Background: Instruments with sufficient diagnostic accuracy are better able to detect healthcare workers (HCWs) who are at risk of psychological distress. The objective of this review is to examine the diagnostic accuracy and measurement properties of psychological distress instruments in HCWs. Methods: We searched in Embase, Medline and PsycINFO from 2000 to February 2021. We included studies if they reported on the diagnostic accuracy of an instrument. To assess the methodological quality of the studies with regard to diagnostic accuracy, we used the Quality Assessment of Diagnostic Accuracy Studies and, for the measurement properties, the Consensus-based Standards for the Selection of Health Measurement Instruments (COSMIN). Results: Seventeen studies reporting on eight instruments were included. Overall, the methodological quality assessing the diagnostic accuracy and measurement properties was low, specifically for items addressing the domain ‘index test’. The items addressing ‘reference standard’, ‘time and flow’ and ‘patient selection’ were mostly unclear. The criterion validity of the single-item burnout, the Burnout–Thriving Index, and the Physician Well-Being Index (PWBI) was sufficient, with area under the curve ranging from 0.75 to 0.92 and sensitivity 71–84%, respectively. Conclusion: Our findings indicate that it is questionable whether screening for HCWs at risk of psychological distress can be performed sufficiently with the included instruments due to the low numbers of studies per instrument and the low methodological quality.
16 March 2022 in International Archives of Occupational and Environmental Health
Purposes: Healthcare workers are at risk of stress-related disorders. Risk communication can be an effective preventive health measure for some health risks, but is not yet common in the prevention of stress-related disorders in an occupational healthcare setting. The overall aim is to examine whether risk communication was part of interventions aimed at the prevention of stress-related disorders in healthcare workers. Method: We performed a scoping review using the framework of Arksey and O’Malley. We searched in Medline, Web of Science and PsychInfo for studies reporting on preventive interventions of stress-related disorders in healthcare workers between 2005 and December 2020. Studies were included when the intervention reported on at least one element of risk communication and one goal. We predefined four elements of risk communication: risk perception, communication of early stress symptoms, risk factors and prevention; and three goals: inform, stimulate informed decision-making and motivate action. Results: We included 23 studies that described 17 interventions. None of the included interventions were primarily developed as risk communication interventions, but all addressed the goals. Two interventions used all four elements of risk communication. The prominent mode of delivery was face to face, mostly delivered by researchers. Early stress symptoms and risk factors were measured by surveys. Conclusions: Risk communication on risk factors and early signs of stress-related disorders is not that well studied and evaluated in an occupational healthcare setting. Overall, the content of the communication was not based on the risk perception of the healthcare workers, which limited the likelihood of them taking action.
1 December 2024 in Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine
Background: The objectives of this study are to explore healthcare workers’ (HCWs’) mental models regarding psychological distress and to compare these with that of experts. Methods: Semistructured interviews were conducted (n = 28 HCWs, n = 13 experts). The topic list encompassed risk perception, early stress symptoms, causes, consequences, and preventive measures of psychological distress. Interviews were transcribed verbatim and thematically analyzed using MAXQDA (VERBI Software, Berlin). Results: Similarities were found in risk perception, symptoms, causes, and consequences. Differences arose in HCWs’ reliance on personal experiences and values versus experts’ scientific perspective. Preventive measures also showed discrepancies. Variation within HCWs was found on all aspects of their mental model. Conclusion: For effective preventive interventions regarding psychological distress, experts should consider HCWs’ personal values and experiences, acknowledging the variation in their mental models. This approach may enhance HCWs’ engagement in preventive behaviors.
Backgrounds: The detection of biomarkers of a stress response in the stratum corneum (SC) could be used as objective assessment of early stress symptoms and monitoring of stress reduction interventions in health care workers (HCWs).Aim: The aim of this study is to explore SC biomarkers of immune and hormonal response and skin barrier for assessment of psychological distress (PD) in HCWs.Methods: Twenty‐five female HCWs and 25 non‐HCWs participated. SC samples were collected using adhesive tapes at baseline and 3−5 days later (T1). We analyzed 24 biomarkers (immunological, vascular, hormones, and natural moisturizing factors). Stress symptoms were assessed using three scales of Copenhagen Psychosocial Questionnaire. The study involved: identifying SC biomarkers, correlating stress symptoms and biomarkers at baseline and T1, examining stress symptoms between the groups with a Mann‐Whitney test, comparing stress symptoms and biomarkers between groups using Ordinary Least Regression and investigating temporal variability of SC biomarkers at baseline and T1 using a Wilcoxon‐signed rank.Results: Fourteen SC biomarkers were identified. We found correlations between general stress and “IL18” (r = 0.55) physical stress and “IL1b” (r = 0.36) and cognitive stress and “MIP3a” (r = 0.38) at baseline and general stress and cortisol (r = −0.49), physical stress and cortisol (r = −0.60) and cortisone (r = −0.67) at T1. We found no differences in stress symptoms and biomarkers between the groups, except for “MIP3a” at baseline. Differences in the biomarker levels between two time points were found for “TARC,” “VEGFA,” “ILRA,” “IL1RA/IL1a,” “NMF,” and “DHEA.”Conclusion: The SC can be suitable biological material to assess biomarkers related to immune response, hormonal response, and skin barrier function. The SC biomarkers, showed strong, moderate and weak correlations with stress symptoms. Notably, these associations include cytokines of innate immunity and well‐known stress hormones, cortisol and cortisone.
Healthcare workers (HCWs) are at risk for work-related stress, but interventions to support early help-seeking are often limited. This study aims to evalua
Stress-related occupational diseases in the Netherlands: How are these occupational diseases reported by occupational physicians, what is the incidence and what are causes? This paper has two purposes. The first purpose is to describe the procedure of occupational physicians when reporting stress-related occupational diseases. The second purpose is to provide an overview of the incidence and causes of stress-related occupational diseases in the Netherlands, as registered at the Netherlands Center for Occupational Diseases. The Netherlands Center for Occupational diseases registers on a national level all occupational diseases as reported by occupational physicians. According to the Dutch Working Conditions Regulations, an occupational disease is “a disease or condition resulting from an exposure that has predominantly occurred at work or in working conditions”. The occupational physicians registered an occupational disease based on a clinical diagnosis and a structured six step plan. In the period 2020-2024, occupational physicians registered on average 1583 mental occupational diseases per year. Stress-related disorder and burn-out were the most frequently registered occupational diseases. ‘Having too much work’ was mentioned most often as the cause of both stress-related disorder and burn-out, followed by ‘little social support from the supervisor’. These numbers are much lower compared to self-reported occupational stress-related disorders/burnout in the Netherlands Working Conditions Survey. This contrast is partly explained by differences in measurement methods and by the fact that not all workers have an occupational physician.