Mathematical modelling enjoys affirmed relevance in educational curricula worldwide, and teacher education programs consider that this process should also be experienced during educational internships. The interest of this study focuses on the argumentation of a prospective teacher to justify the incorporation (or not) of mathematical modelling in his lessons. To do this, we analyzed the reflection of a prospective mathematics teacher on the design of a modelling task during his educational internship. Methodologically, it is a case study in which, based on the didactic suitability criteria tool, the study subject structured the reflection on his educational internship in his master’s degree final project (MFP), whose central axis was modelling. We collected data from video recordings of group reflection sessions with the study subject and other prospective teachers of a professionalizing master’s program, and from the analysis of his MFP. The results evidenced the prospective teacher’s arguments to justify the design of a modelling task, his knowledge, and his beliefs about this process, among other aspects. We conclude that the specialized knowledge that is inferred from this argumentation is of different types and is part of a conglomerate formed, in addition, by values, beliefs, and guidelines for action.
23 June 2025 in International Journal of Science and Mathematics Education
Delving into teaching reflection on practice and the underlying argumentation are key aspects for teacher professional development. Our interest in this study is focused on the role played by the Didactic Suitability Criteria in the analysis of the practical argumentation of a group of teachers during their reflection on a mathematical teaching and learning process. Methodologically, it is a case study conducted in a training course to foster teacher reflection involving eight Brazilian practising mathematics teachers who designed, implemented, and redesigned a lesson with the Pythagorean theorem. In this article, we analysed the practical argumentation emerging from teaching reflection, for which we proposed an adaptation of Toulmin’s model incorporating the Didactic Suitability Criteria construct to structure and represent the emerging practical arguments, and whose use was exemplified in two episodes of practical argumentation. The main result is that Didactic Suitability Criteria allowed us to: (a) reinterpret the dialogues that contained the participating teachers’ practical argumentation, in terms of some of the criteria, components, and indicators of this construct; (b) infer the participating teachers’ beliefs and values in their proposals of actions; and (c) nuance the relationship between the warrant and the action of each practical argument for the choice of certain actions in decision-making.
O artigo tem como objetivo analisar quais são os critérios de adequação didática emergentes na argumentação prática de futuros pedagogos, participantes de um ciclo de Lesson Study, ao planejarem uma aula sobre geometria plana para alunos da Educação Infantil. As sessões do ciclo foram vídeo-gravadas e duas delas foram analisadas, primeiro, com os modelos da Pragma-dialética e de Toulmin e, segundo, com os critérios de adequação didática. Como resultado, observa-se que os argumentos práticos dos futuros pedagogos para a escolha do material manipulativo a ser utilizado apontam para o uso de blocos lógicos e que os critérios que o sustentam baseiam-se, em maior medida, no de meios, seguido do epistêmico. Também, observa-se que o consenso dos participantes sobre a dinâmica da aula é que ela deveria partir da exploração dos blocos lógicos, seguido da produção, registro e exposição de obras de arte e que os critérios que sustentam tal tomada de decisão relacionam-se, respectivamente, com os de interação, ecológico e afetivo. Conclui-se que este estudo fornece uma ferramenta que permite mostrar, com detalhe, a estrutura dos argumentos práticos e o importante papel dos critérios de adequação didática na tomada de decisões didáticas de um coletivo de futuros professores.
19 September 2025 in Educação Matemática em Revista - RS
The aim of this study is to identify the practical arguments of a group of teachers participating in a Lesson Study cycle as they reflect on students’ difficulties related to volume capacity and the comparison of measurement units, and to relate these arguments to the Didactic Suitability Criteria. Methodologically, to identify the participants’ practical arguments, one recorded session from the cycle was analyzed using Toulmin’s model, followed by an analysis based on the Didactic Suitability Criteria. The analysis reveals eight difficulties and seven practical arguments, each of which is linked to a specific type of student difficulty. Among the criteria, the epistemic one is the most closely related to these practical arguments. The study concludes that fostering practical argumentation in teachers’ reflections during Lesson Study cycles is essential.
This article studies practical argumentation in the context of designing application problems and transforming them into modelling problems. To this end, the practical arguments developed by prospective primary education teachers were analysed, using a scheme for structuring and representing these arguments and a modelling cycle for representing the solution plans proposed to these problems. This is a case study with three groups of prospective teachers who were taking a course on mathematical reasoning and activity in primary education, where problem solving and mathematical modelling were the two most relevant topics. For data collection, a questionnaire was applied to and an interview was conducted with the study subjects, thus identifying nine episodes of practical argumentation based on the justification of their pedagogical decisions made on the design and transformation of problems. Also, the written reports prepared by the study subjects were reviewed to analyse their solution plans proposed to the problems. The results showed that the study subjects developed practical arguments to justify the design of motivating learning situations and problems for students in realistic contexts close to their environment and the transformation of application problems into modelling problems by eliminating data from their statements and formulating an open-ended question.
[Objective] The objective of this study was to analyze the practical arguments of a group of mathematics teacher educators during the assessment of the design of a didactic unit on functions for secondary education students (ages 15-16). [Methodology] A qualitative methodology was employed, consisting of an intrinsic case study that involved eight mathematics teacher educators with knowledge of the Didactic Suitability Criteria construct, who participated in a Lesson Study cycle. In the reflection stage of this cycle, participants used this construct to assess the design of the didactic unit (which included the teacher’s planning and the students’ dossier). The emerging practical arguments were structured using Toulmin’s model. [Results] Three results are highlighted. First, the assessment of the didactic unit using the components of the Didactic Suitability Criteria made it possible to identify strengths and areas for improvement within the teaching and learning process of functions. Second, the participants utilized these components as data, backups, and validation in their practical arguments, leveraging their knowledge of this construct. Third, the participants employed all these components to assess the didactic unit and supported their proposals for change based on these components. [Conclusion] The Didactic Suitability Criteria played a role as a generator of practical argumentation for the participants and as a central element in structuring these arguments. Finally, some recommendations are proposed for the implementation of future Lesson Study cycles.