Background: The vast majority of thyroid cancer, in particular the non-anaplastic follicular cell-derived thyroid carcinomas (non-ANA FCDCs), are considered indolent tumors with very low mortality. Hence, it is crucial to analyze the subgroup of these patients who died of disease (DOD) in order to identify clinico-pathologic features predictive of disease specific mortality. Methods: All non-ANA FCDCs operated at a tertiary cancer center between 1985 and 2010 who were DOD were identified and submitted to a meticulous clinico-pathologic analysis. Results: Out of 3,750 non-ANA FCDCs, 58 (1.5%) DOD cases were identified. The DOD group was composed of 33 (57%) poorly differentiated carcinoma (PDTC), 14 (24%) papillary thyroid carcinomas (PTC) tall cell variant, 4 (7%) Hurthle cell carcinomas, 3 (5%) papillary microcarcinomas, 2 (3%) PTC classical variant, and 2 (3%) PTC follicular variant. Twenty-seven patients (47%) presented with distant metastases (DM), 28 (48%) developed DM during follow ups, while the remaining 3 (5%) had locally advanced non-resectable recurrence. Gross extension beyond thyroid (GET) was present in 36 (62%) and extensive vascular invasion (VI) in 21 (36%) of cases. All microcarcinomas had PDTC in their clinically apparent cervical lymph nodes at presentation. Encapsulated thyroid carcinomas were responsible for 17% of DOD cases and all had extensive VI and/or DM at presentation. All patients had at least one of these high risk features at diagnosis: DM at presentation, PDTC, GET, and/or extensive VI. The majority of patients died from DM (n=51, 88%), 3 (5%) of locoregional disease, 3 (5%) from both, and 1 (2%) from unknown cause. Conclusions: PDTC and tall cell variant PTC are responsible for the vast majority of death in differentiated thyroid carcinomas while the few fatal classical, follicular variant PTC and microcarcinomas all harbor PDTC component, DM or GET. Encapsulated differentiated thyroid carcinoma with focal capsular and/or VI without DM at presentation does not seem to cause death. Lack of DM at presentation, PDTC, GET and extensive VI identify thyroid carcinomas at almost no risk of DOD. The vast majority of patients die of DM rather than locoregional invasion, prompting the need for effective systemic treatment.