This study analyzes the economic system dynamics of investment in real estate from mainly four participants in China. Local governments limit the supply of commercial and residential land to raise fiscal revenue, and expand debts by land mortgage to develop industrial zones and parks. Led by local government, banks and real estate development enterprises forge a coalition on real estate investment and facilitate real estate price appreciation. The above theoretical model is empirically evidenced with VAR (Vector Auto Regression) methodology. A panel VAR model shows that land leasing and real estate price appreciation positively affect local government general fiscal revenue. Additional VAR models find that bank credit in addition to private and foreign funds respectively have strong positive dynamic effects on housing prices. Housing prices also have a strong positive impact on speculation from private funds and hot money.
24 October 2023 in Environmental Science and Pollution Research
The regional systemic financial risks driven by escalating urban housing prices have been of great concern recently. Based on the theoretical analyses on the mechanism of formation of regional systemic financial risk driven by urban housing price fluctuations, this paper builds panel spatial economic models to empirically analyze the relationship between urban housing price fluctuations and regional systemic financial risks, in addition to their spatial linkages, in 13 cities in Jiangsu, a representative province of China. The empirical results show the following. (1) The excessive investment or speculation of local governments, banks, real estate developers, individuals, and families on the housing market stimulate the escalation in urban housing prices, leading to the systemic financial risks; (2) Urban housing prices and the land supply price of local governments have strong spatial contagion effects among cities, which will diffuse risks to adjacent cities, causing regional systemic financial risk; (3) Compared with North Jiangsu, South Jiangsu has more serious investment expansion from real estate developers and stronger spatial contagion effects, suggesting the existence of heavier regional systemic financial risks derived from housing price fluctuations; (4) North Jiangsu has slightly stronger “imitative behavior” among local governments, and fewer “substitution effects” of central cities’ demand to adjacent cities’ demand than does South Jiangsu.
Employing the fundamental value of real estate determined by the economic fundamentals, a measurement model for real estate bubble size is established based on the panel data analysis. Using this model, real estate bubble sizes in various regions in Japan in the late 1980s and in recent China are examined. Two panel models for Japan provide results, which are consistent with the reality in the 1980s where a commercial land price bubble appeared in most area and was much larger than that of residential land. This provides evidence of the reliability of our model, overcoming the limit of existing literature with this method. The same models for housing prices in China at both the provincial and city levels show that contrary to the concern of serious housing price bubble in China, over-valuing in recent China is much smaller than that in 1980s Japan.
The real estate prices in urban China have been soaring sharply since the commercialization reform of the housing market in 1998, but have suffered from downward pressure recently. In addition to the peculiarities of the state-owned land system, newly built houses dominate market across the vast territories of China, and this study of China will further the understanding of the financial real estate risks. Based on theoretical analyses, a spatial Durbin model is adopted to evaluate the financial real estate risks based on various sectors’ participation in the real estate market, because it can overcome the biased results brought about by the omission of possible spatial dependence. The results show the following: (1) the four sectors’ participation in the real estate market promotes the rise of real estate prices in the both local and other cities with spatial contagion effects, while the most important factors are different across regions; (2) the real estate price fluctuations, the local government’s land revenue, the bank credit provided to the real estate industry, the demand in the local city, and the real estate developers’ investments in other cities increase the local financial real estate risks, and there are strong spatial diffusion effects among the cities. This study sheds light on the roles of the various sectors’ participation in promoting the financial real estate risk as well as their spatial interactions from both theoretical and empirical aspects. Particularly, the different roles of local governments and real estate developers in China should be highlighted. The rules on the sector and spatial levels suggest that government policy should take the different features of various sectors and regions and spatial connections into account.