Chemical phenomena are only observable on a macroscopic level, whereas they are explained by entities on a non-visible level. Students often demonstrate limited ability to link these different levels. Augmented reality (AR) offers the possibility to increase contiguity by embedding virtual models into hands-on experiments. Therefore, this paper presents a pre- and post-test study investigating how learning and cognitive load are influenced by AR during hands-on experiments. Three comparison groups (AR, animation and filmstrip), with a total of N = 104 German secondary school students, conducted and explained two hands-on experiments. Whereas the AR group was allowed to use an AR app showing virtual models of the processes on the submicroscopic level during the experiments, the two other groups were provided with the same dynamic or static models after experimenting. Results indicate no significant learning gain for the AR group in contrast to the two other groups. The perceived intrinsic cognitive load was higher for the AR group in both experiments as well as the extraneous load in the second experiment. It can be concluded that AR could not unleash its theoretically derived potential in the present study.
29 September 2026 in Journal of Science Education and Technology
Augmented Reality (AR) enables the presentation of models at the submicroscopic level during chemical hands-on experiments and may thus support learners in connecting macroscopic observations, submicroscopic processes, and symbolic representations. Such connections are essential for understanding chemical phenomena, yet many students struggle to establish them, leading to fragmented or purely descriptive explanations. However, little is known about how AR influences the structure and quality of learner-generated explanations during experimentation. In this quasi-experimental pre-post study, three conditions were compared in grade 11 chemistry classes: AR, animation, and filmstrip. Students ( N = 104) worked in pairs on two acid-base experiments and created explanatory screencasts, which were analyzed in two complementary ways: network analysis was used to examine transitions between representational levels, while a separate holistic coding scheme was applied to assess overall explanatory quality. Across both experiments, students in the AR group integrated submicroscopic entities into their explanations more frequently than students in the other groups. However, this increased integration was not consistently associated with higher explanatory quality. The findings suggest that AR can foster representational integration, but that explicit scaffolding might be necessary to translate this into high-quality causal explanations.