Significance: Finding that pan-tolerance derives from defects in carbohydrate regulation connects stress-mediated lesions with metabolic change, identifies a stable type of tolerance, and demonstrates a widely shared death response. Manipulation of the response should improve antimicrobial efficacy, preserve beneficial bacteria during antimicrobial use, and protect industrial bacteria from toxic products. Mutations in many genes can interfere with stress-mediated metabolism; thus, mutation to pan-tolerance could be a high-probability event. Finding that selection of tolerance to one lethal stressor confers tolerance to many, if not all, indicates that massive disinfectant consumption potentially undermines antimicrobial efficacy and immune defenses against pathogenic bacteria. Since pan-tolerance is hidden from current surveillance of resistance, the work indicates a need for facile methods to measure tolerance.
3 February 2025 in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
Disinfectants are essential tools for controlling infectious diseases and maintaining sterile conditions in many medical and food-industry settings. Recent work revealed that a deficiency in the carbohydrate phosphotransferase system (PTS) confers pan-tolerance to killing by diverse disinfectant types through its interaction with the cAMP-CRP regulatory network. The present work characterized a pan-tolerance mutant obtained by enrichment using phenol as a lethal probe and an Escherichia coli PTS null mutant as a parental strain. The resulting super-pan-tolerant mutant, which harbored an F158C substitution in PheS, inhibited bacterial killing by multiple disinfectant classes with surprisingly little effect on antimicrobial lethality. The PheS substitution, which was expected to lower substrate recognition efficiency and result in deacylated tRNA phe occupying the ribosomal A site, activated relA expression and synthesis of ppGpp, even in the absence of disinfectant exposure. ppGpp, along with DksA, increased RpoS function by activating promoters of dsrA and iraP , two genes whose products increase the expression and stability of RpoS. Subsequently, RpoS upregulated the expression of genes encoding a universal stress protein (UspB) and an oxidative stress peroxidase (KatE), which preconditioned bacteria to better survive a variety of disinfectants. Disinfectant-mediated accumulation of reactive oxygen species (ROS) and bacterial killing were abolished/reduced by exogenous dimethyl sulfoxide and by a PheS F158C substitution up-regulating genes encoding ROS-detoxifying enzymes ( katE, sodA, oxyR, ahpC ). These data identify a pheS mutation-triggered, ppGpp-stimulated transcriptional regulatory cascade that negates biocide-mediated lethality, thereby tying the stringent response to protection from ROS-mediated biocide lethality.
Bacterial persistence increases therapy duration, disease relapse, and antibiotic resistance. Mechanisms underlying persistence and feasible ways to rapidly eliminate persister cells are largely unknown. The present work examined genetic and environmental perturbations to identify anti-death events occurring in Escherichia coli persister and phenotypically tolerant cells. The quiescent status of hipA7 and metG2 persister cells, which were protected from killing by multiple antibiotics, was insensitive to the presence/absence of exogenous nutrients. In contrast, stationary-phase and nutrient-starved wild-type cultures, which displayed tolerance rather than the subpopulation status of persistence, were readily killed by ciprofloxacin upon restoration of nutrients, thereby indicating that tolerance was phenotypic. Both persistent and tolerant cells suppressed accumulation of reactive oxygen species (ROS), DNA breakage, and global metabolic activity. Restoration of nutrients to stationary-phase cultures restored these three processes for phenotypically tolerant cells but not for persister cells. Cultures of high-frequency-persistent hipA7 and metG2 mutants and low-frequency-persistent wild-type cells were rapidly sterilized by ROS-independent, synergistic membrane disruption using aminoglycoside-polymyxin combinations; rapid eradication occurred at clinically achievable concentrations for both antibiotics. The aminoglycoside-polymyxin combination also killed environmentally tolerant cells but more slowly. The combination killed both laboratory and clinical isolates of gram-negative bacteria, an E. coli ptsI mutant that is pan-tolerant to diverse antibiotics and disinfectants, and E. coli cells in a biofilm model. Moderate lethality was observed with the gram-positive bacterium Staphylococcus aureus . The work indicates that suppression of ROS accumulation is a common feature of persistence and phenotypic tolerance, and it emphasizes ROS-independent strategies for controlling quiescent bacterial populations. IMPORTANCE: The report generalizes the concept that persistence and tolerance involve suppression of toxic metabolites (reactive oxygen species [ROS]). The work also shows that an environmental perturbation (nutrient deprivation) leads to antibiotic tolerance rather than persistence, thereby raising questions about the classification of other environmental perturbations. The synergistic action of multiple aminoglycoside species with polymyxins opens many treatment options. Lethality with biofilms and with S. aureus may extend polymyxin-based therapies beyond planktonic, gram-negative bacteria, and the ROS independence of the combination may allow antioxidant mitigation of drug toxicity. Overall, the work advances our knowledge of persistent and tolerant bacterial pathogens and our efforts to eradicate them.