Menstrual health and hygiene is a public health and human rights issue. Amid growing access to menstrual health products and education, there is limited focus on end-of-life management and environmental impact of single-use products. Burning is a common practice to dispose of pads globally, with pad incinerators becoming widely available in India and parts of sub-Saharan Africa. However, known literature does not provide insights into the current product landscape for practitioners, researchers, or funders. Thus, this review aimed to identify and characterize incinerators designed specifically for menstrual pads and to propose recommendations for effective onsite incineration. Incinerators were identified using Internet searches, web forum posts, and key informant interviews. A custom coding form documented and summarized product characteristics. An estimate of the total cost of ownership (TCO) was computed. The ‘Availability, Accessibility, Acceptability, Quality’ framework was adapted to identify technology strengths and failures. This review identified 69 incinerators from 30 global manufacturers. Estimates of a 10-year TCO ranged from USD 153 to 149,900, with electricity being the largest driver of cost. Incinerators were found to largely lack safety features, such as emissions controls. This review provides key recommendations for a variety of stakeholders, including manufacturers, policymakers, regulators, researchers, and technical experts.
Postpartum HIV care retention rates are well below retention rates of the general adult population. The Maternal-Child Health Antiretroviral Therapy (MCH-ART) trial tested the benefit of integrating postpartum maternal ART and pediatric care through the end of breastfeeding compared to the standard of care of immediate postpartum referral of mother and infant to separate services. After the trial, twenty-one participants completed in-depth interviews to understand the acceptability of the service integration and the potentially differing “lived” experiences of the women randomized to the two conditions. Key findings include: (1) the MCH-ART integrated service was found to be acceptable, (2) women in the intervention condition expressed more negative feelings around the need to be transferred to general ART services and (3) women in the intervention condition perceived that they had more influence in selecting the clinic to which they would be transferred compared to those in the control group, although there was no actual difference by study design. Future work should more directly evaluate the impact of shared decision-making and long-term relationships with clinic staff on patient engagement and retention in HIV care.
Background: There is growing recognition of obstetric violence in health facilities across the globe. With nearly one in three pregnant women living with HIV in South Africa, it is important to consider the influence of HIV status on birth experiences, including potential experience of obstetric violence as defined by the Respectful Maternity Care Charter. This qualitative analysis aims to understand the factors that shape birth experiences of women living with HIV, including experiences at the nexus of HIV status and obstetric violence, and how women react to these factors. Methods: Data were collected in a Midwife Obstetric Unit in Gugulethu, Cape Town, South Africa, through 26 in-depth interviews with women living with HIV at 6–8 weeks postpartum. Interviews included questions about labor and early motherhood, ART adherence, and social contexts. We combined template style thematic analysis and matrix analysis to refine themes and subthemes. Results: Participants described a range of social and structural factors they felt influenced their birth experiences, including lack of resources and institutional policies. While some participants described positive interactions with healthcare providers, several described instances of obstetric violence, including being ignored and denied care. Nearly all participants, even those who described instances of obstetric violence, described themselves as strong and independent during their birth experiences. Participants reacted to birth experiences by shifting their family planning intentions, forming attitudes toward the health facility, and taking responsibility for their own and their babies’ safety during birth. Conclusions: Narratives of negative birth experiences among some women living with HIV reveal a constellation of factors that produce obstetric violence, reflective of social hierarchies and networks of power relations. Participant accounts indicate the need for future research explicitly examining how structural vulnerability shapes birth experiences for women living with HIV in South Africa. These birth stories should also guide future intervention and advocacy work, sparking initiatives to advance compassionate maternity care across health facilities in South Africa, with relevance for other comparable settings.
20 August 2020 in Maternal and Child Health Journal