MERYEM ELİF ÇELEBİ KARAKÖK

Dr. MERYEM ELİF ÇELEBİ KARAKÖK

Architecture, Akdeniz University, Antalya, Turkey (Türkiye)
orcid

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

9Years (2018-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
18 April 2023 in Sustainability
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
SBSEBNEM ERTAS BESIR
SEBNEM ERTAS BESIR
MKMERYEM ELİF ÇELEBİ KARAKÖK
MERYEM ELİF ÇELEBİ KARAKÖK
This study aims to determine the necessary parameters to ensure sustainable conservation in the adaptive reuse of industrial heritage and create a decision-making model. This study included the selection of the sample industrial heritage, determining the necessary parameters, percentage frequency analysis (PFA) of the industrial heritages in relation to the parameters, interpreting the percentage frequency results by comparing them, and developing the decision-making model. The decisions of the architectural heritage conservation organizations ICOMOS, TICCIH, and UNESCO were used to determine the conservation parameters. The reuse parameters were determined based on sustainability principles, since the adaptive reuse of historical buildings is also the subject of sustainability. The obtained parameters were converted to percentage values after being made numerically significant by two different percentage frequency analyses: conservation and reuse. Each sample used in the model was considered successful in various sources, rewarded, and praised in the literature and media. If we accept 50% as an average value, there are only four industrial heritages which are over 50% for the conservation percentage frequency analysis, but there are nine industrial heritages which are over 50% for the reuse percentage frequency analysis. On the other hand, it is written in the article that the aim is to catch 100%. Therefore, maybe it can be said that we cannot only conserve, but also fail to use. The model developed in this study will serve as a guide in establishing the conservation –use balance of project decisions as well as in objectively evaluating current practices.

5 May 2023 in Sustainability
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
MKMERYEM ELİF ÇELEBİ KARAKÖK
MERYEM ELİF ÇELEBİ KARAKÖK
SBSEBNEM ERTAS BESIR
SEBNEM ERTAS BESIR
This study aims to identify tourism usage strategies for the protection and socioeconomic sustainable development of monumental structures that maintain their functional continuity. The results revealed that some strategies provide significant opportunities in socioeconomic terms if they maintain a structure’s original function; however, some uses pose a significant threat in the case of functional continuity. The main contribution of this work is the definition of monumental structures in relation to adaptive reuse and strategic planning tools (SWOT). The spatial and functional change of the Hacı Ali Ağa Bath was examined chronologically in the first stage. An external expert group determined 41 factors consisting of functional, social, and economic return concepts revealed by the literature review in the second stage. These factors were then evaluated by internal experts using SWOT analyses. The structure’s formation since 2006 was revealed through analysis. The cultural heritage significance of the hammam culture is the function determined as the strength, whereas the functional changes were determined as the weakness. The building became idle due to the pandemic, thus bringing this situation to light. The importance of the original function was placed on the agenda by the general administration, which is regarded as a prominent opportunity to conduct an assessment. The inability of all functions to establish a relationship with tourism has been recognized as a significant threat. Strong opportunities, strong threats, and usage strategies are provided for monumental structures that maintain their functional continuity.

24 November 2025 in Sustainability
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
GAGizem Nazmiye Arı
Gizem Nazmiye Arı
MKMERYEM ELİF ÇELEBİ KARAKÖK
MERYEM ELİF ÇELEBİ KARAKÖK
This study introduces a Fuzzy–AHP–based analytical model for the quantitative assessment of authenticity loss in adaptive reuse practices, addressing a persistent gap in heritage research—the lack of reproducible mathematical frameworks capable of linking authenticity evaluation with sustainability indicators. Unlike previous studies that approach authenticity conceptually or qualitatively, this research develops a hybrid decision-support system that translates both intangible and tangible heritage attributes into measurable linguistic variables, enabling systematic and comparable authenticity assessments. The model was applied to ten traditional houses in Alanya, Türkiye, representing different adaptive reuse types (residential, cultural, commercial, and touristic). A total of 17 experts contributed to the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) weighting stage, producing a Consistency Ratio of 0.0156 (<0.10), and 8 experts provided scoring inputs for the fuzzy system. The fuzzy inference system was implemented in MATLAB R2023a, incorporating seven main criteria and three subcriteria, nine input variables, five linguistic categories, and a rule base of 3400 fuzzy rules. Membership functions were defined within the 0–100 numerical range, and the centroid defuzzification method was used to compute final authenticity values. Model reliability was confirmed through Kendall’s W = 0.87, demonstrating strong inter-rater agreement. Results show that buildings retaining their original residential function achieved the highest authenticity scores (Final Score ≈ 86), while structures converted into boutique hotels or restaurants exhibited substantial authenticity losses (Final Score range: 25–45), especially within Group 2 criteria (environment, function, spirit, and intangible cultural heritage). This divergence illustrates a sustainability paradox: although adaptive reuse prolongs building life cycles and reduces embodied carbon, it may simultaneously undermine cultural sustainability when authenticity is significantly compromised. The proposed Fuzzy–AHP authenticity model provides a replicable, transparent, and empirically validated tool for evaluating the effects of functional transformation within a sustainability framework. By quantifying the relationship between adaptive reuse types and authenticity retention, the study contributes to sustainable heritage management research and supports the implementation of SDG 11—Sustainable Cities and Communities.

31 October 2021 in Düzce Üniversitesi Bilim ve Teknoloji Dergisi
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
MKMERYEM ELİF ÇELEBİ KARAKÖK
MERYEM ELİF ÇELEBİ KARAKÖK
GAGizem Nazmiye Arı
Gizem Nazmiye Arı
Kent merkezlerindeki tarihi dokularda günümüzde rant marjları çok yükselmiş, tarihi yapılara turizm ve ticaret işlevleri verme eğilimi artmıştır. Yeniden işlevlendirme adı verilen bu uygulama aslında terk edilmiş ya da özgün işlevini devam ettirmesi mümkün olmayan yapıları, yeni bir işlevle kullanımını sağlayarak gelecek kuşaklara aktarmak için geliştirilmiş bir koruma yöntemidir. Ancak bu yöntem günümüzde sanki bir tasarım modeli gibi kullanılarak tarihi yapıların özgün değerlerinden çok fazla kayıplara neden olmaktadır. Koruma yasasındaki esneklik, sayısal nicelik ve şahıs mülkiyetlerinde olmaları gibi sebeplerle yeniden işlevlendirilerek özgünlük değerlerinden en çok kayıplar veren yapılar geleneksel konutlardır. Tarihi yapılar ve bu yapıların oluşturduğu tarihi çevre, bölgeye özgü fiziksel ve kültürel özellikler sonucu oluşmuş geleneksel mimari örneklerdir. Özellikle geleneksel konutlar bulunduğu bölgedeki günlük yaşam ve kültürü hakkında önemli veriler sunan tarihi belgelerdir. Bu nedenle diğer tarihi yapılar gibi geleneksel konut yapılarının da özgünlüklerinin korunması ve gelecek kuşaklara aktarılması önem arz etmektedir. Yeniden işlevlendirme ile özgün değerlerini yitiren tarihi çevrelerden birisi de Antalya'nın önemli turizm merkezlerinden birisi olan Alanya’dır. Bu nedenle bu çalışmada yeniden işlevlendirme ile restorasyonu yapılan geleneksel Alanya konutları çalışma alanı olarak seçilmiş, bu bölgedeki uygulamaların olumlu ve olumsuz yönleri ortaya konularak tartışılmıştır.

24 August 2023 in Religions
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
MKMERYEM ELİF ÇELEBİ KARAKÖK
MERYEM ELİF ÇELEBİ KARAKÖK
The religious journeys of humanity and their components are now recognized as cultural heritage values. UNESCO, WHC, ICOMOS, CIIC, and COE are organizations that actively work and issue international certificates for the protection, promotion, and survival of religious routes. These organizations have certified 14 faith-based routes as of 2023. A route’s certification is critical since it allows the route to be recognized globally and accessible to international tourism. However, each institution has its own set of requirements to obtain these certificates. When all religious cultures are examined, 14 routes are insufficient to explain the phenomenon of religion to today’s people. For this reason, it is beneficial to increase the current number by re-activating the religious routes that have affected large masses. Many countries apply every year to obtain certificates from these organizations with various route studies. However, many applications are rejected as insufficient. Therefore, the goal of this study is to determine the effective criteria for religious routes to receive international certification. In this regard, St. Paul’s Route stands out for its extensive geography spanning 12 countries and international potential. St. Paul is regarded as the most important figure in the spread of Christianity from Jerusalem to Anatolia and Europe. However, the St. Paul Routes being implemented do not meet the criteria of the any certificates. But the authentic St. Paul Route has the potential to receive certification from all organizations. In this research, the criteria required for the St. Paul Route to be certified by international organizations were investigated. A certified St. Paul Route will benefit many issues, including inter-religious dialogue between 12 countries, international cooperation, world peace, and sustainable tourism. It is thought to be an exemplary route with these features.

18 May 2023 in Mimarlık Bilimleri ve Uygulamaları Dergisi (MBUD)
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
SCSeray Coşkun
Seray Coşkun
MKMERYEM ELİF ÇELEBİ KARAKÖK
MERYEM ELİF ÇELEBİ KARAKÖK
Geography, climate, culture, and technology directly influenced the architectural production of societies. These effects first shaped the production of traditional architecture. After the developments in the industrial revolution, architectural formatting has been open to constant and rapid changes. These changes, dating back to the twentieth century and called modernism, aimed to move away from tradition and design with its forms. Design theorists divide between the view that modernism is directly influenced by tradition and that modernity is an entirely new formation. This research aims to identify the effects of these parameters with the parameters that shape tradition and modernism to shed light on the debates about the effect of modernization. In literature research, the design parameters that can be reached from the past to the present generally do not change in housing structures, and these parameters are included in the concept of environmental sustainability today. Therefore, traditional and modernist design product housing structures have been analyzed through environmental sustainability parameters. Information collected from the literature and selected structures were studied using the comparative analysis method. The results of the analysis will shed light on the discussions about the interaction of traditional and modernist designs with extracts from residents.