The fulfillment of customer orders has gained a particularly important role within omni-channel retailing, as it requires significant effort to integrate logistics networks and product flows. Offering additional fulfillment options is costly but allows the enhancement of customer services via cross-channel substitutions and faster deliveries. Retailers are asking themselves how they can leverage these integrated systems to improve return on investment as well as customer service. One option is to influence customers’ channel choice (i.e., steering). Because this has so far mainly been viewed from a marketing perspective, this study investigates how and why different fulfillment options can help to steer customers across channels. By using multiple sources of data (i.e., market data, retailer interviews, customer focus groups), this paper identifies how customers can be guided through channels by means of related options in inventory management (e.g., cross-channel inventory information and substitution), delivery modes (e.g., differentiation of prices and delivery velocity across channels), and return modes (e.g., pricing for returns and options to return goods in-store). In essence, this research paper contributes a theory of cross-channel customer steering by means of different fulfillment options.
Problem definition: We compare several approaches for generating a prioritized list of items to be counted in a retail store, with the objective of detecting inventory record inaccuracy and unknown out of stocks. Academic/practical relevance: We consider both “rule-based” approaches, which sort items based on heuristic indices, and “model-based” approaches, which maintain probability distributions for the true inventory levels updated based on sales and replenishment observations. Methodology: Our study evaluates these approaches on multiple metrics using data from inventory audits we conducted at European home and personal care retailer dm-drogerie markt. Results: Our results support arguments for both rule-based and model-based approaches. We find that model-based approaches provide versatile visibility into inventory states and are useful for a broad range of objectives but that rule-based approaches are also effective as long as they are matched to the retailer’s goal. We find that “high-activity” rule-based policies, which favor items with high sales volumes, inventory levels, and past errors, are more effective at detecting inventory discrepancies. The best policies uncover over twice the discrepancies detected by random selection. A “low-activity” rule-based policy based on low recorded inventory levels, on the other hand, is more effective at detecting unknown out of stocks. The best policy detects over eight times the unknown out of stocks found by random selection. Managerial implications: Our findings provide immediate guidance to our retail partner on appropriate methods for detecting inventory record inaccuracy and unknown out of stocks. Our approach can be replicated at other retailers interested in customized optimization of their counting programs. Funding: This work was supported by the Bavarian Ministry for Science and Arts [Grant BayIntAn_KUEI_2018_43] and the EHI Foundation and GS1 Germany [Prize for Best Collaboration Between Science and Practice in Retail Research (2019)]. A. J. Mersereau thanks the Sarah Graham Kenan Foundation for support. Supplemental Material: The online appendix is available at https://doi.org/10.1287/msom.2022.1119 .
This paper investigates and systematizes planning problems along the supply chain of small and medium-sized companies in the horticultural market of ornamental plants, perennials, and cut flowers. The sector faces considerable challenges such as multiple planning uncertainties, product perishability, and considerable lead times. However, decisions in practice are often based on rules of thumb. Data-driven decision support is thus necessary to professionalize supply chain, logistics, and operations planning in the sector. We explore the practical planning problems with the help of expert interviews with people in charge of typical companies active in the market. We structure the planning problems along the supply chain according to their time horizon and highlight the critical elements of the planning tasks and horticultural specifics. We examine the status quo of research on decision support for these planning tasks with the help of a structured literature review, highlight research gaps, and outline promising future research directions. We find that the tactical planning domains of material/product requirement, production, and demand planning are especially critical in practice, and that there is a great need for research to develop practically relevant decision support systems. Such systems are currently available only to a limited extent in literature and are not fully compatible with requirements in the ornamental horticultural sector. By structuring and detailing the relevant decision problems, we contribute to an understanding of planning problems and decision-making in horticultural supply chains, and we provide a first comprehensive overview of planning problems, aligned literature, and research gaps for the horticultural business.
Public holiday weeks cause specific challenges in grocery retailing as sales are raising and working days for logistics processes are reduced. The paper analyzes the operational planning challenges and solutions for demand planning and disposition as well as for warehouse and transportation management of grocery retailers in public holiday seasons. A total of 22 top managers representing 20 sales lines of 17 of the top 30 grocery retailers in Germany participated in the study. Semi-structured, face-to-face interviews with logistics managers were conducted and analyzed. Uncertainties and missing resources can be identified as the two main challenges of public holiday seasons in grocery retailing. Retailers implement numerous measures that can be summarized in three categories, i.e., the adjustment of workload profiles, the adaptation of resources and modifying processes. Literature has so far considered public holidays only to a limited extent, e.g., as a parameter in forecasting models or for the application of marketing instruments. This study is the first developing a framework and providing insights into operational planning in grocery retailing.
24 September 2023 in International Transactions in Operational Research