CCChile Universidad Católica de la Santísima de Concepción
Chile Universidad Católica de la Santísima de Concepción
The investigation compares argumentative individual complexity written in socio-scientific tasks of university students of Psychology, depending on years of study and the presence/absence of an additional representation system (graphs) of information external. 72 students from the argentine university participated. They gave their opinion about a socio-scientific situation that included arguments for and against it, and a group received additional graphic information. The productions were coded according to: (a) whether it was an argumentative text; (b) the relation to the argumentative texts, the number of arguments, the type of difference of opinion, the argumentative structure, and confirmatory bias; (c) he use of information. The results show a relationship between first-year students and non-argumentative texts and between advanced students and the use of argumentative texts. Both types of students reduced the number of arguments when there was no additional information. The results are discussed in relation to both theoretical conceptualization of argumentative competence and the design of educative materials to university. La investigación compara la complejidad argumentativa individual escrita en tareas sociocientíficas de estudiantes universitarios de Psicología, en función del momento de cursado (ingresante/avanzado) y de la presencia de un sistema de representación externa adicional (gráfico). Participaron 72 estudiantes de una universidad argentina. Éstos emitieron opinión escrita sobre una situación sociocientífica con argumentos a favor y en contra, y un grupo dispuso de un sistema de información adicional gráfico. Se codificaron las producciones según: (a) si se trataba de un texto argumentativo; (b) en los textos argumentativos, se consideraron cantidad de argumentos, diferencia de opinión principal, estructura argumentativa, sesgo confirmatorio; (c) uso de información. Los resultados indicaron relación entre estudiantes ingresantes y la producción de textos no argumentativos, por un lado, y estudiantes avanzados y producción de textos argumentativos, por el otro. Ambos tipos de estudiantes redujeron los argumentos cuando no hubo información adicional. Se discuten las implicancias de los resultados en relación a la comprensión teórica de la competencia argumentativa y la creación de material educativo para la formación universtaria.
Mercier and Sperber (2011a, 2011b; Mercier, 2011a, 2011b, 2011c, and 2011d) have presented a stimulating and provocative new theory of reasoning: the argumentative theory of reasoning. They maintain that argumentation is a meta-representational module. In their evolutionary view of argumentation, the function of this module would be to regulate the flow of information between interlocutors through persuasiveness on the side of the communicator and epistemic vigilance on the side of the audience. The aim of this paper is to discuss the perspective of the authors in which they conceive this competence as the natural scenario of reflective reasoning.
This paper reports the first empirical results aiming to characterize argumentative practices in Chile. We described features of Chilean interpersonal arguing among university students, compared those results with others obtained in the United States, and also compared the associations among variables from country to country. Chilean men displayed more aggressive and self-oriented arguing profiles than Chilean women. Compared to U.S. Americans, Chileans were more motivated to argue and saw the practice of arguing as more cooperative and civil. Many results and correlational patterns were recognizable from one nation to the other, but some differences deserve notice. For example, several measures that are routinely seen as opposites in the U.S. (e.g., impulses to approach or avoid arguing) have only modest negative correlations in the Chilean data.
13 August 2015 in Íkala, Revista de Lenguaje y Cultura