Benjamyn Scott

Dr. Benjamyn Scott

International Institute of Air and Space Law, Leiden University, 2311 ES Leiden, The Netherlands

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

12Years (2015-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
11 January 2025 in AI & SOCIETY
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
BCBart Custers
Bart Custers
HLHenning Lahmann
Henning Lahmann
Benjamyn ScottBenjamyn Scott
Benjamyn Scott
Complex technologies such as Artificial Intelligence (AI) can cause harm, raising the question of who is liable for the harm caused. Research has identified multiple liability gaps (i.e., unsatisfactory outcomes when applying existing liability rules) in legal frameworks. In this paper, the concepts of shared responsibilities and fiduciary duties are explored as avenues to address liability gaps. The development, deployment and use of complex technologies are not clearly distinguishable stages, as often suggested, but are processes of cooperation and co-creation. At the intersections of these stages, shared responsibilities and fiduciary duties of multiple actors can be observed. Although none of the actors have complete control or a complete overview, many actors have some control or influence, and, therefore, responsibilities based on fault, prevention or benefit. Shared responsibilities and fiduciary duties can turn liability gaps into liability overlaps. These concepts could be implemented in tort and contract law by amending existing law (e.g., by assuming that all stakeholders are liable unless they can prove they did not owe a duty of care) and by creating more room for partial liability reflecting partial responsibilities (e.g., a responsibility to signal or identify an issue without a corresponding responsibility to solve that issue). This approach better aligns legal liabilities with responsibilities, increases legal certainty, and increases cooperation and understanding between actors, improving the quality and safety of technologies. However, it may not solve all liability gaps, may have chilling effects on innovation, and may require further detailing through case law.

29 July 2022 in Journal of Intelligent & Robotic Systems
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
KAKonstantinos Andritsos
Konstantinos Andritsos
Benjamyn ScottBenjamyn Scott
Benjamyn Scott
ATAndrea Trimarchi
Andrea Trimarchi
As the world’s population increases, new ways of improving transportation systems in, around and between urban areas are being suggested. Early discussions on this have been technology-focused, pointing at the use of Unmanned Aircraft Systems (UAS) for cargo delivery and electrical Vertical Take-Off and Landing (eVTOL) aircraft for passenger transportation. Recently, the term ‘Urban Air Mobility’ has become widely used to encompass these vehicles within a new mobility ecosystem. However, due to deficiencies in this term, other proposals – namely ‘Advanced Air Mobility’, ‘New Air Mobility and ‘Innovative Air Mobility’ – have emerged. The rise in different terms can lead to confusion as their scope is not always fully known or appreciated, and they are often used interchangeably. This paper, therefore, shifts focus from the recent debate about the definition of ‘UAS’ to the aforementioned ecosystem terms so to address and evaluate them as potentially different aspects of the same concept. An interpretive approach of the terms, an assessment of their major characteristics, as well as an analysis of their relationship with the aircraft types will take place. This will show the scope of these terms so that the context can be properly understood and then appropriately applied.

23 February 2024 in Journal of Intelligent & Robotic Systems
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
Benjamyn ScottBenjamyn Scott
Benjamyn Scott
The Paris Olympics and Paralympics are scheduled to take place between 26 July and 8 September 2024, whereby electric vertical take-off and landing aircraft are anticipated to take to the skies to offer a new mobility solution to spectators of the Games. This will allow paying members of the public to move between different points within the Paris region akin to an on-demand taxi service, but through the air; passenger air taxi services (PATS). These passengers, as consumers, will have certain rights and duties under European Union law. To determine the level of protection afforded to these air passengers, a full assessment of Regulation (EC) No 261/2004 is required. As the revision of the Regulation is currently on the European Commission’s agenda, it is also important to consider its revision in light of PATS, whereby new technology, emerging business practices, changing customer behaviour and societal expectations for the level of legal protection of PATS users must be considered. This article will, therefore, assess the current version of the Regulation, in light of the interpretation from the European Court, to see whether it applies to PATS and, if so, whether it is suitable or if specific amendments need to be added to the planned revised Regulation.

1 January 2022 in Journal of Air Law and Commerce
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
Benjamyn ScottBenjamyn Scott
Benjamyn Scott
While aviation has been used in transportation for decades, the use of vertical takeoff and landing (VTOL) aircraft for large- scale, low-cost, green, sustainable, and integrated mobility in populated areas is a new phenomenon. Despite the importance of ground infrastructure for embarkation and disembarkation of passengers, cargo, and mail, questions remain on how these “vertiports” are or should be regulated and how they will relate to existing regulated ground infrastructure such as aerodromes, airports, and heliports. Therefore, several questions arise: what is a vertiport; how do vertiports relate to other aviation infra- structure; what are the legal implications of having different terms; what laws apply to vertiports? This Article seeks to address these questions from a European Union (EU) perspective by looking at the rise of civil VTOL aircraft and the need for vertiports. Following this, the Article analyzes the current and pro- posed legal landscapes in the EU. This analysis shows how vertiports are currently regulated and highlights the steps that still need to be taken. An examination of the different terms that exist and their definitions is also undertaken. This high- lights the similarities and differences that exist between the different terms, thus allowing the relevant laws to be appropriately identified and their scope understood. Finally, the Article looks at some of the legal consequences of introducing the term “vertiport” by focusing on specific EU aviation-based regulations. Thus, this shows the real-life implications of the questions posed.

24 December 2015
Verified
Book Chapter
Closed access
PDF file
PLPablo Mendes de Leon
Pablo Mendes de Leon
Benjamyn ScottBenjamyn Scott
Benjamyn Scott

6 October 2025 in Ethics and Information Technology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
HLHenning Lahmann
Henning Lahmann
BCBart Custers
Bart Custers
Benjamyn ScottBenjamyn Scott
Benjamyn Scott
This article analyses ideas to use AI-supported systems to counter ‘cognitive warfare’ and critically examines the implications of such systems for fundamental rights and values. After explicating the notion of ‘cognitive warfare’ as used in contemporary public security discourse, the article describes the emergence of generative AI tools that are expected to exacerbate the problem of adversarial activities against the online information ecosystems of democratic societies. In response, researchers and policymakers have proposed to utilize AI to devise countermeasures, ranging from AI-based early warning systems to state-run content moderation tools. These interventions, however, interfere, to different degrees, with fundamental rights and values such as privacy, communication rights, and self-determination. This article argues that such proposals insufficiently account for the complexity of contemporary online information ecosystems, particularly the inherent difficulty in establishing causality and attribution. Reliance on the precautionary principle might offer a justificatory frame for AI-enabled measures to counter ‘cognitive warfare’ in the absence of conclusive empirical evidence of harm. However, any such state intervention must be based in law and adhere to strict proportionality.