Michèle Knodt

Prof. Dr. Michèle Knodt


Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

23Years (2004-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
2 July 2020 in Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
MKMichèle Knodt
Michèle Knodt
Marc RingelMarc Ringel
Marc Ringel
RMRainer Müller
Rainer Müller
In 2016, the Commission proposed an ambitious governance strategy in order to further the transformation of the European energy system towards the Unions’ 2030 climate and energy targets. Therein the EU adopted the Regulation on the Governance of the Energy Union in 2018 to harden its otherwise soft governance. This contribution firstly aims at characterizing the ‘hardness’ of this soft governance. The analyses showed the introduction of harder elements to soft governance to at least a certain extend. Secondly, it explains the degree of hardness from actor-centred institutionalism perspective by analysing the trilogue of the co-legislators and the Commission. The analysis shows a successful entrepreneurial role of the Commission in those questions where it was backed by the European. The Parliament performed strongly due to powerful support of its joint committee, experienced negotiators and a wide majority voting in the plenum. In contrary, the Council showed a divided opinion in many points and was confronted with a weak presidency during the dialogue. As a result, harder elements were introduced in questions, where Commission and Parliament argued along the same lines and could even go beyond the Commissions’ proposal, where Parliament and Council found points of common interest.


10 February 2023 in Energy Research & Social Science
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
ABArina Belova
Arina Belova
CQChristine Quittkat
Christine Quittkat
LLLukáš Lehotský
Lukáš Lehotský
MKMichèle Knodt
Michèle Knodt
JOJan Osička
Jan Osička
JKJörg Kemmerzell
Jörg Kemmerzell

14 October 2020 in Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
MKMichèle Knodt
Michèle Knodt
JSJonas Schoenefeld
Jonas Schoenefeld
While various forms of soft governance have been long in the making, there is a growing introduction of new policy elements in order to ‘harden’ soft governance arrangements. These new forms of ‘harder’ soft governance (HSG) vary in the degree of hardness in different settings. This special issue aims to derive lessons for climate and energy policy on HSG by looking across other policy fields and institutions where such ‘hardening’ has emerged, including in climate policy monitoring, the EU Energy Union, the UNFCCC, the OECD, the Open Method of Coordination, the European Semester, and policy surveillance in transnational city networks. Bringing the contributions together, this introduction reviews soft governance approaches, including their hardening. It then develops a framework for diagnosing HSG, including indicators such as obligations, justification, precision, ‘blaming and shaming’ opportunities, the role of third party actors, bundling, enforcement by policy field coupling, and sanctions. The introduction then identifies driving factors of HSG, including the role of the EU Member States, a strong need for coordination, policy entrepreneurs and institutional opportunities. The lessons from this special issue provide a useful yardstick for the future development of climate and energy governance, and the use of HSG in other policy fields.

25 January 2011 in JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
PKPeter Kotzian
Peter Kotzian
MKMichèle Knodt
Michèle Knodt
SUSigita Urdze
Sigita Urdze

19 June 2020 in West European Politics
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
JSJonas Schoenefeld
Jonas Schoenefeld
MKMichèle Knodt
Michèle Knodt
Soft law and governance captured the attention of scholars in the 2000s, and new policy challenges and the novel introduction of ‘harder’ elements now drive a (re)turn to these discussions. This article explores the extent to which dynamics leading towards ‘harder soft governance’ (HSG) appear in the EU’s renewable energy governance by comparing the 2020 and 2030 Renewable Energy Directives. Document analysis and interviews reveal a surface-level softening because the new 2030 directive contains no binding national targets for the Member States. An entrepreneurial Commission has been seeking to introduce ‘harder elements’ at the core by focusing on implementation, allowing for potentially deeper influence on the national energy mixes though the Energy Union. Two main factors drive these changes: the evolving international context of climate change governance, as well as re-configurations of the actors in the EU. Future research should explore the effectiveness of emerging HSG in detail.