidago canadensis), in both headwater streams and pond mesocosms in Central Europe. We conducted experiments with 169 litter bags to assess decomposition rates and test the home-field advantage hypothesis. The hypothesis assumes that native litter decomposes faster due to the evolutionary adaptation of local decomposer communities. We found that invasive S. canadensis decomposed significantly faster than native A. glutinosa in both lotic and lentic environments. On the other hand, invasive F. japonica decomposed at a comparable rate (streams) or at a slower rate (ponds) than the native species. These findings contradict the home-field advantage hypothesis, suggesting that decomposition rates are primarily driven by litter nutrient content rather than geographic origin. The rapid breakdown of S. canadensis is likely driven by the low C:P ratio of its litter. The rapid decomposition of this litter may lead to short-term nutrient boosts that are quickly lost due to microbial activity, whereas the slow decomposition of F. japonica may limit immediate nutrient availability but extend their accessibility over longer periods. Overall, the invasion of riparian zones by species with litter traits distinct from those of native species can disrupt ecosystem processes, leading to cascading effects on aquatic food webs and nutrient cycling. Understanding the effects of riparian forest invasions on organic matter processing is essential for managing biodiversity and maintaining ecosystem integrity in freshwater environments.