Jerusalem Merkebu

Jerusalem Merkebu


Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

8Years (2019-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
5 September 2022 in Perspectives on Medical Education
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
EBErin S. Barry
Erin S. Barry
JMJerusalem Merkebu
Jerusalem Merkebu
LVLara Varpio
Lara Varpio
Introduction Researchers and practitioners rely on literature reviews to synthesize large bodies of knowledge. Many types of literature reviews have been developed, each targeting a specific purpose. However, these syntheses are hampered if the review type’s paradigmatic roots, methods, and markers of rigor are only vaguely understood. One literature review type whose methodology has yet to be elucidated is the state-of-the-art (SotA) review. If medical educators are to harness SotA reviews to generate knowledge syntheses, we must understand and articulate the paradigmatic roots of, and methods for, conducting SotA reviews. Methods We reviewed 940 articles published between 2014–2021 labeled as SotA reviews. We (a) identified all SotA methods-related resources, (b) examined the foundational principles and techniques underpinning the reviews, and (c) combined our findings to inductively analyze and articulate the philosophical foundations, process steps, and markers of rigor. Results In the 940 articles reviewed, nearly all manuscripts (98%) lacked citations for how to conduct a SotA review. The term “state of the art” was used in 4 different ways. Analysis revealed that SotA articles are grounded in relativism and subjectivism. Discussion This article provides a 6-step approach for conducting SotA reviews. SotA reviews offer an interpretive synthesis that describes: This is where we are now. This is how we got here. This is where we could be going. This chronologically rooted narrative synthesis provides a methodology for reviewing large bodies of literature to explore why and how our current knowledge has developed and to offer new research directions.

12 February 2024 in Advances in Health Sciences Education
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
JMJerusalem Merkebu
Jerusalem Merkebu
MVMario Veen
Mario Veen
SHShera Hosseini
Shera Hosseini
LVLara Varpio
Lara Varpio
The concepts of metacognitive reflection, reflection, and metacognition are distinct but have undergone shifts in meaning as they migrated into medical education. Conceptual clarity is essential to the construction of the knowledge base of medical education and its educational interventions. We conducted a theoretical integrative review across diverse bodies of literature with the goal of understanding what metacognitive reflection is. We searched PubMed, Embase, CINAHL, PsychInfo, and Web of Science databases, including all peer-reviewed research articles and theoretical papers as well as book chapters that addressed the topic, with no limitations for date, language, or location. A total of 733 articles were identified and 87 were chosen after careful review and application of exclusion criteria. The work of conceptually and empirically delineating metacognitive reflection has begun. Contributions have been made to root metacognitive reflection in the concept of metacognition and moving beyond it to engage in cycles of reflection. Other work has underscored its affective component, transformational nature, and contextual factors. Despite this merging of threads to develop a richer conceptualization, a theory of how metacognitive reflection works is elusive. Debates address whether metacognition drives reflection or vice versa. It has also been suggested that learners evolve along on a continuum from thinking, to task-related reflection, to self-reflection, and finally to metacognitive reflection. Based on prior theory and research, as well as the findings of this review, we propose the following conceptualization: Metacognitive reflection involves heightened internal observation, awareness, monitoring, and regulation of our own knowledge, experiences, and emotions by questioning and examining cognition and emotional processes to continually refine and enhance our perspectives and decisions while thoughtfully accounting for context. We argue that metacognitive reflection brings a shift in perspective and can support valuable reconceptualization for lifelong learning.

28 April 2020 in Diagnosis
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
JMJerusalem Merkebu
Jerusalem Merkebu
MBMichael Battistone
Michael Battistone
KMKevin McMains
Kevin McMains
KMKathrine McOwen
Kathrine McOwen
CWCatherine Witkop
Catherine Witkop
SDSteven J. Durning
Steven J. Durning
The diagnostic error crisis suggests a shift in how we view clinical reasoning and may be vital for transforming how we view clinical encounters. Building upon the literature, we propose clinical reasoning and error are context-specific and proceed to advance a family of theories that represent a model outlining the complex interplay of physician, patient, and environmental factors driving clinical reasoning and error. These contemporary social cognitive theories (i.e. embedded cognition, ecological psychology, situated cognition, and distributed cognition) can emphasize the dynamic interactions occurring amongst participants in particular settings. The situational determinants that contribute to diagnostic error are also explored.

1 December 2022 in Journal of Graduate Medical Education
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
EBErin S. Barry
Erin S. Barry
JMJerusalem Merkebu
Jerusalem Merkebu
LVLara Varpio
Lara Varpio
Sometimes the literature review you need isn't one that answers a narrow question: for that we would use a systematic review to determine, for example, the best workplace-based assessment tool for a pediatric residency program. Sometimes educators are not interested in how individual theories addressing a phenomenon align and differ, an answer you would find via an integrative review. Instead, educators may need to know how the modern conceptualization of a specific phenomenon became the norm—including the history that informed current understanding, what that understanding is, and what might develop in the future. For example, to understand resident assessment, you might want to know its history, what the current orientation is, and what future expansions might occur. To answer such questions, educators and researchers turn to State-of-the-Art (SotA) literature reviews.SotA literature reviews provide a time-based overview of the current state of knowledge about a phenomenon and suggest directions for future research.1 They are organized in relation to how the understanding of the phenomena has evolved over time. Structured around turning points in the history of knowledge development, SotA reviews articulate: This is where we are now. This is how we got here. This is where we should go next. By synthesizing how the main characteristics of a topic have changed over time to give rise to current understandings, SotA reviews offer a modern knowledge synthesis that “tend[s] to address more current matters in contrast to other combined retrospective and current [literature review] approaches.”1 SotA reviews are used prolifically in many fields, such as biomedical science, medicine, and engineering, to provide information on the current understanding of a topic, the historical roots that shaped the understanding, and potential next directions for future research.Given their time-based and turning point-based orientations, SotA reviews are inherently different from other types of knowledge synthesis. For example, systematic reviews focus on specific research questions that are narrow in scope; in contrast, SotA reviews present a broader historical overview of knowledge development. Scoping reviews focus on mapping the present state of knowledge about a phenomenon, including, for example, the data currently available, the nature of that data, and the gaps in knowledge. Conversely, SotA reviews offer interpretations of the historical progression of knowledge relating to a phenomenon, centered on significant shifts that occurred during that history.2SotA reviews are especially useful within graduate medical education due to their purpose: these knowledge syntheses focus on the turning points that ended older ways of thinking and gave rise to current insights, while also evaluating where the field should go next. Thus, by conducting this type of review, educators and researchers in graduate medical education will be positioned to understand and apply modern best practices and to influence future directions. The Box illustrates the Case of Dr. Smith, which continues throughout this Journal of Graduate Medical Education (JGME) special review series, considering the same question using different review methodologies.Although SotA reviews are frequently published in peer-reviewed journals, there are few descriptions of how to conduct these knowledge syntheses, their markers of methodical rigor, and their reporting standards. We set out to address this gap by: (1) analyzing all publicly available and indexed methods-related publications describing SotA reviews, and (2) studying all SotA reviews (n=398) published between 2016 and 2020 to identify the foundational principles and techniques underpinning them.3 Through this work, we developed a 6-stage process for conducting SotA reviews,3 which aligns with the existing brief descriptions.1,2,4-7 These 6 stages are summarized in a short how-to guide accompanying this article.8 Here, we explain the orienting premises that shape SotA reviews.SotA literature reviews are founded on the principle that there is no single objectively true or correct synthesis of a body of literature. Instead, SotA reviews rest on the premise that literature is open for interpretation and that the context in which the review is conducted will shape the synthesis developed. SotA literature reviews are steeped in a relativist ontology: the nature of reality is socially and experientially informed and constructed. Consequently, SotA reviews do not require the literature included in the review to use identical methodology to support meta-analyses to generate a right answer. That is, not all findings synthesized in the review need to be carried out in the same way to enable cross-study data amalgamations. Instead—because SotA reviews assume that multiple different understandings of a phenomenon are available—this synthesis does not exclude research using different methodologies.In terms of epistemology (the origins, nature, and limits of knowledge about reality), SotA literature reviews embrace subjectivism, the premise that knowledge generated from the review is a construction, not an objective fact. The knowledge generated through the review is value-dependent; it grows out of the subjective interpretations of the researchers who performed the synthesis. SotA reviews generate an interpretation of the literature informed by the expertise, experiences, and social context of the review team. Furthermore, the knowledge developed through SotA reviews is informed by the point in time when the review was conducted. A SotA review from 2000 reflects the contemporary knowledge of the year 2000; a SotA review from 2022 would report different knowledge reflecting that year's perspectives.SotA literature reviews seek (1) to create a critical summary of contemporary thinking about a topic; (2) to describe historical progressions and patterns in the literature; (3)...

5 April 2023 in Frontiers in Education
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
JMJerusalem Merkebu
Jerusalem Merkebu
AKAnastasia Kitsantas
Anastasia Kitsantas
SDSteven J. Durning
Steven J. Durning
TMTinglan Ma
Tinglan Ma
Introduction: This paper explores the trilateral relationship among metacognition, emotional regulation, and reflection under the integrative framework of metacognitive reflection.Methods: Data were gathered from undergraduate participants at a large state university on the East Coast (N= 493). The quantitative data were derived from: the Metacognitive Awareness Inventory (MAI), the Self-Reflection and Insight Scale (SR-IS), and the Cognitive Reappraisal Scale (ERQ). Data analysis consisted of structural equation modeling (SEM) in which the associations between latent constructs were tested. Emotional regulation and metacognition were found to be positively and significantly related to the latent construct of reflection.Results: SEM results indicated that emotional regulation (which emerged as the strongest predictor) together with metacognition predicted 52% of the variance in reflection. Moreover, the latent moderation model showed that metacognition significantly moderated the relationship between emotional regulation and reflection such that emotional regulation was a strong and positive predictor of reflection when students simultaneously showed high levels of metacognition. In contrast, emotional regulation did not significantly predict reflection for students with low levels of metacognition. The alternative model showed that emotional regulation also moderated the relationship between metacognition and reflection such that metacognition contributed to reflection the most when participants simultaneously showed high levels of emotional regulation.Discussion: These findings suggest the interaction between metacognition and emotional regulation is critical in the gamut of reflection.

1 December 2022 in Journal of Graduate Medical Education
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
EBErin S. Barry
Erin S. Barry
JMJerusalem Merkebu
Jerusalem Merkebu
LVLara Varpio
Lara Varpio
This article provides a brief introduction to critical steps needed for conducting a high-quality State-of-the-Art (SotA) literature review, one that will add to our understanding of the phenomenon under study. This introduction complements another article in this issue, which discusses the purposes, underlying foundations, strengths, and weakness of SotA reviews in more detail.1The fundamental purpose of SotA literature reviews is to create a 3-part argument about the state of knowledge for a specific phenomenon: This is where we are now. This is how we got here. This is where we could go next (Table 1). Below is a 6-stage process for conducting a SotA literature review.2 To support this process, questions for guiding each of the 6 stages are provided in Table 2.It is important to identify individuals who will be a part of the research team. While a SotA review can be conducted by a single author, most SotA reviews harness the perspectives of an interdisciplinary team to generate rich interpretations of the literature. The team should also include a medical librarian to help with developing the search strategy.In Stage 1, the research team determines the initial research question that incorporates the phenomenon to be addressed in the SotA literature review. It is important to clearly define the field of knowledge and/or practice that will be targeted.Stage 2 determines the time frame that will define “state-of-the-art” for the research question defined in Stage 1. In Stage 2, the research team should engage in a broad overview of the literature to develop an understanding of the phenomenon's historical development (ie, seminal articles). This process will shape the research team's focus vis-à-vis the pivotal moments in history when the thinking about the phenomenon changed and the time frame for contemporary thinking (ie, the date marking the beginning of this is where we are now thinking). At the end of Stage 2, the research team should be able to justify why a specific year (ie, turning point in history) is chosen to mark the beginning of state-of-the-art thinking around the phenomenon.Based on the developments from Stages 1 and 2, the research team will revise and finalize the research question(s) to determine what needs to be included in the search strategy and analyses. The revised research question(s) and justification for the timeline must be reported in the article.Next, a search strategy is developed, enabling the research team to construct the corpus of literature to be included in the SotA review. This involves determining which database(s) to search and when to set the start date for the review. Since the review needs to describe this is how we got here, it must include literature that predates the this is where we are now time frame determined in Stage 2. Stage 4 is an iterative process of testing and revising the search strategy to capture pertinent literature required to meet the purpose of the SotA review. It is important to note that the search goal is not to review all pertinent literature in the SotA review; instead, the goal is to include relevant literature to describe a historical evolution in the field's thinking about a topic. The final search strategy must be included in the manuscript. If possible, a librarian should be consulted when developing the search strategy. A software program such as Covidence may be useful to help organize and share all articles with the research team.Analysis of the included literature is an inductive process where the research team reads and reflects on the articles and constructs an interpretation of the historical development of how the specific phenomenon is understood in the field. The research team should begin by reading each included article to become familiar with this literature and be able to identify similarities among the articles, ways of thinking that have shaped current understandings, assumptions underpinning changes in understandings over time, and gaps and assumptions in the current knowledge.Next, the research team can generate the premises that fit the purpose of a SotA review (ie, creating an understanding of the topic, constructing a history of knowledge development that gave rise to this modern thinking, and developing suggestions for future research). In this stage, the research team should highlight specific articles that either support or contradict its premises.The final step in Stage 5 is to verify the thoroughness and strength of the research team's interpretations. This can be done by selecting different articles and examining if they are congruent with the team's interpretations. The research team may also seek out additional literature that offers alternative interpretations to convey that their summary successfully refutes conflicting interpretations. The goal of this verification work is not to engage in a triangulation process for objectivity or for external confirmation; instead, this process is to help the research team ensure that they have successfully explained their interpretations in a way that supports or refutes the interpretations offered by others.The SotA manuscript should offer insights into the subjectivity of the research team by describing members who comprise the team, applications of their expertise, and how these informed their interpretations of the data. This reflexivity description will help readers understand the perspectives that informed the interpretation offered by the research team.