Sakura Arai

Dr. Sakura Arai

orcid

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

23Years (2004-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
1 November 2022 in Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
GSGiuliana Spadaro
Giuliana Spadaro
CGCaroline Graf
Caroline Graf
SJShuxian Jin
Shuxian Jin
SASakura Arai
Sakura Arai
YIYukako Inoue
Yukako Inoue
DDaniel Balliet
Daniel Balliet
Impersonal cooperation among strangers enables societies to create valuable public goods, such as infrastructure, public services, and democracy. Several factors have been proposed to explain variation in impersonal cooperation across societies, referring to institutions (e.g., rule of law), religion (e.g., belief in God as a third-party punisher), cultural beliefs (e.g., trust) and values (e.g., collectivism), and ecology (e.g., relational mobility). We tested 17 preregistered hypotheses in a meta-analysis of 1,506 studies of impersonal cooperation in social dilemmas (e.g., the Public Goods Game) conducted across 70 societies (k = 2,271), where people make costly decisions to cooperate among strangers. After controlling for 10 study characteristics that can affect the outcome of studies, we found very little cross-societal variation in impersonal cooperation. Categorizing societies into cultural groups explained no variance in cooperation. Similarly, cultural, ancestral, and linguistic distance between societies explained little variance in cooperation. None of the cross-societal factors hypothesized to relate to impersonal cooperation explained variance in cooperation across societies. We replicated these conclusions when meta-analyzing 514 studies across 41 states and nine regions in the United States (k = 783). Thus, we observed that impersonal cooperation occurred in all societies-and to a similar degree across societies-suggesting that prior research may have overemphasized the magnitude of differences between modern societies in impersonal cooperation. We discuss the discrepancy between theory, past empirical research and the meta-analysis, address a limitation of experimental research on cooperation to study culture, and raise possible directions for future research. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2022 APA, all rights reserved).

13 November 2017 in Adaptive Human Behavior and Physiology
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
AEAdar B. Eisenbruch
Adar B. Eisenbruch
ALAaron W. Lukaszewski
Aaron W. Lukaszewski
ZSZachary L. Simmons
Zachary L. Simmons
SASakura Arai
Sakura Arai
JRJames R. Roney
James R. Roney

19 April 2022 in PLOS ONE
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
SASakura Arai
Sakura Arai
JTJohn Tooby
John Tooby
LCLeda Cosmides
Leda Cosmides
Evolutionary models of dyadic cooperation demonstrate that selection favors different strategies for reciprocity depending on opportunities to choose alternative partners. We propose that selection has favored mechanisms that estimate the extent to which others can switch partners and calibrate motivations to reciprocate and punish accordingly. These estimates should reflect default assumptions about relational mobility: the probability that individuals in one’s social world will have the opportunity to form relationships with new partners. This prior probability can be updated by cues present in the immediate situation one is facing. The resulting estimate of a partner’s outside options should serve as input to motivational systems regulating reciprocity: Higher estimates should down-regulate the use of sanctions to prevent defection by a current partner, and up-regulate efforts to attract better cooperative partners by curating one’s own reputation and monitoring that of others. We tested this hypothesis using a Trust Game with Punishment (TGP), which provides continuous measures of reciprocity, defection, and punishment in response to defection. We measured each participant’s perception of relational mobility in their real-world social ecology and experimentally varied a cue to partner switching. Moreover, the study was conducted in the US (n = 519) and Japan (n = 520): societies that are high versus low in relational mobility. Across conditions and societies, higher perceptions of relational mobility were associated with increased reciprocity and decreased punishment: i.e., those who thought that others have many opportunities to find new partners reciprocated more and punished less. The situational cue to partner switching was detected, but relational mobility in one’s real social world regulated motivations to reciprocate and punish, even in the experimental setting. The current research provides evidence that motivational systems are designed to estimate varying degrees of partner choice in one’s social ecology and regulate reciprocal behaviors accordingly.

20 February 2023 in Games
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
SASakura Arai
Sakura Arai
MWMotoki Watabe
Motoki Watabe
KKKei Kanari
Kei Kanari
QSQiulu Shou
Qiulu Shou
Frank KruegerFrank Krueger
Frank Krueger
HTHaruto Takagishi
Haruto Takagishi
Oxytocin has been proposed to regulate human trust. Previous experiments supported this claim by demonstrating that exogenous and endogenous oxytocin is associated with trust (how much trust people place in strangers) and reciprocity (how much people reciprocate when trusted). However, recent replication attempts have been unsuccessful in demonstrating the trust-enhancing effect of oxytocin, and there is limited evidence on whether oxytocin is associated with reciprocity. This study aimed to replicate the previously found nonlinear relationships between the endogenous oxytocin concentration and both trust and reciprocity by utilizing a monetarily incentivized trust game. In a college sample, we found that salivary oxytocin levels showed (i) an inverted U-shaped relationship with trust in men and (ii) a U-shaped relationship with reciprocity in women. The current results confirm the previous finding that endogenous oxytocin levels have nonlinear relationships with trust and reciprocity. Further research on the role of oxytocin secretion in trust and reciprocity is warranted.

7 July 2023 in PsyArXiv
Verified
Preprint
Open access
SASakura Arai
Sakura Arai
JTJohn Tooby
John Tooby
LCLeda Cosmides
Leda Cosmides
Accumulating evidence suggests that group is a cue of reputation-based partner choice: it evokes an assumption that one is being recognized and evaluated as a cooperation partner and thereby triggers reputation concern. For instance, studies have demonstrated that people cooperate more with ingroup than outgroup members, but this bias disappears when the beneficiary does not know the donor is a fellow ingroup member and, thus, is unlikely to evaluate the donor as a partner. Here, we further examined this hypothesis by (i) testing whether people avoid reputation-harming behaviour, such as second-party punishment, and (ii) manipulating anonymity instead of membership knowledge. Across three experiments (N = 723), participants were less likely to punish ingroup than outgroup partners, while cooperating more with ingroup partners. However, when participants were anonymous, the degree to which people favoured ingroup decreased regardless of study setting (online vs. in-person) or sample (convenience vs. college). That is, without reputation concern, people donated less to ingroup members and were less hesitant to punish them. The results illustrate that our mind perceives one’s group as a “market” for cooperation partners and employs a default reputation-management strategy—up-regulating motivations to cooperate while down-regulating punitive motivations—unless other cues challenge its necessity.

15 March 2022 in PsyArXiv
Verified
Preprint
Open access
GSGiuliana Spadaro
Giuliana Spadaro
CGCaroline Graf
Caroline Graf
SJShuxian Jin
Shuxian Jin
SASakura Arai
Sakura Arai
YIYukako Inoue
Yukako Inoue
DBDaniel Balliet
Daniel Balliet
Impersonal cooperation among strangers enables societies to create valuable public goods, such as infrastructure, public services, and democracy. Several factors have been proposed to explain variation in impersonal cooperation across societies, referring to institutions (e.g., rule of law), religion (e.g., belief in God as a third-party punisher), cultural beliefs (e.g., trust) and values (e.g., collectivism), and ecology (e.g., relational mobility). We tested 17 pre-registered hypotheses in a meta-analysis of 1,506 studies of impersonal cooperation in social dilemmas (e.g., the Public Goods Game) conducted across 70 societies (k = 2,271), where people make costly decisions to cooperate among strangers. After controlling for 10 study characteristics that can affect the outcome of studies, we found very little cross-societal variation in impersonal cooperation. Categorizing societies into cultural groups explained no variance in cooperation. Similarly, cultural, ancestral, and linguistic distance between societies explained little variance in cooperation. None of the cross-societal factors hypothesized to relate to impersonal cooperation explained variance in cooperation across societies. We replicated these conclusions when meta-analyzing 514 studies across 41 states and nine regions in the United States (k = 783). Thus, we observed that impersonal cooperation occurred in all societies – and to a similar degree across societies – suggesting that prior research may have overemphasized the magnitude of differences between modern societies in impersonal cooperation. We discuss the discrepancy between theory, past empirical research and the meta-analysis, address a limitation of experimental research on cooperation to study culture, and raise possible directions for future research.