Introduction: The food environment influences the availability and affordability of food options for consumers in a given neighborhood. However, disparities in access to healthy food options exist, affecting Black and low-income communities disproportionately. This study investigated whether racial segregation predicted the spatial distribution of supermarkets and grocery stores better than socioeconomic factors or vice versa in Cleveland, Ohio. Method: The outcome measure was the count of supermarket and grocery stores in each census tract in Cleveland. They were combined with US census bureau data as covariates. We fitted four Bayesian spatial models. The first model was a baseline model with no covariates. The second model accounted for racial segregation alone. The third model looked at only socioeconomic factors, and the final model combined both racial and socioeconomic factors. Results: Overall model performance was better in the model that considered only racial segregation as a predictor of supermarkets and grocery stores (DIC = 476.29). There was 13% decrease in the number of stores for a census tract with a higher majority of Black people compared to areas with a lower number of Black people. Model 3 that considered only socioeconomic factors was less predictive of the retail outlets (DIC = 484.80). Conclusions: These findings lead to the conclusion that structural racism evidenced in policies like residential segregation has a significant influence on the spatial distribution of food retail in the city of Cleveland.
Effective governance requires timely and reliable small area population counts. Geospatial modelling approaches which utilise bespoke microcensus surveys and satellite-derived settlement maps and other spatial datasets have been developed to fill population data gaps in countries where censuses are outdated and incomplete. However, logistics and costs of microcensus surveys and tree canopy or cloud cover obscuring settlements in satellite images limit its wider applications in tropical rural settings. Here, we present a two-step Bayesian hierarchical modelling approach that can integrate routinely collected health intervention campaign data and partially observed settlement data to produce reliable small area population estimates. Reductions in relative error rates were 32–73% in a simulation study, and ~32% when applied to malaria survey data in Papua New Guinea. The results highlight the value of demographic data routinely collected through health intervention campaigns or household surveys for improving small area population estimates, and how biases introduced by satellite data limitations can be overcome.
Statistical modelling approaches which produce fine spatial resolution population estimates have been developed to fill data gaps in resource-poor countries where census data are either outdated or incomplete. These population modelling methods often draw upon recent georeferenced sample population enumeration datasets to predict population density and distribution at both sampled and non-sampled locations, based on their correlation with a set of carefully selected geospatial covariates. These modelled population estimates are increasingly used to support governance, health surveillance, equitable resource allocation, and humanitarian response. However, methodological challenges remain. For example, the georeferenced sample enumeration data are usually disparate and patchy in their distributions, with a high proportion of non-sampled locations that result in highly uncertain estimates. Here, we present a model-based Bayesian geostatistical small area population estimation approach which simultaneously · Combines multiple sample population enumeration datasets and· Explicitly integrates spatial autocorrelation within a single modelling framework. Findings from a simulation study show varying levels of accuracy in the posterior parameter estimates over different levels of spatial variance and data missingness. The methodology, which was further validated using five nationally representative household listing datasets in Cameroon, provides a valuable methodological development in small area population estimation modelling from sparsely distributed sample enumeration data.
Background: The COVID-19 pandemic led to widespread economic disruptions, with government-imposed restrictions and lockdowns significantly affecting livelihoods globally. Burkina Faso, a country with pre-existing vulnerabilities in food security, experienced considerable challenges during this period. The aim of this study was to examine how COVID-19-related income losses is associated with self-reported food insecurity among women in Burkina Faso in 2020. The study also examined whether there was an increase in self-reported food insecurity among women during the COVID-19 restrictions compared with the pre-pandemic era. Methods: We conducted a cross-sectional analysis using data from the Performance Monitoring for Action (PMA) female survey, which included 3,499 women from Burkina Faso. This study examined the associations between socioeconomic variables, such as age, education, household income loss, and food insecurity. We conducted two analyses using logistic regression. The first analysis focused on self-reported food insecurity and its association with the socioeconomic variables, and the second analysis focused on whether there was an increase in self-reported food insecurity compared with pre-pandemic levels and its association with the socioeconomic factors. We controlled for relevant confounders in the analysis and presented the results as adjusted odds ratios (AORs) with 95% confidence intervals (CIs). Results: Our findings indicated that 16.97% of women reported experiencing food insecurity during the pandemic period. Compared with women with no income loss, women who experienced partial household income loss were 1.82 times (95% CI: 0.98–3.38) more likely to report food insecurity, whereas those who experienced complete income loss were 5.16 times (95% CI: 2.28–9.43) more likely to report food insecurity. The study, however, did not find a statistically significant increase in self-reported food insecurity due to COVID-19 restrictions compared with pre-pandemic levels. Conclusions: This study demonstrated that income loss due to COVID-19 restrictions profoundly affected women’s food security in Burkina Faso. The significant associations between income loss and increased food insecurity underscore the need for targeted interventions and safety nets to support women during public health crises.
Recently, there has been a growing interest in the production of high-resolution maps of vaccination coverage. These maps have been useful for uncovering geographic inequities in coverage and improving targeting of interventions to reach marginalized populations. Different methodological approaches have been developed for producing these maps using mostly geolocated household survey data and geospatial covariate information. However, it remains unclear how much the predicted coverage maps produced by the various methods differ, and which methods yield more reliable estimates. Here, we explore the predictive performance of these methods and resulting implications for spatial prioritization to fill this gap. Using Nigeria Demographic and Health Survey as a case study, we generate 1x1 km and district level maps of indicators of vaccination coverage using geostatistical, machine learning (ML) and hybrid methods and evaluate predictive performance via cross-validation. Our results show similar predictive performance for five of the seven methods investigated, although two geostatistical approaches are the best methods. The worst-performing methods are two ML approaches. We find marked differences in spatial prioritization using these methods, which could potentially result in missing important underserved populations, although broad similarities exist. Our study can help guide map production for other health and development metrics.