New reform documents underscore the importance of integrating science practices into the learning of science. This integration requires sophisticated teaching that does not often happen. Educative curriculum materials – materials explicitly designed to support teacher and student learning – have been posited as a way to support teachers to achieve these ambitious goals, yet little is known about how elementary teachers actually use educative curriculum materials to support student engagement in science practices. To address this gap, this study investigated how five upper elementary teachers supported students to engage in science practices during an enactment of two curriculum units. Three of the teachers had units enhanced with educative features, informed by current research and reforms, while two of the teachers had units without these features. The teachers varied in how they supported students in the science practices of justifying predictions, constructing evidence-based claims, recording observations, and planning investigations. For example, some of the teachers with the educative features supported students in constructing evidence-based claims and justifying predictions in ways called for by the educative features. Implications for curriculum developers and teacher educators are discussed based on the patterns found in the teachers’ use of the educative curriculum materials.
Educative curriculum materials present a promising mechanism for promoting more ambitious science teaching in elementary classrooms, including engaging students in science practices. Integrating science practices with science content is emphasized in new education reforms. Elementary teachers, however, face challenges in engaging children in science practices such as scientific argumentation. We propose that the justification of predictions could serve as an entrée to scientific argumentation in elementary grades. To support elementary teachers in integrating science content with science practice, including justifying predictions about scientific phenomena, we added educative features to 2 existing upper elementary inquiry science units, 1 on electric circuits and 1 on ecosystems. This article reports results from a large-scale, quasi-experimental study with 2 conditions: the treatment condition, in which teachers had educative features, and the comparison condition, in which teachers had the original curriculum materials. This study sought to characterize differences in students’ written predictions with justification across condition and discipline. In the treatment condition, in which teachers were using the educative curriculum materials, the students’ predictions with justification showed significantly greater improvement in quality scores from the preunit assessment to the postunit assessment compared to the comparison condition. In addition, there was more evidence of teacher support for justifying predictions in the collected notebooks and enactments in the treatment condition compared to the comparison condition. These findings have implications for curriculum developers and teacher educators, suggesting an important role for educative curriculum materials in promoting reforms in science education.
6 February 2020 in Journal of Science Teacher Education
This study investigated how practice-based science methods courses, at three different institutions, provided opportunities for preservice teachers (PSTs) to develop new ways of enacting and noticing ambitious teaching through analyzing rehearsal lessons. We examined 194 written rehearsal reflections for similarities and differences in the types of evidence the PSTs attended to, how they reasoned about what they noticed, and their revision ideas for improving their instruction. The findings suggest the PSTs at the three institutions (a) attended to aspects of their teacher practice and student actions as evidence to decide how to adapt their teaching; (b) used improvement to learning as a key reason to modify the instruction; and (c) focused on ways to revise how they scaffolded science practices for students and supported student sensemaking of core ideas. These findings offer insights into the unique affordances of rehearsal-based reflections in providing opportunities for PSTs to notice and analyze critical features of science teaching.
22 January 2022 in Journal of Research in Science Teaching