Two separate feeding trials were undertaken to benchmark a series of commercial diets and determine the nutrient and energy apparent digestibility coefficients of a variety of protein-based feed ingredients when fed to sobaity seabream, Sparidentex hasta. In Experiment 1, triplicate groups of fish (initial body weight: 330.5 ± 2.6 g) were fed with one of three locally available diets containing crude protein (CP) levels ranging from 44 to 46% of dry matter (DM), each with ~12% crude fat. Fish grew at around 3.2 g day−1 with a specific growth rate (SGR) of 0.7% day−1. Both the feed conversion ratio (FCR) and protein efficiency ratio (PER) were significantly better in fish fed diets, which contained the highest (46.4%) crude protein level. Overall, the data from these preliminary studies suggest that the best performance by sobaity seabream was obtained with a diet containing 46% crude protein, 20 MJ/kg, and a protein-to-energy ratio of 23 mg/kJ. In Experiment 2, fish with an initial body weight of 319 ± 7 g were held in 11 tanks and fed reference (D1) and test diets (D2–D11) for 7 days before fecal collection. This process was repeated twice in a blocking arrangement to generate three replicates. Each of the ten test diets contained 30% of a test ingredient, with the remaining 70% proportionally identical to the D1 diet. Diet apparent digestibility coefficients (ADCs) were measured, and the diet ADCs were then used to derive the protein and energy ADCs for the individual test ingredients. Ingredient protein ADC ranged between 75.5 and 93.9%, while ingredient energy ADC ranged between 66.8 and 81.2%.
This study aimed to evaluate the apparent digestibility coefficients (ADCs) for nutrients and energy of seven conventional and alternative feed ingredients (poultry feather meal, fermented feather meal, mealworm meal, defatted black soldier fly, Chlorella, poultry by-product meal, and corn meal) when fed to Sobaity seabream (Sparidentex hasta), with the goal of identifying sustainable, digestible, and nutritionally viable ingredients for aquaculture feed formulations. A reference diet (RF) was formulated to meet the nutrient requirements of Sobaity seabream while test diets were prepared to contain 70% RF and 30% of the test ingredients. Sobaity seabream (200 ± 8.0 g) were fed the diets for seven days before fecal matter was collected by stripping. The whole length of the digestibility trial was 21 days. The ingredient apparent digestibility of dry matter (34.8–70.4%), crude protein (52.8–107.8%), crude lipid (67.7–112.9%), and energy (52.2–86.1%) were affected by test ingredients (p < 0.01). The dry matter digestibility of mealworm meal was the highest (70.4%) compared to other ingredients. Feather meal, Chlorella, and black soldier fly meal had significantly lower values of dry matter digestibility. Dry matter and crude protein were significantly more digestible in fermented feather meal than the feather meal without fermentation. The crude protein digestibility was significantly higher (107.8%) for mealworm meal. However, feather meal has shown a significantly lower value (52.8%) for crude protein digestibility compared to other ingredients. Energy digestibility showed a significant positive correlation with dry matter digestibility (r = 0.870). The energy digestibility of mealworm meal was significantly higher (86.1%, p < 0.05) than other ingredients. Feather meal had the lowest energy digestibility (52.2%) with no statistically significant difference from Chlorella, corn meal, and black soldier fly meal. This study indicates that mealworm meal is the most easily digestible protein source for Sobaity seabream and should be prioritized in their diets. Fermentation enhances the digestibility of feather meal and is recommended when using it. Ingredients with a lower digestibility, like feather meal, chlorella, and black soldier fly meal, should be used in moderation or undergo further processing to improve nutrient availability.