Baseline biodiversity data are key for ecological and evolutionary studies and are especially relevant for areas such as the Maldivian Archipelago in the Indian Ocean, which can act as a stepping-stone for the transport of widely distributed marine species. We surveyed the islands and reefs of the Faafu and Malé Atolls with snorkeling and scuba diving, collecting the two gastropod subclasses, Heterobranchia and Vetigastropoda. Our inventory comprises 104 species photographed alive to create an identification guide. We also provide COI barcodes for most species, adding novel sequence data for the Maldivian malacofauna. Half of our species represent new records for the Maldives, emphasizing how much diversity remains to be discovered. Species distributions reflect ecological rarity, with almost 60% of taxa only found in one site. We also compiled a comprehensive checklist of heterobranchs and vetigastropods of the Maldives based on literature records, resulting in 320 species, which, together with barcoding data, indicate several potential cryptic species in the Indo-Pacific. Six new species are described, the nudibranchs Limenandra evanescenti n. sp., Eubranchus putnami n. sp., Sakuraeolis marhe n. sp., Moridilla maldivensis n. sp., Tergiposacca perspicua n. sp., and the sacoglossan Costasiella fridae n. sp.
12 August 2025 in Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution
Taxonomy is a cumulative science that translates evolutionary knowledge into a stable, communicable, and functional system of names. Yet its progress is often undermined not by new data, but by how evidence is interpreted and acted upon. We argue that taxonomic decisions should meet five foundational thresholds: (i) a classification reflecting the tree of life, ensuring replicated monophyly and rank symmetry; (ii) diagnosability, linking molecular and morphological traits to recognizable features; (iii) compatibility with topotypical material, minimizing misinterpretation and the need for further taxonomic remediation actions; (iv) collateral-impact assessment, preventing changes that induce downstream paraphyly and instability; and (v) transparent communication, fostering a civil, evidence-focused scientific debate. Together, these criteria frame taxonomy as a reproducible and accountable scientific enterprise, in which individual taxonomic decisions contribute coherently to an evolving classification. Using heterobranch sea slugs as a case study, we illustrate how departures from these standards generate instability without corresponding gains in explanatory power and demonstrate that the same evidence-based principles apply across the taxonomic hierarchy, from higher-level clades to families, genera, and species. Applying these principles supports retaining historically entrenched, monophyletic names, such as Nudibranchia s.l., when redefining them offers no phylogenetic or practical advantage. We encourage shared, transparent standards across the taxonomic community.