This paper presents a novel approach to identify inerter-based suspension struts, which can provide significant performance enhancement for passenger vehicles. The inerter has been used on Formula 1 racing cars, and several beneficial devices incorporating inerters have also been identified for ride comfort enhancement. However, previous investigations either were limited to simple network configurations with moderate performance improvement, or resulted in complicated configurations with a large number of elements which are impractical for real-life applications. In addition, some important practical performance constraints have not been taken into consideration, such as high-frequency dynamic stiffness which influences the NVH performance, and frequency content consideration of the sprung mass acceleration which more directly relates to passenger perception. In this paper, a quarter-car model including top mount is studied, with the performance of a conventional suspension strut presented as baseline. The structure-immittance approach, which can cover all networks with pre-determined numbers of each element type, is adopted for the identification of the optimal suspension configurations. Several configurations with up to a performance improvement are identified with all other practical performance indices to be no worse than the baseline. The suspension devices proposed in previous works are also considered for a sake of comparison, demonstrating significant advantages of the structure-immittance approach. Subsequently, a sensitivity analysis against the sprung and unsprung mass changes is carried out, which represents cargo and tyre weight variations, respectively. Time domain response and other reality checks are then conducted for the out-performing configurations, which reconfirm the ride comfort enhancement and ensure no unexpected behaviour occurs.
20 June 2023 in International Journal of Mechanical Sciences
Ride comfort is an important indicator to evaluate the dynamic performance of automotive vehicles. One method for improving ride comfort is to incorporate an active actuator into the passive suspension. However, the improvement is closely linked with the required actuation power and force. Increased actuation requirements may lead to higher energy consumption and a larger actuator size. To enhance the trade-off between ride comfort and active actuation requirements, a new design approach for searching for the optimal passive-active-combined suspension across many different mechanical component layouts incorporating an inerter is proposed in this paper. Compared with traditional designs where the suspension is limited to a few special layouts, via this approach the optimal passive part among all network possibilities with pre-determined numbers of each element type (springs, dampers and inerters), and optimal controller parameters of the parallel active actuator can be identified. Considering a quarter-car model, with a benchmark combined active-passive suspension in which the passive part is a spring-damper, the optimal inerter-based suspension can reduce the active force by more than 48% and regenerate 6 W more average power in the active part while achieving the same ride comfort. Note that in this case, two constraints are always considered: the road-holding ability (as indicated by the dynamic tyre load) and suspension travel of the identified suspension will not be worse than those of the benchmark suspension. The optimal trade-off obtained with this approach serves as a powerful tool in the automotive suspension design as it provides guidance on the following three aspects: the optimal ride comfort, the minimum power consumption and the feasibility of specific actuation requirements, where the second point is obtained in conjunction with the power conservation theorem proposed in this paper which proves that the total power consumed by the passive and active parts will not vary with changes in the passive part and active controller parameters.
Improving the track friendliness of a railway vehicle can benefit the railway industry significantly. Rail surface damage in curves can be reduced by using vehicles with a lower Primary Yaw Stiffness (PYS); however, this can reduce high-speed stability and worsen ride comfort. Previous studies have shown that this trade-off between track friendliness and passenger comfort can be successfully combated by using an inerter in the primary suspension; however, these utilise simplified vehicle models, contact models, and track inputs. Considering a realistic four-axle passenger vehicle model, this paper investigates the extent to which the PYS can be reduced with inertance-integrated primary lateral suspensions without increasing root-mean-square (RMS) carbody lateral accelerations. The vehicle model, with these enhanced suspensions, has been created in VAMPIRE , with the dynamics being captured over a range of vehicle velocities and equivalent conicities. Based on systematic optimisations using network-synthesis theory, several beneficial inertance-integrated configurations are identified, and the PYS can be reduced by up to 47% compared to the default vehicle (a potential Network Rail Variable Usage Charge saving of 26%), without increasing RMS carbody lateral accelerations. Further simulations are performed to investigate the vehicle's performance in curve transitions and when subject to one-off peak lateral track irregularities.