Automatic Speech Recognition and Understanding (ASRU) systems can generally use temporal and situational context information to improve their performance for a given task. This is typically done by rescoring the ASR hypotheses or by dynamically adapting the ASR models. For some domains, such as Air Traffic Control (ATC), this context information can be, however, small in size, partial and available only as abstract concepts (e.g. airline codes), which are difficult to map into full possible spoken sentences to perform rescoring or adaptation. This paper presents a multi-modal ASRU system, which dynamically integrates partial temporal and situational ATC context information to improve its performance. This is done either by 1) extracting word sequences which carry relevant ATC information from ASR N-best Lists and then perform a context-based rescoring on the extracted ATC segments or 2) by a partial adaptation of the language model. Experiments conducted on 4 hours of test data from Prague and Vienna approach (arrivals) showed a relative reduction of the ATC command error rate metric by 30% to 50%.
As researchers around the globe develop applications for the use of Automatic Speech Recognition and Understanding (ASRU) in the Air Traffic Management (ATM) domain, Air Traffic Control (ATC) language ontologies will play a critical role in enabling research collaboration. The MITRE Corporation (MITRE) and the German Aerospace Center (DLR), having independently developed ATC language ontologies for specific applications, recently compared these ontologies to identify opportunities for improvement and harmonization. This paper extends the topic in two ways. First, this paper describes the specific ways in which ontologies facilitate the sharing of and collaboration on data, models, algorithms, metrics, and applications in the ATM domain. Second, this paper provides comparative analysis of word frequencies in ATC speech in the United States and Europe to illustrate that, whereas methods and tools for evaluating ASRU applications can be shared across researchers, the specific models would not work well between regions due to differences in the underlying corpus data.
This paper describes the safety assessment conducted in SESAR2020 project PJ.10-W2-96 ASR on automatic speech recognition (ASR) technology implemented for air traffic control (ATC) centers. ASR already now enables the automatic recognition of aircraft callsigns and various ATC commands including command types based on controller–pilot voice communications for presentation at the controller working position. The presented safety assessment process consists of defining design requirements for ASR technology application in normal, abnormal, and degraded modes of ATC operations. A total of eight functional hazards were identified based on the analysis of four use cases. The safety assessment was supported by top-down and bottom-up modelling and analysis of the causes of hazards to derive system design requirements for the purposes of mitigating the hazards. Assessment of achieving the specified design requirements was supported by evidence generated from two real-time simulations with pre-industrial ASR prototypes in approach and en-route operational environments. The simulations, focusing especially on the safety aspects of ASR application, also validated the hypotheses that ASR reduces controllers’ workload and increases situational awareness. The missing validation element, i.e., an analysis of the safety effects of ASR in ATC, is the focus of this paper. As a result of the safety assessment activities, mitigations were derived for each hazard, demonstrating that the use of ASR does not increase safety risks and is, therefore, ready for industrialization.
Automatic speech recognition and understanding (ASRU) for air traffic control (ATC) has been investigated in different ATC environments and applications. The objective of this study was to quantify the effect of ASRU support for air traffic controllers (ATCos) radar label maintenance in terms of safety and human performance. Therefore, an implemented ASRU system was validated within a human-in-the-loop environment by ATCos in different traffic-density scenarios. In the baseline condition, ATCos performed radar label maintenance by entering verbally instructed ATC commands with a mouse and keyboard. In the proposed solution, ATCos were supported by ASRU, which achieved a command recognition rate of 92.5% with a command error rate of 2.4%. ASRU support reduced the number of wrong or missing inputs from ATCos into the radar label by a factor of two, which contemporaneously improved their situational awareness. Furthermore, ATCos where able to perform more successful secondary tasks when using ASRU support, indicating a greater capacity to handle unexpected events. The results from NASA TLX showed that the perceived workload decreased with a statistical significance of 4.3% across all scenarios. In conclusion, this study provides evidence that using ASRU for radar label maintenance can significantly reduce workload and improve flight safety.
The information air traffic controllers (ATCos) communicate via radio telephony is valuable for digital assistants to provide additional safety. Yet, ATCos have to enter this information manually. Assistant-based speech recognition (ABSR) has proven to be a lightweight technology that automatically extracts and successfully feeds the content of ATC communication into digital systems without additional human effort. This article explains how ABSR can be integrated into an advanced surface movement guidance and control system (A-SMGCS). The described validations were performed in the complex apron simulation training environment of Frankfurt Airport with 14 apron controllers in a human-in-the-loop simulation in summer 2022. The integration significantly reduces the workload of controllers and increases safety as well as overall performance. Based on a word error rate of 3.1%, the command recognition rate was 91.8% with a callsign recognition rate of 97.4%. This performance was enabled by the integration of A-SMGCS and ABSR: the command recognition rate improves by more than 15% absolute by considering A-SMGCS data in ABSR.