In recent years, digital endoscopy has established as key technology for medical screenings and minimally invasive surgery. Since then, various research communities with manifold backgrounds have picked up on the idea of processing and automatically analyzing the inherently available video signal that is produced by the endoscopic camera. Proposed works mainly include image processing techniques, pattern recognition, machine learning methods and Computer Vision algorithms. While most contributions deal with real-time assistance at procedure time, the post-procedural processing of recorded videos is still in its infancy. Many post-processing problems are based on typical Multimedia methods like indexing, retrieval, summarization and video interaction, but have only been sparsely addressed so far for this domain. The goals of this survey are (1) to introduce this research field to a broader audience in the Multimedia community to stimulate further research, (2) to describe domain-specific characteristics of endoscopic videos that need to be addressed in a pre-processing step, and (3) to systematically bring together the very diverse research results for the first time to provide a broader overview of related research that is currently not perceived as belonging together.
The last decade has seen innovations that make video recording, manipulation, storage and sharing easier than ever before, thus impacting many areas of life. New video retrieval scenarios emerged as well, which challenge the state-of-the-art video retrieval approaches. Despite recent advances in content analysis, video retrieval can still benefit from involving the human user in the loop. We present our experience with a class of interactive video retrieval scenarios and our methodology to stimulate the evolution of new interactive video retrieval approaches. More specifically, the Video Browser Showdown evaluation campaign is thoroughly analyzed, focusing on the years 2015-2017. Evaluation scenarios, objectives and metrics are presented, complemented by the results of the annual evaluations. The results reveal promising interactive video retrieval techniques adopted by the most successful tools and confirm assumptions about the different complexity of various types of interactive retrieval scenarios. A comparison of the interactive retrieval tools with automatic approaches (including fully automatic and manual query formulation) participating in the TRECVID 2016 Ad-hoc Video Search (AVS) task is discussed. Finally, based on the results of data analysis, a substantial revision of the evaluation methodology for the following years of the Video Browser Showdown is provided.
Despite the fact that automatic content analysis has made remarkable progress over the last decade - mainly due to significant advances in machine learning - interactive video retrieval is still a very challenging problem, with an increasing relevance in practical applications. The Video Browser Showdown (VBS) is an annual evaluation competition that pushes the limits of interactive video retrieval with state-of-the-art tools, tasks, data, and evaluation metrics. In this paper, we analyse the results and outcome of the 8th iteration of the VBS in detail. We first give an overview of the novel and considerably larger V3C1 dataset and the tasks that were performed during VBS 2019. We then go on to describe the search systems of the six international teams in terms of features and performance. And finally, we perform an in-depth analysis of the per-team success ratio and relate this to the search strategies that were applied, the most popular features, and problems that were experienced. A large part of this analysis was conducted based on logs that were collected during the competition itself. This analysis gives further insights into the typical search behavior and differences between expert and novice users. Our evaluation shows that textual search and content browsing are the most important aspects in terms of logged user interactions. Furthermore, we observe a trend towards deep learning based features, especially in the form of labels generated by artificial neural networks. But nevertheless, for some tasks, very specific content-based search features are still being used. We expect these findings to contribute to future improvements of interactive video search systems.
Videos of endoscopic surgery are used for education of medical experts, analysis in medical research, and documentation for everyday clinical life. Hand-crafted image descriptors lack the capabilities of a semantic classification of surgical actions and video shots of anatomical structures. In this work, we investigate how well single-frame convolutional neural networks (CNN) for semantic shot classification in gynecologic surgery work. Together with medical experts, we manually annotate hours of raw endoscopic gynecologic surgery videos showing endometriosis treatment and myoma resection of over 100 patients. The cleaned ground truth dataset comprises 9 h of annotated video material (from 111 different recordings). We use the well-known CNN architectures AlexNet and GoogLeNet and train these architectures for both, surgical actions and anatomy, from scratch. Furthermore, we extract high-level features from AlexNet with weights from a pre-trained model from the Caffe model zoo and feed them to an SVM classifier. Our evaluation shows that we reach an average recall of .697 and .515 for classification of anatomical structures and surgical actions respectively using off-the-shelf CNN features. Using GoogLeNet, we achieve a mean recall of .782 and .617 for classification of anatomical structures and surgical actions respectively. With AlexNet the achieved recall is .615 for anatomical structures and .469 for surgical action classification respectively. The main conclusion of our work is that advances in general image classification methods transfer to the domain of endoscopic surgery videos in gynecology. This is relevant as this domain is different from natural images, e.g. it is distinguished by smoke, reflections, or a limited amount of colors.
26 January 2022 in International Journal of Multimedia Information Retrieval