Design of in situ microbially induced calcite precipitation (MICP) strategies relies on a predictive capability. To date much of the mathematical modeling of MICP has focused on small‐scale experiments and/or one‐dimensional flow in porous media, and successful parameterizations of models in these settings may not pertain to larger scales or to nonuniform, transient flows. Our objective in this article is to report on modeling to test our ability to predict behavior of MICP under controlled conditions in a meter‐scale tank experiment with transient nonuniform transport in a natural soil, using independently determined parameters. Flow in the tank was controlled by three wells, via a complex cycle of injection/withdrawals followed by no‐flow intervals. Different injection solution recipes were used in sequence for transport characterization, biostimulation, cementation, and groundwater rinse phases of the 17 day experiment. Reaction kinetics were calibrated using separate column experiments designed with a similar sequence of phases. This allowed for a parsimonious modeling approach with zero fitting parameters for the tank experiment. These experiments and data were simulated using PHT3‐D, involving transient nonuniform flow, alternating low and high Damköhler reactive transport, and combined equilibrium and kinetically controlled biogeochemical reactions. The assumption that microbes mediating the reaction were exclusively sessile, and with constant activity, in conjunction with the foregoing treatment of the reaction network, provided for efficient and accurate modeling of the entire process leading to nonuniform calcite precipitation. This analysis suggests that under the biostimulation conditions applied here the assumption of steady state sessile biocatalyst suffices to describe the microbially mediated calcite precipitation.
We investigate the effect of computational error on the inversion of a density‐dependent flow and transport model, using SEAWAT and UCODE‐2005 in an inverse identification of hydraulic conductivity and dispersivity using head and concentration data from a 2‐D laboratory experiment. We investigated inversions using three different solution schemes including variation of number of particles and time step length, in terms of the three aspects: the shape and smoothness of the objective function surface, the consequent impacts to the optimization, and the resulting Pareto analyses. This study demonstrates that the inversion is very sensitive to the choice of the forward model solution scheme. In particular, standard finite difference methods provide the smoothest objective function surface; however, this is obtained at the cost of numerical artifacts that can lead to erroneous warping of the objective function surface. Total variation diminishing (TVD) schemes limit these impacts at the cost of more computation time, while the hybrid method of characteristics (HMOC) approach with increased particle numbers and/or reduced time step gives both smoothed and accurate objective function surface. Use of the most accurate methods (TVD and HMOC) did lead to successful inversion of the two parameters; however, with distinct results for Pareto analyses. These results illuminate the sensitivity of the inversion to a number of aspects of the forward solution of the density‐driven flow problem and reveal that parameter values may result that are erroneous but that counteract numerical errors in the solution.
Multicomponent reactive transport involves the solution of a system of nonlinear coupled partial differential equations. A number of methods have been developed to simplify the problem. In the case where all reactions are in instantaneous equilibrium and the mineral assemblage is constant in both space and time, de Simoni et al. (2007) provide an analytical solution that separates transport of aqueous components and minerals using scalar dissipation of “mixing ratios” between a number of boundary/initial solutions. In this approach, aqueous speciation is solved in conventional terms of primary and secondary species, and the mineral dissolution/precipitation rate is given in terms of the scalar dissipation and a chemical transformation term, both involving the secondary species associated with the mineral reaction. However, the identification of the secondary species is nonunique, and so it is not clear how to use the approach in general, a problem that is keenly manifest in the case of multiple minerals which may share aqueous ions. We address this problem by developing an approach to identify the secondary species required in the presence of one or multiple minerals. We also remedy a significant error in the de Simoni et al. (2007) approach. The result is a fixed and extended de Simoni et al. (2007) approach that allows construction of analytical solutions to multicomponent equilibrium reactive transport problems in which the mineral assemblage does not change in space or time and where the transport is described by closed‐form solutions of the mixing ratios.
A classical theoretical inverse problem in groundwater hydraulics is the calibration of a heterogeneous isotropic hydraulic conductivity field using known hydraulic head data at each point in the domain. It has been long known that a necessary condition for the uniqueness of the solution to this theoretical inverse problem is the Cauchy data, i.e., the hydraulic conductivity values (or, equivalently, flux) along a line crossing all streamtubes in the entire domain. This result has been cited in identifying the value of boundary flux data in practical inverse problems, although in general such data are generally not available. In this work, we show that groundwater mean age data replace this Cauchy data requirement.
We analyze and simulate laboratory data on flow and solute transport in a submeter scale sample of Massillon sandstone and we re‐evaluate studies that have stated that these data indicate a failure of the advection‐dispersion, and that nonlocal modeling approaches are necessary. Our examination reveals experimental issues including artificial edge effects in the data, as well as inconsistency in the measured solute injection rates. When the edge effects are removed the data no longer exhibit power‐law tailing. Our simulations show that failure of the advection‐dispersion equation has not been demonstrated and that nonlocal approaches are not necessary.