Insect pests represent a major challenge to the agricultural sector, causing substantial yield losses and degrading crop quality, with significant economic and food security implications. Conventional pest management strategies are largely based on chemical insecticides, which pose a threat to the environment, present toxicity to non-target organisms, are affected by regulatory restrictions, and show limited efficiency due to the widespread development of resistance. Besides detailing these drawbacks, this review paper briefly discusses several emerging pest control alternatives, and then focuses on non-thermal plasma as an innovative and sustainable approach, characterised by reduced environmental impact and promising efficacy against a broad range of insect pests. A comprehensive description of various plasma sources operating at both low and atmospheric pressure is included, containing valuable information regarding key plasma properties and analysing their dependence on experimental parameters. This paper critically reviews experimental studies conducted over the past two decades regarding the biological effects induced by plasma exposure in insects. The vast majority of publications report mortality as the primary output of interest, showing an increasing trend with rising discharge voltage or input power, extending treatment duration and time post-treatment. Long-term monitoring of insects surviving plasma exposure reveals significant effects, such as morphological abnormalities in development, likely linked to plasma-induced disruption of endocrine regulation, surface etching and severe dehydration, activation of antioxidant defence mechanisms, reflecting plasma-related stress, damage to nervous or neuromuscular systems associated with persistent behavioural alterations, marked reduction in reproductive capacity possibly involving persistent plasma-induced DNA damage. The need for further interdisciplinary research to correlate plasma characteristics with biological effects is emphasized, enabling tuning of plasma treatment conditions for maximum efficiency. Current challenges regarding the practical implementation of plasma-based pest control methods are also discussed, mainly referring to scalability, throughput, and cost.