SUMMARY: The precise estimation of the mass changes in Madagascar is a challenge by using the Gravity Recovery and Climate Experiment (GRACE) mission Level-2 products since they are contaminated by noise. Although this issue can be alleviated by the empirical destriping method or spatial filtering, they result in potential signal distortion or signal leakage. To improve this, we propose a reconstructive filter, whose parameters are optimized by the signal-to-noise ratio. Subsequently, our optimal filter corresponding to the best signal-to-noise ratio (5.63) is used to estimate the mass changes (2002–2017) in Madagascar. Eventually, our results are compared with two reliable GRACE mascon products and other independent observations. Correspondingly, here are our major conclusions: (1) Compared with groundwater storage from the mascon products, our estimates have the highest Pearson correlation (0.5) with in situ observation and can detect the rapid increase of groundwater storage during the rainy season. (2) The Fourier spectrum analysis detects a ∼3.8-yr periodic signal in the terrestrial water storage changes in Madagascar, which is contributed from the interannual precipitation driven by climate factor (Indian Ocean Dipole) and the aliasing error for imperfect GRACE pre-process. Our work introduces an effective filter for processing GRACE Level-2 data and presents novel insights into mass changes in Madagascar.
SUMMARY: In this work, a novel method has been developed to remove the north–south stripe noise in the Level-2 spherical harmonic coefficient products collected by the Gravity Recovery and Climate Experiment (GRACE) mission. The proposed method extracts the stripe noise from the equivalent water height (EWH) map via the Multivariate Variational Mode Decomposition algorithm. The idea behind our method is to extract the cofrequency mode in multiple-channel series in the longitude direction. The parameters of our method are empirically determined. The investigation in a closed-loop simulation proves the improvement of our methods compared with the Singular Spectrum Analysis Spatial (SSAS) filter. Subsequently, the spatial-domain and spectral-domain investigations are conducted by using real GRACE data. Our method only suppresses stripe noise at low latitudes (30°S–30°N) and imposes an order-dependent impact on spherical harmonic coefficients but with potential oversmoothing. Meanwhile, the well-documented water level proves that our method further reduces outliers in a time-series of localized mass variations compared with the SSAS filter. More importantly, users are allowed to reduce the filtering strength of our method to preserve small-scale strong signals while suppressing stripe noise. Moreover, noise levels over the ocean at low latitudes are evaluated as well. The noise level of our method using empirical parameters is 32.48 mm of EWH, with 31.54 and 53.52 mm for DDK6 and SSAS, respectively. Our work introduces a novel method to address the issue of north–south stripe noise in the spatial domain.
SUMMARY: The spherical harmonic coefficient Level-2 products of the Gravity Recovery and Climate Experiment (GRACE) mission are affected by north–south stripe noise. Toward this end, we proposed a new filter named Variational Mode Decomposition spatial (VMDS) filter that transforms an equivalent water height (EWH) map derived from GRACE Level-2 product into a 1-D sequence, which is then filtered by using variational mode decomposition. This approach overcomes the limitations of the singular spectrum analysis spatial (SSAS) filter, which performs well in the medium-frequency band but omits the high-frequency NSS noise. Integrating the strengths of both, we developed a combined filter termed SV by placing the VMDS filter behind the SSAS filter. A closed-loop simulation demonstrates the better ability of SV to suppress NSS noise and preserve signal at the grid scale compared to the SSAS filter. In the real-world scenario, the SV solution achieves a noise level (46.68 mm of EWH) below that for SSAS and DDK7 solutions (53.52 and 53.68 mm of EWH, respectively) over the ocean at low latitudes. Moreover, the well-documented water level of Lake Victoria and the well-modelled coseismic gravity change of the Mw9.2 2004 Sumatra-Andaman earthquake demonstrate that the SV filter efficiently preserves localized mass evolutions while suppressing north–south stripe noise. Such short-wavelength signals are usually missed in highly filtered spherical harmonics (e.g. DDK5 and DDK6) solutions or are significantly inconsistent for various mass concentration solutions.
Among the Gravity Recovery and Climate Experiment (GRACE) and GRACE Follow-on temporal gravity products, the north–south stripe noise in the spherical harmonic coefficient (SHC) products contaminates the inversion of the Earth’s mass field. In this study, GRACE SHC products are adopted to estimate the mass changes in Nicaragua. To improve this estimation, we propose an empirical low-pass filter to suppress stripe noise. After only using our filter, the Nicaragua regional uncertainty diminishes from 123.26 mm to 69.11 mm, and the mean signal-to-noise ratio of all available months (2002–2021) improves from 1.67 to 1.8. Subsequently, our filter is employed to estimate the basin terrestrial water storage (TWS) change in Nicaragua. In the end, TWS change estimations are compared with various observations such as mascon products, hydrological models, and in situ groundwater observation. The main conclusions are as follows: (1) After using the wavelet coherent analysis, there is a negative resonance between TWS and the climate factor (El Nino–Southern Oscillation) with a period of 2~4 years; (2) The significant ~3.8-year periodic signal in groundwater storage change estimation is contributed by GRACE aliasing error. Our work can provide new knowledge and references for mass change in small areas.
Approximately 3.5 million people in Nicaragua have experienced food insecurity due to the El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO)-induced drought from 2014 to 2016. It is essential to study terrestrial water storage component (TWSC) changes and their responses to ENSO to prevent the water crisis in Nicaragua influenced by ENSO. In this paper, we investigate the TWSC changes in Nicaragua and its sub-basins derived from the Gravity Recovery and Climate Experiment (GRACE)’s temporal gravity field, hydrological model, and water level data, and then determine the connection between the TWSC and ENSO from April 2002 to April 2021 by time series analysis. The research results show that: (1) The estimated TWSC changes in Nicaragua are in good agreement with the variation of precipitation and evaporation, and precipitation is the main cause of TWSC variation. (2) According to the cross-correlation analysis, there is a significant negative peak correlation between the interannual TWSC and ENSO in western Nicaragua, especially for interannual soil moisture (−0.80). The difference in peak correlation between the western and eastern sub-basins may be due to the topographic hindrance of the ENSO-inspired precipitation process. (3) The cross-wavelet analysis indicates that the resonance periods between TWSC and ENSO are primarily 2 and 4 years. These resonance periods are related to the two ENSO modes (the central Pacific (CP) mode with a quasi-2-year period and the eastern Pacific (EP) mode with a quasi-4-year period). Furthermore, their resonance phase variation may be due to the transition to ENSO mode. This study revealed the relationship between ENSO and TWSC in Nicaragua, which can provide a certain reference for water resources regulation.
Noise and the necessary smoothing introduced by post-processing filters fundamentally degrade the spatial resolution of temporal gravity field products from the Gravity Recovery and Climate Experiment (GRACE) and GRACE Follow-On missions, thus limiting their utility for investigating terrestrial water storage variations. To address this issue, this study presents a generalized reconstructed filtering framework that enhances conventional filters, including Gaussian, Fan, and DDK kernels. The framework converts iterative filtering operations into analytically expressed equivalent filters, explicitly characterizing their impact on signal and noise. Evaluations using both real-world data and controlled closed-loop simulations demonstrate that the reconstructed filters achieve higher empirical signal-to-noise ratios compared to their original counterparts. Among them, the DDK-based reconstructed filter performs best, yielding the highest signal-to-noise ratio. We further demonstrate that the land-ocean root-mean-square ratio can serve as a reliable empirical proxy for the signal-to-noise ratio in global or regional real-world applications. The proposed framework provides an adaptable and effective means of balancing noise suppression with spatial resolution in the investigation of terrestrial water storage variations.