IntroductionTrap Neuter Return (TNR) programs exist in large part to reduce population size and growth rate by decreasing reproduction.(Jones and Downs, 2011; Levy et al., 2003; Levy and Crawford, 2004; Schmidt et al., 2009; Spehar and Wolf, 2017) Reductions in population size are desirable due to concerns regarding wildlife predation, public health and nuisance factors.(Schaffner, 2017) In addition to reducing population size or growth, TNR is also promoted as a method for improving cat welfare.(Finkler et al., 2011; Griffin, 2001; Gunther et al., 2018; Levy and Crawford, 2004; Nutter et al., 2004; Schmidt et al., 2009) TNR of free-roaming cats may decrease predation as compared to populations that are not sterilized or provided anthropogenic food sources.(Cove et al., 2018) TNR allows for the provision of veterinary care, including vaccination against infectious disease, treatment of injuries and illnesses, and humane euthanasia for animals found to be suffering. It is also a method for promoting humane communities by avoiding euthanasia as a means of population control or nuisance abatement.Multiple studies have shown TNR to be effective in reducing population size or curtailing population growth, but they are complicated by the fact that many colonies are not geographically restricted.(Levy et al., 2003; Miller et al., 2014; Natoli et al., 2006; Schmidt et al., 2009; Scott et al., 2002) The presence of a long-term TNR program with both population level and detailed individual information was a unique opportunity to study the impacts of sustained TNR on a geographically isolated population of free-roaming cats.The objective of this study was to evaluate the effect of a long-term (23 year) TNR program on the population size of community cats in the Ocean Reef Community and to describe the demographic composition and outcome of cats enrolled in the TNR program. These findings can be used by shelters and other invested parties to estimate the impact of TNR on cat welfare and provide input parameters for mathematical models used to estimate the impact of TNR programs on community cat populations.Material and methodsStudy communityThe community of Ocean Reef occupies approximately 2,500 acres on the northernmost tip of Key Largo in the Florida Keys. It is a peninsula approximately four miles long and a mile wide, with a single gated road staffed 24 hours a day leading into the community. This private club is bordered on three sides by water and on the fourth by protected state and federal conservation land. Ocean Reef contains approximately 1,700 homes, although much of the occupation is seasonal and there is a correspondingly large number of seasonal workers. Five unaltered cats were brought to Ocean Reef by a groundskeeper to perform rat control in the 1960s. While the cats controlled the rat problem successfully, by the 1980s, the number of cats had grown large enough to be themselves considered a nuisance to the increasing number of residents. Over 2,000 cats are stated anecdotally to have been present in the 1980s. Population control measures, which included lethal methods, were instituted to control the cat population. As an alternative to lethal measures, an individual resident began to trap cats and bring them to a local veterinarian for neutering. In 1995, the Ocean Reef Community Association (ORCA) supported the opening of a spay/neuter clinic in Ocean Reef and the formation of the ORCAT program to provide sterilization, care and feeding to the free-roaming cats.(Kimball, 2009) In 2006, the Grayvik Animal Care Center opened, which contains a full-service veterinary and grooming clinic for the pets of residents in addition to a cat adoption center and sanctuary. There has been a single individual in the role of director of the ORCAT program since its inception, maintaining feeding stations, creating individual cat medical records and performing episodic surveys of the population. This position reports to the Vice President of Ocean Reef and is accountable for annual goals. Only two veterinarians have been the main provider of services for the population, one from 1995-1998, and the other since 1998.Surveys of the cat population were performed between 1999 and 2013. Documented population surveys were not executed after 2013, although cats continued to be cared for and TNR efforts continued. Surveys were recorded by marking feeding stations on a paper map and recording the total number of cats per feeding station. The number and location of feeding stations was determined by homeowner preference, convenience, and minimization of feeding station colony size. The initial number of feeding stations was large in order to facilitate complete trapping of colonies, which was easier with smaller numbers of cats per colony, and to minimize fighting between cats. All cat counts were performed by the caretaker.Cats were trapped when un-marked individuals were noted at feeding stations, or when previously sterilized cats required veterinary care. Individual medical records for each cat were maintained in paper files. Each cat’s visit (check-in to check-out at the medical center) was documented in the medical record. At their first visit, cats were routinely neutered, marked by ear-tipping, vaccinated with FVRCP, rabies and FeLV vaccines, and dewormed (pyrantel pamoate, praziquantel). They were also tested for FIV antibodies and FeLV antigen; cats that tested positive for either retrovirus were typically euthanized prior to administration of routine preventive care. Cats were determined to be euthanized for retrovirus status if they were euthanized concurrently with a positive test and there was no evidence that the cat was otherwise significantly unhealthy. A date of birth was estimated through the joint effort of the caretaker and veterinarian. Upon re-trapping, cats were provided with vaccine boosters for FVRCP, rabies and FeLV and medical care as required. Microchipping of cats...