What is new? Trends in university technology transfer practices in the United States of America and proposed modifications to U.S. public policy underscore the need for validated instruments to assess the maturity of technologies. The NASA TRL scale appears to be the most widely adopted instrument for measuring technology maturity but anecdotal testimony from university technology transfer practitioners and evidence in the literature indicate that the NASA TRL scale poses challenges in its use, is likely subject to idiosyncratic variation, and has not been thoroughly validated. What was the approach? Content analysis was used to develop a generalized TRL (GTRL) scale to demonstrate that the NASA TRL scale can be modified and generalized in a way that increases its practicality and minimizes idiosyncratic variation both within and across contexts. A pilot study to assess its content validity, intra-rater reliability, and inter-rater reliability was performed to determine whether standard approaches for validating measurement instruments can be applied to validate the GTRL scale. What is the academic impact? The findings of the study suggest that the GTRL scale has promise as a potentially more useful measurement instrument for technology transfer practitioners than the traditional NASA TRL scale, demonstrate the viability of a methodology for evaluating its validity and reliability, highlight areas where the GTRL scale can be improved, and reveal potential methodological issues that researchers may encounter when conducting validity and reliability studies of the GTRL scale as well as strategies for coping with those challenges. What is the wider impact? The modifications and generalizations of the NASA TRL scale, as represented in the GTRL scale, have the potential to improve university technology transfer practices. With a valid and reliable measurement instrument, university technology transfer practitioners will be able to better determine how much a given technology needs to be matured and provide better guidance to university researchers. This will also enable practitioners to better allocate scarce resources.
This paper presents the results of a study aimed at understanding how technology maturity level influences the incidence of university technology transfer to the private sector. The study examined the topic from the perspective of private sector organizations. It used data from a random sample of patent applications filed with the United States Patent and Trademark Office and a theoretically guided sampling of multiple cases of private sector organizations that contemplated obtaining and assimilating technologies created at universities in the United States. The patent application data were analyzed using nonparametric statistical techniques and the case data were analyzed using qualitative comparative analysis (QCA). The findings of the study suggest that the typical maturity level of technologies created at U.S. universities is a TRL-5 or lower on as scale adapted from the NASA technology readiness level (TRL) scale. A technology maturity level of TRL-6 or higher is likely an insufficient but necessary part of at least one unnecessary but sufficient configuration of conditions that tends to result in the occurrence of university technology transfer. However, under certain circumstances, a technology maturity level of at least TRL-6 could be a sufficient but unnecessary condition for the occurrence of university technology transfer. These findings have several important implications. First, they provide support for the notion that university technology transfer is subject to causal complexity. Moreover, it may be possible to increase the incidence of university technology transfer in the United States by implementing public policy and practices that explicitly take technology maturity level into consideration.
The current practices of the university technology transfer profession seem to reflect the belief that the chances for success are greatly improved when faculty inventors employ their social capital to facilitate the process. However, this notion has not been extensively investigated directly. There is a gap in the university technology transfer literature regarding our understanding of faculty inventor social capital in the context of the occurrence of technology transfer outcomes. The aim of this study was to understand whether the use of faculty inventor social capital is a causal condition for the occurrence of university technology transfer. This question was examined using a multiple case study approach and the qualitative comparative analysis (QCA) method. The data were generated by collecting information on 21 cases that occurred during or around calendar year 2019 in which a private sector organization considered whether to obtain and assimilate a technology that was created at a university in the United States of America. The results of the study suggest that the use of faculty inventor social capital is not a necessary, sufficient, or INUS condition for the occurrence of university technology transfer.
Despite significant government intervention, the incidence of technology transfer in the United States of America is still less than desired. There appears to be policy options to address this problem, but policymakers have not pursued them. One conjecture is that notions of what are politically legitimate actions are restraining policymakers from pursuing certain kinds of technology transfer policies. This paper presents the results of an examination of two questions. First, how have the current conceptualizations of political legitimacy potentially contributed to the lack of public policies that directly mitigate circumstances that hinder the transfer of technologies from universities and federal laboratories to the private sector? And second, what alternative conceptualization of political legitimacy can potentially encourage lawmakers to pursue such public policies? The primary conclusions are that the concept of political legitimacy has been reified on a normative basis and does not align with the behaviors of constituents. Moreover, current conceptualizations are potentially restraining policymakers in several ways that curb their willingness to pursue certain kinds of technology transfer policies. The paper presents an alternative conceptualization of political legitimacy that might enable policymakers to pursue a more diverse array of public policies that will more directly address factors that curtail technology transfer.
Facilitating the use of academic research outputs, namely new scientific discoveries and technologies made or created by university researchers, to benefit society has become a core function of universities around the world. Today, scholars and practitioners refer to this activity as “technology transfer” or “technology commercialization”. The role of universities in the commercialization of academic research outputs resides at the nexus of discourse about the widening gap between academic knowledge production and its societal impact. Although there are vast literatures about the university as a social institution and university activities that facilitate commercialization of academic research outputs, there is sparse discourse that directly examines the evolution of universities’ roles in the commercialization of academic research outputs in the context of the expansion of the mission of institutions of higher education. This paper aims to fill this gap. While the paper examines the topic primarily from a Western perspective, specifically from the viewpoint of the United States of America (USA), it provides points of comparison by briefly summarizing the history, evolution, and current status of university technology transfer in select countries around the world. It concludes by considering what the future may hold for the role of U.S. universities in the commercialization of academic research outputs.