CRISPR-Cas9 is a promising technology for genome editing. Here we use Cas9 nuclease-induced double-strand break DNA (DSB) at the UROS locus to model and correct congenital erythropoietic porphyria. We demonstrate that homology-directed repair is rare compared with NHEJ pathway leading to on-target indels and causing unwanted dysfunctional protein. Moreover, we describe unexpected chromosomal truncations resulting from only one Cas9 nuclease-induced DSB in cell lines and primary cells by a p53-dependent mechanism. Altogether, these side effects may limit the promising perspectives of the CRISPR-Cas9 nuclease system for disease modeling and gene therapy. We show that the single nickase approach could be safer since it prevents on- and off-target indels and chromosomal truncations. These results demonstrate that the single nickase and not the nuclease approach is preferable, not only for modeling disease but also and more importantly for the safe management of future CRISPR-Cas9-mediated gene therapies.

Underweight and obese phenotypes can both pose health risks. But whereas obesity has been associated with a number of genetic variants, little is known about the genetic basis of underweight. A large-scale screen of data from 28 cytogenetic centres in Europe and North America now shows that being underweight is frequently associated with duplication of a short region on chromosome 16. Deletion of this same chromosomal region has previously been associated with obesity. The observed associated phenotypes are opposites, or mirrors, of those reported in carriers of deletions at this locus, and correlate with changes in transcript levels for genes within the duplication but not within the adjacent regions. The suggestion is that severe obesity and being underweight could have mirror etiologies, possibly through contrasting effects on energy balance. Both obesity and being underweight have been associated with increased mortality1,2. Underweight, defined as a body mass index (BMI) ≤ 18.5 kg per m2 in adults and ≤ −2 standard deviations from the mean in children, is the main sign of a series of heterogeneous clinical conditions including failure to thrive3,4,5, feeding and eating disorder and/or anorexia nervosa6,7. In contrast to obesity, few genetic variants underlying these clinical conditions have been reported8,9. We previously showed that hemizygosity of a ∼600-kilobase (kb) region on the short arm of chromosome 16 causes a highly penetrant form of obesity that is often associated with hyperphagia and intellectual disabilities10. Here we show that the corresponding reciprocal duplication is associated with being underweight. We identified 138 duplication carriers (including 132 novel cases and 108 unrelated carriers) from individuals clinically referred for developmental or intellectual disabilities (DD/ID) or psychiatric disorders, or recruited from population-based cohorts. These carriers show significantly reduced postnatal weight and BMI. Half of the boys younger than five years are underweight with a probable diagnosis of failure to thrive, whereas adult duplication carriers have an 8.3-fold increased risk of being clinically underweight. We observe a trend towards increased severity in males, as well as a depletion of male carriers among non-medically ascertained cases. These features are associated with an unusually high frequency of selective and restrictive eating behaviours and a significant reduction in head circumference. Each of the observed phenotypes is the converse of one reported in carriers of deletions at this locus. The phenotypes correlate with changes in transcript levels for genes mapping within the duplication but not in flanking regions. The reciprocal impact of these 16p11.2 copy-number variants indicates that severe obesity and being underweight could have mirror aetiologies, possibly through contrasting effects on energy balance.

The 600-kilobase (kb) break points 4 and 5 (BP4-BP5) 16p11.2 deletion and duplications (chr16; 29.6-30.2 megabase) are among the most frequent genetic causes of autism spectrum disorder (ASD), schizophrenia, and other neurodevelopmental disorders.^1-5 These reciprocal copy number variants (CNVs) are associated with mirror phenotypes of obesity and being underweight and with increased and decreased global and regional brain volumes in deletion and duplication carriers, respectively.^6-8 Previous studies^5,9 have demonstrated that ASD is diagnosed in approximately 18% of deletion carriers and that this CNV affects global cognition by shifting the IQ approximately 2 SDs without altering the variance. To our knowledge, such studies have not been conducted for the reciprocal duplication. Akin to duplications of other genomic regions, case series^10-18 have reported variable expressivity and suggested incomplete penetrance; however, incomplete penetrance was recently ruled out after recalling carriers identified in unselected populations.¹⁹ This phenotypic variability and the limited available data underscore the need to systematically characterize the clinical impact of the duplication with standardized assessments in large numbers of carriers.

Phil Beales and colleagues show that mutations in the lectin complement pathway genes COLEC11 and MASP1 cause 3MC syndrome, a disorder that includes craniofacial defects, learning disability and other developmental phenotypes. They also present evidence that the COLEC11 gene product serves as a guidance cue for neural crest cell migration. 3MC syndrome has been proposed as a unifying term encompassing the overlapping Carnevale, Mingarelli, Malpuech and Michels syndromes. These rare autosomal recessive disorders exhibit a spectrum of developmental features, including characteristic facial dysmorphism, cleft lip and/or palate, craniosynostosis, learning disability and genital, limb and vesicorenal anomalies. Here we studied 11 families with 3MC syndrome and identified two mutated genes, COLEC11 and MASP1, both of which encode proteins in the lectin complement pathway (collectin kidney 1 (CL-K1) and MASP-1 and MASP-3, respectively). CL-K1 is highly expressed in embryonic murine craniofacial cartilage, heart, bronchi, kidney and vertebral bodies. Zebrafish morphants for either gene develop pigmentary defects and severe craniofacial abnormalities. Finally, we show that CL-K1 serves as a guidance cue for neural crest cell migration. Together, these findings demonstrate a role for complement pathway factors in fundamental developmental processes and in the etiology of 3MC syndrome.