Diatom identification and counting by light microscopy of permanently embedded acid-cleaned silicate shells (frustules) is a fundamental method in ecological and water quality investigations. Here we present a new variant of this method based on “digital virtual slides”, and compare it to the traditional, non-digitized light microscopy workflow on freshwater samples. We analysed three replicate slides taken from six benthic samples using two methods: (1) working directly on a light microscope (the “traditional” counting method), and (2) preparing “virtual digital slides” by high-resolution slide scanning and subsequently identifying and labelling individual valves or frustules using a web browser-based image annotation platform (the digital method). Both methods led to comparable results in terms of species richness, diatom indices and diatom community composition. Although counting by digital microscopy was slightly more time consuming, our experience points out that the digital workflow can not only improve the transparency and reusability of diatom counts but it can also increase taxonomic precision. The introduced digital workflow can also be applied for taxonomic inter-expert calibration through the web, and for producing training image sets for deep-learning-based diatom identification, making it a promising and versatile alternative or extension to traditional light microscopic diatom analyses in the future.
Diatoms represent one of the morphologically and taxonomically most diverse groups of microscopic eukaryotes. Light microscopy-based taxonomic identification and enumeration of frustules, the silica shells of these microalgae, is broadly used in aquatic ecology and biomonitoring. One key step in emerging digital variants of such investigations is segmentation, a task that has been addressed before, but usually in manually captured megapixel-sized images of individual diatom cells with a mostly clean background. In this paper, we applied deep learning-based segmentation methods to gigapixel-sized, high-resolution scans of diatom slides with a realistically cluttered background. This setup requires large slide scans to be subdivided into small images (tiles) to apply a segmentation model to them. This subdivision (tiling), when done using a sliding window approach, often leads to cropping relevant objects at the boundaries of individual tiles. We hypothesized that in the case of diatom analysis, reducing the amount of such cropped objects in the training data can improve segmentation performance by allowing for a better discrimination of relevant, intact frustules or valves from small diatom fragments, which are considered irrelevant when counting diatoms. We tested this hypothesis by comparing a standard sliding window / fixed-stride tiling approach with two new approaches we term object-based tile positioning with and without object integrity constraint. With all three tiling approaches, we trained Mask-R-CNN and U-Net models with different amounts of training data and compared their performance. Object-based tiling with object integrity constraint led to an improvement in pixel-based precision by 12–17 percentage points without substantially impairing recall when compared with standard sliding window tiling. We thus propose that training segmentation models with object-based tiling schemes can improve diatom segmentation from large gigapixel-sized images but could potentially also be relevant for other image domains.
The marine waters around the South Shetland Islands are paramount in the primary production of this Antarctic ecosystem. With the increasing effects of climate change and the annual retreat of the ice shelf, the importance of macroalgae and their diatom epiphytes in primary production also increases. The relationships and interactions between these organisms have scarcely been studied in Antarctica, and even less in the volcanic ecosystem of Deception Island, which can be seen as a natural proxy of climate change in Antarctica because of its vulcanism, and the open marine system of Livingston Island. In this study we investigated the composition of the diatom communities in the context of their macroalgal hosts and different environmental factors. We used a non-acidic method for diatom digestion, followed by slidescanning and diatom identification by manual annotation through a web-browser-based image annotation platform. Epiphytic diatom species richness was higher on Deception Island as a whole, whereas individual macroalgal specimens harboured richer diatom assemblages on Livingston Island. We hypothesize this a possible result of a higher diversity of ecological niches in the unique volcanic environment of Deception Island. Overall, our study revealed higher species richness and diversity than previous studies of macroalgae-inhabiting diatoms in Antarctica, which could however be the result of the different preparation methodologies used in the different studies, rather than an indication of a higher species richness on Deception Island and Livingston Island than other Antarctic localities.
Background: Diatoms are microalgae with finely ornamented microscopic silica shells. Their taxonomic identification by light microscopy is routinely used as part of community ecological research as well as ecological status assessment of aquatic ecosystems, and a need for digitalization of these methods has long been recognized. Alongside their high taxonomic and morphological diversity, several other factors make diatoms highly challenging for deep learning–based identification using light microscopy images. These include (i) an unusually high intraclass variability combined with small between-class differences, (ii) a rather different visual appearance of specimens depending on their orientation on the microscope slide, and (iii) the limited availability of diatom experts for accurate taxonomic annotation.Findings: We present the largest diatom image dataset thus far, aimed at facilitating the application and benchmarking of innovative deep learning methods to the diatom identification problem on realistic research data, “UDE DIATOMS in the Wild 2024.” The dataset contains 83,570 images of 611 diatom taxa, 101 of which are represented by at least 100 examples and 144 by at least 50 examples each. We showcase this dataset in 2 innovative analyses that address individual aspects of the above challenges using subclustering to deal with visually heterogeneous classes, out-of-distribution sample detection, and semi-supervised learning.Conclusions: The problem of image-based identification of diatoms is both important for environmental research and challenging from the machine learning perspective. By making available the so far largest image dataset, accompanied by innovative analyses, this contribution will facilitate addressing these points by the scientific community.
It has been shown that size of planktonic diatoms responds to changes in water chemistry, but little is known about the influence of different types of environmental factors upon benthic diatom size variation. Here we ask whether water chemistry or hydromorphological influences show a stronger effect on benthic diatom morphometry. 10,624 diatom valves / frustules were imaged, identified and measured from 48 samples across eight sites in the Ebro river basin obtained during ten years of biomonitoring work. We analysed how differences in surface-to-volume (S/V) ratio and other morphometric characteristics were related to spatial and temporal variability in environmental parameters. Our results show that both hydrological and physicochemical variables generated significant responses in interspecific and intraspecific morphometric variation. S/V ratio and transapical width showed the strongest responses, followed by (the predominantly used) cell volume. Freshwater benthic diatom morphology seems to respond to diverse environmental factors and could provide complementary ecological information to community composition.