Whereas a B cell–transcriptional profile has been recorded for operationally tolerant kidney graft patients, the role that B cells have in this tolerance has not been reported. In this study, we analyzed the role of B cells from operationally tolerant patients, healthy volunteers, and kidney transplant recipients with stable graft function on T cell suppression. Proliferation, apoptosis, and type I proinflammatory cytokine production by effector CD4⁺CD25⁻ T cells were measured after anti-CD3/anti-CD28 stimulation with or without autologous B cells. We report that B cells inhibit CD4⁺CD25⁻ effector T cell response in a dose-dependent manner. This effect required B cells to interact with T-cell targets and was achieved through a granzyme B (GzmB)–dependent pathway. Tolerant recipients harbored a higher number of B cells expressing GzmB and displaying a plasma cell phenotype. Finally, GzmB⁺ B-cell number was dependent on IL-21 production, and B cells from tolerant recipients but not from other patients positively regulated both the number of IL-21⁺ T cells and IL-21 production, suggesting a feedback loop in tolerant recipients that increases excessive B cell activation and allows regulation to take place. These data provide insights into the characterization of B cell–mediated immunoregulation in clinical tolerance and show a potential regulatory effect of B cells on effector T cells in blood from patients with operationally tolerant kidney grafts.

The role of Foxp3⁺ regulatory T cells (Tregs) in operational tolerance remains elusive, as initial results revealed an increased frequency of this subset in tolerant patients but no functional differences compared with immunosuppressed recipients. In addition, recent studies of regulatory B cells strongly suggest that Tregs may not have a central role in kidney transplantation tolerance. However, recent investigations of the crucial role of Foxp3 demethylation in Treg function and the possibility of identifying distinct Foxp3 T cell subsets prompted us to more thoroughly characterize Tregs in operationally tolerant patients. Thus, we studied the level of demethylation of the Foxp3 Treg-specific demethylated region (TSDR) in circulating CD4⁺ T cells and analyzed Treg subset frequency in tolerant patients, healthy volunteers, patients with stable graft function under immunosuppression, and chronically rejecting recipients. We observed a higher proportion of CD4⁺ T cells with demethylated Foxp3 and a specific expansion of CD4⁺ CD45RA⁻ Foxp3^hi memory Tregs exclusively in tolerant patients. The memory Tregs of tolerant recipients exhibited increased Foxp3 TSDR demethylation, expressed higher levels of CD39 and glucocorticoid-induced TNF-related receptor, and harbored greater suppressive properties than memory Tregs from patients with stable graft function. Taken together, our data demonstrate that operationally tolerant patients mobilize an array of potentially suppressive cells, including not only regulatory B cells but also Tregs. Our results also indicate that tolerant patients have potent CD4⁺CD45RA⁻ Foxp3^hi memory Tregs with a specific Foxp3 TSDR demethylation pattern, which may contribute to the maintenance of graft tolerance.

Diagnosis of the specific cause of late allograft injury is necessary if more personalized and efficient immunosuppressive regimens are to be introduced. This study sought previously unrecognized biomarkers for specific histologic diagnoses of late graft scarring by comparison of gene sets from published microarray studies. Tribbles-1 (TRIB1), a human homolog of Drosophila tribbles, was identified to be a potentially informative biomarker. For testing this, mRNA expression in 76 graft biopsies, 71 blood samples, and 11 urine samples were profiled from independent cohorts of renal transplant patients with different histologic diagnoses recruited at two European centers. TRIB1 but not TRIB2 or TRIB3 was found to be a potential blood and tissue biomarker of chronic antibody-mediated rejection, an active immune-mediated form of chronic allograft failure associated with a poor prognosis. TRIB1 mRNA levels in peripheral blood mononuclear cells discriminated patients with chronic antibody-mediated rejection from those with other types of late allograft injury with high sensitivity and specificity. TRIB1 was also upregulated in a rodent model of chronic cardiac vasculopathy, suggesting that this biomarker may be useful in other solid-organ transplants and across species. It was determined that TRIB1 is expressed primarily by antigen-presenting cells and activated endothelial cells. Overall, these data support the potential use of TRIB1 as a biomarker of chronic antibody-mediated allograft failure.

Long-term renal transplant outcome is limited by side effects of immunosuppressive drugs, particularly calcineurin inhibitor (CNI). We assumed that some patients selected for a "low immunological risk of rejection" could be eligible and benefit from a CNI weaning strategy. We designed a prospective, randomized, multicenter, double-blind placebo-controlled clinical study (Eudract: 2010-019574-33) to analyze the benefit-risk ratio of tacrolimus weaning on highly selected patients (≥4 years of transplantation, normal histology, stable graft function, no anti-HLA immunization). The primary endpoint was improvement of renal function. Fifty-two patients were scheduled in each treatment arm, placebo compared to the CNI maintenance arm. Only 10 patients were eligible and randomized. Five patients were assigned to the placebo arm and five were assigned to the tacrolimus maintenance arm. In the tacrolimus maintenance arm, all patients maintained stable graft function and no immunological events occurred. Contrastingly, in the placebo arm, all five patients had to reintroduce a full dose of tacrolimus since three of them presented an acute rejection episode (one humoral, one mixed, and one borderline) and two displayed anti-HLA antibodies without histological lesion (one donor-specific antibodies [DSA] and one non-DSA). Clearly, tacrolimus withdrawal must be avoided even in long-term highly selective stable kidney recipients.

Deciphering the mechanisms of tolerance and chronic rejection (CR) remains a major goal in transplantation. Data in rodents suggest that Toll-like receptors (TLR), regulators of innate immune responses, play a role in determining graft outcome. However, few studies have focused on TLR expression in human kidney transplant recipients. Here, we analyzed the expression of TLR4 in peripheral blood mononuclear cells from kidney recipients with contrasted clinical situations: operational tolerance and CR, compared with patients with stable graft function, nontransplant patients with renal failure and healthy volunteers. We report that myeloid differentiation factor 88 and TLR4 are significantly contrasted in the peripheral blood mononuclear cells, and in particular in monocytes, of patients with CR versus operational tolerance. Chronic rejection patients have significantly increased TLR4 and myeloid differentiation factor 88 compared with operationally tolerant patients, who resemble healthy volunteers and nontransplant patients with renal failure. Interestingly, analysis of TLR4 transcripts in graft biopsies from patients with normal histology or CR reflected the blood findings, with a significant increase of TLR4 in CR. These data support a link between TLR4 expression and long-term graft outcome. Moreover, whereas absence of TLR signaling may be a feature of tolerance, increased TLR4 signaling may be implicated in CR.