Radicular pain is characterized by radiating buttock and leg pain in a lumbar nerve root distribution, which may be accompanied by neurosensory and motor deficits. Radicular pain caused by lumbar disc herniation improves in most patients with conservative treatment only. Yet, 1 in 5 individuals will experience persistent symptoms and/or neurological deficit
1,2 such that lumbar discectomy may be indicated to surgically remove the herniated disc material. Recurrent herniation occurs in 7% to 18% of patients following discectomy
3-5 and a large defect in the annulus fibrosus after surgery is a major risk factor for reherniation.
6 In a meta-analysis involving more than 1600 patients undergoing lumbar discectomy, the risk of symptom recurrence (odds ratio, 2.5;
P = .004) and reoperation (odds ratio, 2.3;
P < .001) was higher in patients with large vs small annular defects.
6 Reoperations for lumbar disc herniation are more costly,
4 less effective,
7,8 and are associated with higher risk of disability
9 than primary procedures. Therefore, intraoperative strategies intended to close or occlude large annular defects may lower the clinical and economic burden related to surgery for recurrent herniation. This randomized clinical trial evaluated the 5-year clinical and radiographic outcomes of patients with large annular defects after lumbar microdiscectomy treated with or without a bone-anchored annular closure device.