Over-extraction of groundwater is a prominent challenge in India, with profound implication for food security, livelihoods, and economic development. As groundwater is an ‘invisible’ and mobile common pool resource, sustainable governance of groundwater is complex, multifaceted, requiring coordination among various stakeholders at different scales. It remains an open question as to what can be done to strengthen the governance of groundwater, particularly on the scale necessary to address widespread depletion of resources. The growing competition over groundwater resources calls for systemic changes towards sustainable water management. These require understanding the behaviours of actors in the system network, as well as the institutions that shape the direction in which the system moves. In this paper, we offer a behavioural perspective to system transformation and apply it to the example of an Indian NGO working on sustainable natural resource governance. The organisation, Foundation for Ecological Security (FES), has been co-designing and using various institutional tools for groundwater governance with the collaboration of other NGOs and government partners, academic and research organisations towards strengthening governance of water. At the local level, these include groundwater monitoring and crop water budgeting, combined with experiential learning tools such as games for demand management, and supply side interventions to support water harvesting and recharge. These tools are combined with efforts to strengthen multi-actor platforms, building coalitions and capacity of government, civil society and private sector actors to support groundwater governance at scale. By combining local and systemic approaches, the aim is to influence water governance on a larger scale and contribute to the sustainable management of water resources in India. Our reflections illustrate how conceptual thinking can inform multi-methods approaches which consider that sustainably improving groundwater management at large scale requires inter-linked behavioural changes of diverse actors. Our approach constitutes critical reflection and conceptualization, based on situated knowledge which contributes to designing better adapted and more powerful intervention strategies through informed argument.
1 January 2018 in GAIA - Ecological Perspectives for Science and Society
Stakeholder (SH) involvement is a major and ever-challeng ing aspect of transdisciplinary research (TDR). Reflecting on three land management research projects (Carbiocial, SuLaMa, TFO) in a North-South setting, we present their individual approaches for SH involvement and discuss which SH group was involved, when and why. We identify patterns and share lessons learnt that can serve to design TDR projects in general and in a North-South context specifically. Close collaboration with strategic SHs for project conceptualisation and implementation is essential to build ownership and link the project to other SHs. However, structures based on equal partnerships are required. Diversified methods adapted to the specific regional context enable target-oriented involvement during research, but un expected dynamics and diverging interests must be kept in mind. Reflections on the processes of SH involvement in TDR project teams are vital for easing power imbalances and intercultural misunderstandings.
15 June 2020 in International Journal of Information Technology
9560 Background: Melanoma staging, as defined by the American Joint Committee on Cancer (AJCC), is limited in its ability to predict outcome. We have previously identified and validated a prognostic gene signature expressed in primary cutaneous melanoma and adjacent stroma. The signature comprises seven protective genes (down-regulated with tumor progression) and one risk-associated gene (up-regulated). A signature-based risk score independently predicts patient survival, across AJCC stages IA-IIIC, in formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded (FFPE) melanomas (training cohort, n = 125; p = 0.0003, hazard ratio 1.85). The score has been validated in 206 melanomas, selected to be significantly mis-prognosticated by AJCC staging regarding patient survival (40.8% mis-prognostication). In this cohort, the score outperforms AJCC staging (p = 0.0005, hazard ratio 1.41 vs. p = n.s.), correcting 34.9% of AJCC-based mis-prognostications. Methods: Here, we report twofold external validation of the risk score, (i) prognostic performance in silico using the SurvExpress web tool (Aguirre-Gamboa et al., 2013), and (ii) technical performance in vitro(Dermatologikum Hamburg; IMGM Munich). Results: (i) Kaplan Meier analysis and log-rank testing demonstrated that all signature genes combined predicted survival in four different cohorts of metastatic melanoma (from GEO Expression Omnibus or Cancer Genome Atlas; cohorts dichotomized at the median): see table. (ii) The risk score was re-analyzed in melanomas of the training cohort (n=69). The overall concordance of duplicate determinations was 90% (average scores of 1.12 ± 0.14 and 0.97 ± 0.14). Conclusions: In conclusion, we have validated a signature-based FFPE melanoma risk score, complementary to AJCC staging in predicting outcome: (i) Signature genes predicted patient survival in silico(n=449) (ii) The risk score proved to be reproducible and technically robust in vitro. The score improves risk stratification and decision making in melanoma, particularly regarding new adjuvant therapies.
Economic games have emerged as promising tools for fostering sustainable resource management, yet their gender dynamics remain underexplored. We examine how women’s participation relates to the effectiveness of game-based learning in 56 Indian communities facing water management challenges. These structured experiential learning environments allow participants to develop system understanding, problem-solving capacities, and collective action through active engagement. Our results suggest that greater female involvement is associated with improved water management outcomes 2 years after the intervention. Notably, the presence of female leaders correlated with broader participation among women, which in turn was linked to the development of more effective management rules. These findings indicate that gender-balanced participation may enhance the success of such interventions. Incorporating women in game-based learning has the potential to support long-term improvements in resource management, highlighting the importance of inclusive approaches.