Lake Rawapening, Semarang Regency, Indonesia, has incorporated a holistic plan in its management practices. However, despite successful target achievements, some limitations remain, and a review of its management plan is needed. This paper identifies and analyzes existing lake management strategies as a standard specifically in Lake Rawapening by exploring various literature, both legal frameworks and scholarly articles indexed in the Scopus database and Google Scholar about lake management in many countries. By using Publish or Perish with the keywords “lake management” OR “management of lake”, 1532 and 1990 works from the Scopus database and Google Scholar, respectively, have been reduced 37. The results show that there are two major types of lake management, namely pillar-based and object-based. The holistic review has resulted in nine points of pillar-based management, which consists of conceptual paradigms as the foundation, and 11 points of object-based management to restore or preserve the lake, which is in line with the form of programs and activities. Overall, Lake Rawapening management should be concerned with finance and technology when applying pillar-based management, and it should include more activities within programs on erosion-sedimentation control as well as monitoring of operational performance using information systems to ensure the implementation of activities within programs in applying object-based lake management.
Lake Rawapening, Semarang Regency, Indonesia, has incorporated a holistic plan in its management practices. However, despite successful target achievements, some limitations remain that a review of its management plan is needed. This paper identifies and analyzes existing lake management strategies as a standard specifically in Lake Rawapening by exploring various literature, both legal frameworks and scholarly articles indexed in Google Scholar and published in Water by MDPI about lake management in many countries. There are two major types of lake management, namely pillar-based and object-based. While the former is the foundation of a conceptual paradigm that does not comprehensively consider the roles of finance and technology in the lake management, the latter indicates the objects to manage so as to create standards or benchmarks for the implementation of various programs. Overall, Lake Rawapening management should include more programs on erosion-sedimentation control and monitoring of operational performance using information systems.
1 April 2024 in Journal of Degraded and Mining Lands Management
In 2014, Kelud, an active volcano in East Java, ejected ashes (hereafter termed KA; Kelud ash) that reportedly reached as far as Central Java and the Special Region of Yogyakarta (DIY). The KA deposits are observable in, among others, the coastal sand dune area in Parangtritis. Due to the active aeolian process, the KA layers can be found at different depths five years after the eruption. Thus, the KA can be used as a marker of the post-2014 aeolian activities at the Parangtritis dune, which was once classified as a degraded land and later recognized as a coastal geosite, ultimately allowing us to calculate the volume and sand transport rate. The research surveys performed at 25 points discovered volcanic ash layers at 1 cm to 26 cm below the surface. At some observed points, the ash deposits were found on the surface and continuously transported. This research observed an area of 60,000 m2 with an average of 8.5 cm thick sand layers lying above the KA layer. Based on the calculation, the total volume of the transported sand at the Parangtritis sand dune from 2014 to 2019 was approximately 5,100 m3. This volume is considerably small owing to various obstacles in the transport zones. Based on the five-year dynamic of the sand dune, this study suggested that restoration needs to be conducted immediately particularly in eliminating vegetation barriers to maintain the sediment balance (erosion-transport-sedimentation) of the coastal sand dune area.
Eutrophication triggered by excessive nutrient loading has become a major driver of lake degradation in many parts of the world. Lake Rawapening is one of Indonesia’s national priority lakes for environmental restoration and has experienced eutrophic conditions progressing toward a hypertrophic state due to high phosphorus loads (P-load) and total phosphorus concentrations (TP-C). Despite the implementation of lake rehabilitation programs, their effectiveness in improving trophic status has not been quantitatively evaluated, limiting stakeholders’ understanding of the outcomes. This study evaluates the effectiveness of rehabilitation interventions in controlling the trophic state of Lake Rawapening using a calibrated SWAT hydrological model. Seven scenarios were developed by combining land use changes from seasonal agriculture to agroforestry; fertilizer management in paddy fields; and lake deepening. Model simulations compared TP-C responses across scenarios. The results indicate that conversion of seasonal agricultural land to agroforestry is the most effective intervention, reducing TP-C by 33% (from 0.029 mg/L to 0.020 mg/L) and improving the trophic state from eutrophic to mesotrophic. Conversely, fertilizer management scenarios, even when applied according to recommended dosages, consistently increased TP-C by 14%. Lake deepening scenarios also tended to elevate TP-C by 20.9% due to increased water volume of 90% and phosphorus residence time (P-RS) of 92.4%. The study provides a measurable and replicable approach for simulating spatial dynamics and trophic responses to lake rehabilitation interventions. The findings support the development of multi-scenario management strategies for Lake Rawapening and other lakes in Indonesia.