Jacoba H. Bührmann

Prof. Jacoba H. Bührmann

orcid

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

7Years (2020-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
23 July 2021 in Education and Information Technologies
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
BSBevan Smith
Bevan Smith
CCCharles Chimedza
Charles Chimedza
JBJacoba H. Bührmann
Jacoba H. Bührmann

31 December 2024 in BMC Health Services Research
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
MZMaria Magdalena Van Zyl-Cillié
Maria Magdalena Van Zyl-Cillié
JBJacoba H. Bührmann
Jacoba H. Bührmann
ABAlwiena J. Blignaut
Alwiena J. Blignaut
DDDerya Demirtas
Derya Demirtas
SCSiedine K. Coetzee
Siedine K. Coetzee
Background: The demand for quality healthcare is rising worldwide, and nurses in South Africa are under pressure to provide care with limited resources. This demanding work environment leads to burnout and exhaustion among nurses. Understanding the specific factors leading to these issues is critical for adequately supporting nurses and informing policymakers. Currently, little is known about the unique factors associated with burnout and emotional exhaustion among nurses in South Africa. Furthermore, whether these factors can be predicted using demographic data alone is unclear. Machine learning has recently been proven to solve complex problems and accurately predict outcomes in medical settings. In this study, supervised machine learning models were developed to identify the factors that most strongly predict nurses reporting feelings of burnout and experiencing emotional exhaustion. Methods: The PyCaret 3.3 package was used to develop classification machine learning models on 1165 collected survey responses from nurses across South Africa in medical-surgical units. The models were evaluated on their accuracy score, Area Under the Curve (AUC) score and confusion matrix performance. Additionally, the accuracy score of models using demographic data alone was compared to the full survey data models. The features with the highest predictive power were extracted from both the full survey data and demographic data models for comparison. Descriptive statistical analysis was used to analyse survey data according to the highest predictive factors. Results: The gradient booster classifier (GBC) model had the highest accuracy score for predicting both self-reported feelings of burnout (75.8%) and emotional exhaustion (76.8%) from full survey data. For demographic data alone, the accuracy score was 60.4% and 68.5%, respectively, for predicting self-reported feelings of burnout and emotional exhaustion. Fatigue was the factor with the highest predictive power for self-reported feelings of burnout and emotional exhaustion. Nursing staff’s confidence in management was the second highest predictor for feelings of burnout whereas management who listens to employees was the second highest predictor for emotional exhaustion. Conclusions: Supervised machine learning models can accurately predict self-reported feelings of burnout or emotional exhaustion among nurses in South Africa from full survey data but not from demographic data alone. The models identified fatigue rating, confidence in management and management who listens to employees as the most important factors to address to prevent these issues among nurses in South Africa.

28 July 2020 in International Journal of Artificial Intelligence in Education
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
BSBevan Smith
Bevan Smith
CCCharles Chimedza
Charles Chimedza
JBJacoba H. Bührmann
Jacoba H. Bührmann
Identifying students at risk of failing a course has potential benefits, such as recommending the At-Risk students to various interventions that could improve pass rates. The challenges however, are firstly in measuring how effective these interventions are, i.e. measuring treatment effects, and secondly, to not only predict overall (average) treatment effects, but also individual treatment effects. Previous work has used machine learning (ML) to estimate treatment effects by training models on treatment and control groups and using these models to predict counterfactuals. This is called the machine learning for predicting treatment effects, or MLTE method, in this study. This paper extends this previous work by (1) being the first to compare, or validate, the MLTE method, with the traditional propensity score matching (PSM) method; (2) using the MLTE method to compute not only global, but also subgroup and individual (heterogeneous) treatment effects and (3) by developing a method that combines the MLTE method with methods such as SHAP (SH apley A dditive exP lanations), to predict final grades, predict individual treatment effects and characterize individual students. This is a comparative study between control and experimental groups, using observational data from a first year engineering mechanics course. Students could self-select to attend extra weekly tutorials (called the intervention), resulting in treatment and control groups. The aim was to measure the treatment effects of the intervention by comparing the difference in outcomes between treated and control groups. One of the main results was to develop a method for not only predicting final grades for subgroups and individuals, but also predicting treatment effects. This is valuable for predicting how a student/subgroup would perform and whether the intervention would benefit them. It allows for determining which types of students (or subgroups) would benefit from the intervention. This method shows the most promise for catering to individual students by not only predicting individual students’ final grades (mean absolute errors of between 6% and 8% were computed), but also predicting by how much the intervention would benefit the student (individual treatment effect, ITE) and by characterizing these students using SHAP. In terms of the ML models used, tree-based models performed the best in predictions. The method developed in this study therefore promises much for using ML to help individual students pass a course by identifying individuals that will receive the most benefit from the intervention.

Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
BSBevan Smith
Bevan Smith
CCCharles Chimedza
Charles Chimedza
JBJacoba H. Bührmann
Jacoba H. Bührmann
This study critically evaluates a recent machine learning method called the X-Learner, that aims to estimate treatment effects by predicting counterfactual quantities. It uses information from the treated group to predict counterfactuals for the control group and vice versa. The problem is that studies have either only been applied to real world data without knowing the ground truth treatment effects, or have not been compared with the traditional regression methods for estimating treatment effects. This study therefore critically evaluates this method by simulating various scenarios that include observed confounding and non-linearity in the data. Although the regression X-Learner performs just as well as the traditional regression model, the other base learners performed worse. Additionally, when non-linearity was introduced into the data, the results of the X-Learner became inaccurate.

1 January 2021 in South African Journal of Industrial Engineering
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
JBJacoba H. Bührmann
Jacoba H. Bührmann
FBFrances Bruwer
Frances Bruwer
In this research, k-medoid clustering is modelled and evaluated for the capacitated vehicle routing problem (CVRP). The k-medoid clustering method creates petal-shaped clusters, which could be an effective method to create routes in the CVRP. To determine routes from the clusters, an existing metaheuristic — the ruin and recreate (R&R) method — is applied to each generated cluster. The results are benchmarked to those of a well-known clustering method, k-means clustering. The performance of the methods is measured in terms of travel cost and distance travelled, which are well-known metrics for the CVRP. The results show that k-medoid clustering method outperforms the benchmark method for most instances of the test datasets, although the CVRP without any predefined clusters still provides solutions that are closer to optimal. Clustering remains a reliable distribution management tool and reduces the processing requirements of large-scale CVRPs.

1 November 2021 in South African Journal of Industrial Engineering
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
BSBevan Smith
Bevan Smith
JBJacoba H. Bührmann
Jacoba H. Bührmann
CCCharles Chimedza
Charles Chimedza
Supplementing student learning with online videos has produced mixed results in respect of improving academic performance. This study proposed that these mixed results, before COVID-19, are due to most of the literature on online videos being observational studies and not taking confounding factors into account. This study applied the difference -indifferences (DID) technique, which measures treatment effects in observational studies. Using student grades data from an engineering mechanics course, the treatment effects of videos were measured 1) on the entire group that used the videos, 2) on those initially with failing and then with passing grades, and 3) on those grouped by grade percentage ranges. It was found that the videos had no effect on the entire group but did significantly affect those who had initial failing grades - specifically, grades of 40% to 49%. A main finding was that initial grades are an indication of how effective the online videos are in improving grades.