This paper delves into the emotional landscape of researchers engaged in participatory design and action research. It addresses the less-discussed aspects of unwanted emotions, such as guilt and shame, experienced by researchers during and post-project. The paper explores the guilty dichotomy between the researchers' intent to contribute positively and the reality of unmet expectations. The unease stemming from perceived exploitation and the limitations of project impact is scrutinised, highlighting the tightrope walked in participatory design. Furthermore, the paper discusses the paradox of professional recognition versus the ongoing adversities faced by what may be marginalised communities. Through reflective analysis, this paper contributes to a deeper understanding of the emotional landscape traversed by researchers in participatory design and action research. It underscores the need for supportive frameworks that address these emotional aspects, advocating for ethical reflexivity and sustained engagement strategies that align closely with community needs and well-being.
Participatory Design (PD) aims for inclusivity, but the level of inclusion varies widely. Inclusion often means integrating stakeholder perspectives into design processes, often neglecting bi-directionality, where communities also have agendas. True collaboration rests on mutual understanding, acknowledging the dynamic nature of community collaboration and the holistic impact of shaping relationships. This workshop will explore collaboration challenges and practices with marginalized communities. It will draw on the organisers’ extensive experiences with diverse groups, including nomadic and resettled indigenous communities in Namibia, Rohingya refugees in Bangladesh, and Syrian war refugees in Jordan. The workshop encourages sharing and reflecting on experiences with marginalized communities, welcoming contributions from participants to enrich discussions and enhance collective understanding of collaborative practices.
This paper offers an exploration of everyday life during the Covid-19 pandemic in Bangladesh with a focus on how it has been reordered through commonplace digital technologies and services. We present findings from a qualitative field study. Themes emerging from the findings suggest that digital technologies have been important to the reordering of everyday life during the pandemic: videoconferencing have been instrumental in allowing urban residents to work from home, digital money has enabled workers in rural areas to continue financial transactions, and social media has been a source of news and rumours during the pandemic. However, the benefits of the digital reordering of everyday life are unevenly distributed. The themes emerging are used to frame a discussion of the notion of reordering compared to the concept of resilience within ICTD.
This article focuses on the ways that technological initiatives aimed at contributing to the sustainability of human lives in Dhaka, Bangladesh, are coupled to social, economic and environmental issues that at best have no easy solution, and at worst leads initiatives to worsen one issue as they try to solve another. With a starting point in ethnographic observations made during a research visit in July 2023, we present how such initiatives and their underlying visions of technological transformations operate in relation to the contemporary vagaries of an international capitalism, which itself is sustained by a faith in technological solutions. Our observations lead us to pay attention to how both the vulnerabilities to the hazards exacerbated by climate change, and the alleged technological solutions to mitigate these hazards, are tied up in social inequalities related to income, class and consumption, but also how they are coupled or decoupled from populations in the Global North, whose purchases sustain local economies in Bangladesh. Namely, discussions of the way that new technological transformations impact upon the environment, or the climate, or sustainability more generally, often take a starting point in the processes of digitalisation taking place in the Global North, where the solutions to climate change are often assumed by mainstream political and industrial actors to be technological and often digital. This article thus aims – through the deployment of ethnographic sensitivity – to shift the digitally focused gaze to a reiteration of the bigger question of how capitalism is multifariously involved in climate change and sustainability more broadly through technological means.