While the clinical importance of CD8+ and CD3+ cells in colorectal cancer (CRC) is well established, the impact of other immune cell subsets is less well described. We sought to provide a detailed overview of the immune landscape of CRC in the largest study to date in terms of patient numbers and in situ analyzed immune cell types. Tissue microarrays from 536 patients were stained using multiplexed immunofluorescence panels, and fifteen immune cell subclasses, representing adaptive and innate immunity, were analyzed. Overall, therapy-naïve CRC patients clustered into an ‘inflamed’ and a ‘desert’ group. Most T cell subsets and M2 macrophages were enriched in the right colon (p-values 0.046–0.004), while pDC cells were in the rectum (p = 0.008). Elderly patients had higher infiltration of M2 macrophages (p = 0.024). CD8+ cells were linked to improved survival in colon cancer stages I-III (q = 0.014), while CD4+ cells had the strongest impact on overall survival in metastatic CRC (q = 0.031). Finally, we demonstrated repopulation of the immune infiltrate in rectal tumors post radiation, following an initial radiation-induced depletion. This study provides a detailed analysis of the in situ immune landscape of CRC paving the way for better diagnostics and providing hints to better target the immune microenvironment.
Radiotherapy (RT) or chemoradiotherapy (CRT) are frequently used in rectal cancer, sometimes resulting in complete tumor remission (CR). The predictive capacity of all clinical factors, laboratory values and magnetic resonance imaging parameters performed in routine staging was evaluated to understand what determines an excellent response to RT/CRT. A population-based cohort of 383 patients treated with short-course RT (5 × 5 Gy in one week, scRT), CRT, or scRT with chemotherapy (scRT+CT) and having either had a delay to surgery or been entered into a watch-and-wait program were included. Complete staging according to guidelines was performed and associations between investigated variables and CR rates were analyzed in univariate and multivariate analyses. In total, 17% achieved pathological or clinical CR, more often after scRT+CT and CRT than after scRT (27%, 18% and 8%, respectively, p < 0.001). Factors independently associated with CR included clinical tumor stage, small tumor size (<3 cm), tumor level, and low CEA-value (<3.8 μg/L). Size or stage of the rectal tumor were associated with excellent response in all therapy groups, with small or early stage tumors being significantly more likely to reach CR (p = 0.01 (scRT), p = 0.01 (CRT) and p = 0.02 (scRT+CT). Elevated level of carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA) halved the chance of response. Extramural vascular invasion (EMVI) and mucinous character may indicate less response to RT alone.
The Receiver Operating Characteristic (ROC) is a de facto standard for determining the accuracy of in vitro diagnostic (IVD) medical devices, and thus the exactness in its probability distribution is crucial toward accurate statistical inference. We show the exact probability distribution of the ROC AUC-value, hence exact critical values and p-values are readily obtained. Because the exact calculations are computationally intense, we demonstrate a method of geometric interpolation, which is exact in a special case but generally an approximation, vastly increasing computational speeds. The method is illustrated through open access data, demonstrating superiority of 26 composite biomarkers relative to a predicate device. Especially under correction for testing of multiple hypotheses, traditional asymptotic approximations are encumbered by considerable imprecision, adversely affecting IVD device development. The ability to obtain exact p-values will allow more efficient IVD device development.
Summary: The Receiver Operating Characteristic (ROC) is a de facto standard for determining the accuracy of in vitro diagnostic (IVD) medical devices, and thus exactness in its probability distribution is crucial toward accurate statistical inference. We show the exact probability distribution of the ROC AUC-value, hence exact critical values and p-values are readily obtained. Because the exact calculations are computationally intense, we demonstrate a method of geometric interpolation which is exact in a special case but generally an approximation, vastly increasing computational speeds. The method is illustrated through open access data, demonstrating superiority of 26 composite biomarkers relative to a predicate device. Especially under correction for testing of multiple hypotheses, traditional asymptotic approximations are encumbered by considerable imprecision, adversely affecting IVD device development. The ability to obtain exact p-values will allow more efficient IVD device development.
Mutational analyses of tumor DNA guide the use of targeted therapies and checkpoint inhibitors in management of solid tumors. Reducing false positive mutation calls without compromising sensitivity as gene panels increase in size, and whole exome and genome sequencing enters clinical use, remains a major challenge. Aiming for robust somatic mutation analyses in the clinical setting, we have developed VARify, an integrated, accurate and computationally efficient software for cancer genome analyses encompassing all steps from pre-processing of sequencing reads to mutation identification. Benchmarking to two state-of-the-art open-source somatic mutation analysis pipelines demonstrated accurate detection of clinically actionable point mutations, all while strongly reducing the number of false positive mutations reported, at comparable or faster speed. Further, the VARify output classified microsatellite unstable colorectal cancers by tumor mutation burden better than the other pipelines. In comparisons where the same tumors were subjected to different panel enrichment and sequencing technologies, VARify had the most consistent intersection of consensus mutations. False positive calls were produced when the same data was used as tumor and reference by the other pipelines, while VARify did not produce such calls. The calling uniformity across sequencing technologies of VARify and its tumor-only analysis derivative pipeline ALTOmate was also demonstrated. Taken together, these two novel pipelines can improve clinical mutation analysis to the benefit of cancer patients.