Hoteliers have steadily been able to reduce costs and increase employees’ workload as a result of mass unemployment sparked by the financial crisis, beginning in 2008, and associated legislative reforms by the Spanish government. Outsourcing has been hotels’ main instrument in this drive. Hotel chambermaids are among the groups most affected by this phenomenon. This article analyses the impacts of outsourcing on hotel maids’ working conditions, while questioning the possibilities for achieving inclusive tourism given the current outsourcing trend. It is based on 44 in-depth interviews with a range of informants, including 24 hotel maids who have experienced the process of outsourcing, in major Spanish tourism destinations. This study aims to understand the changes these workers have experienced and perceived in their working conditions. The research results highlight a marked deterioration in hotel maids’ working conditions in recent years, most notably involving (a) a reduction in their salary and the loss of professional categories, (b) work overload, (c) greater uncertainty in the duration of employment, timetables and work schedule, (d) de-professionalisation, (e) segmentation, division and an increase in competition between hotel staff, (f) the accentuation of health problems and (g) a decrease in the capacity of representation and the defence of workers’ collective interests.
Potential to identify and cultivate forms of post-capitalism in tourism development has yet to be explored in depth in current research. Tourism is one of the world’s largest industries, and hence a powerful global political and socio-economic force. Yet numerous problems associated with conventional tourism development have been documented over the years, problems now greatly exacerbated by impacts of the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic. Calls for sustainable tourism development have long sought to address such issues and set the industry on a better course. Yet such calls tend to still promote continued growth as the basis of the tourism industry’s development, while mounting demands for “degrowth” suggest that growth is itself the fundamental problem that needs to be addressed in discussion of sustainability in tourism and elsewhere. This critique asserts that incessant growth is intrinsic to capitalist development, and hence to tourism’s role as one of the main forms of global capitalist expansion. Touristic degrowth would therefore necessitate postcapitalist practices aiming to socialise the tourism industry. While a substantial body of research has explored how tourism functions as an expression of a capitalist political economy, thus far no research has systematically explored what post-capitalist tourism might look like or how to achieve it. Applying Erik Olin Wright’s 2019 innovative typology for conceptualizing different forms of post-capitalism as components of an overarching strategy for “eroding capitalism” to a series of illustrative allows for exploration of their potential to contribute to an analogous strategy to similarly “erode tourism” as a quintessential capitalist industry.
Since the COVID-19 pandemic began, platform capitalism has expanded greatly in the delivery sector. The consolidation of an oligopoly controlled by a few corporate platforms has led to precarious working conditions for “gig economy” workers. Increasing protests and strikes have led to the reform of labour directives and to the emergence of alternative ways of organising work through platform cooperatives. This article examines how these emergent platform cooperatives are mobilised and their challenges and implications. Barcelona, the cradle of many platform economy and delivery sector start-ups, is a critical case for examining the recent birth of alternative delivery cooperatives. This article is informed by the cases of three cooperatives, organised by those working as riders, providing delivery services in the city of Barcelona: Mensakas, Les Mercedes, and 2GoDelivery. The paper shows how the embeddedness of these nascent platform cooperatives in favourable governance arrangements, a supportive social and solidarity movement, the knowledge and experience of workers, and the territory where the cooperatives are embedded are essential for their creation. This multi-layered embeddedness is necessary, but not sufficient, to explain how platform cooperatives thrive. The study concludes that the agency of platform workers, who triggered this transformation, was essential for the emergence of alternative ways of organising work in the platform economy.
13 November 2015 in Anuario de Estudios Centroamericanos
El fracaso de numerosas iniciativas de cooperación internacional en el ámbito del turismo comunitario en diferentes países de América Latina ha puesto en cuestión en ciertos círculos académicos y agencias de desarrollo la viabilidad del mismo modelo. Uno de los temas en discusión ha sida la escasa capacidad de comercialización y generación de ingresos de este tipo de emprendimientos una vez puestos en marcha, lo cual derivaba en su posterior abandono. Sin embargo, en una aproximación más cercana a las dinámicas presentes es posible identificar dos formas de comercialización que ponen en cuestión esa imagen. Por una parte destaca la consolidación de numerosas iniciativas comunitarias orientadas de forma directa a un mercado de proximidad de clase media y baja. Por otra el fortalecimiento de estructuras de intermediación surgidas desde las propias iniciativas comunitarias o en alianza con estas y que han empezado a posicionar al turismo comunitario en el mercado internacional. El debate se resitúa en torno a las estrategias que han permitido la consolidación de determinadas iniciativas de turismo comunitario así como las implicaciones derivadas de estas formas de articulación comercial en el sector.
The creation of new tourist areas forms part of the spatiotemporal capital fixes available to territories to deal with the different crises that affect them. The transformation of these territories into functional areas for a new logic of accumulation has a profound impact on their different population groups and on nature. As a consequence of the major drive in tourism from the late 1990s to the early 2000s, Central America has become the ideal setting to observe and analyze how this metamorphosis occurs. In this sense, based on the analysis of the conflicts that have arisen, three major dynamics for these new tourist areas have been identified: (a) the dispossession of natural resources and the dismantling of preexisting territory; (b) intensive population movements that expel and attract different groups; and (c) subordinate integration of those from rural communities into new tourism activities that are central to the economy in these areas. This transformation exhibits a structurally violent nature. Using this interpretation framework, this article proffers approaches on how to move forward with a research agenda that enables a deeper understanding of the construction processes underpinning tourist areas, based on the Central American case study.