There is a broad consensus on the potential of smart services for production and the added value their use offers. Industrial artificial intelligence (AI) has several advantages. AI technologies, for example, can strengthen resilience, support work processes, increase product quality and thus improve competitiveness. Many companies have recognised these potentials and are developing AI solutions. There are many successful proof-of-concepts (PoC) and pilot projects, but AI technologies successfully implemented in the real environment are scarce. Successful implementation of smart services based on industrial AI in production operations can be understood as its repetitive use and integration into operational business, which is a prerequisite for exploiting the potentials. Currently, little is known about how to achieve successful implementation. In contrast, there is much evidence that the implementation and operation of AI in manufacturing is associated with extensive challenges and barriers. The factors that positively influence the roll-out of AI technologies in manufacturing, however, are little explored. Therefore, this paper focuses on the identification of success factors and barriers for the implementation and operation of AI solutions in manufacturing. Furthermore, it is analysed whether and how the identified success factors and barriers differ from each other in order to subsequently derive initial recommendations for action. The methodology is based on explorative qualitative research. First, 10 semi-structured interviews were conducted with AI experts from a German Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM). In an expert workshop, the main findings were validated, and possible solution and support options were discussed. Our findings confirm the results found in the literature and complement them with new insights. Success factors and challenges can be found on the technical, organisational, and human side and relate most often to "data", "development and operational processes" and "stakeholder engagement".
Using data collected through the Internet of Things offers new opportunities for manufacturing companies to innovate and differentiate their increasingly significant service businesses. Developing these industrial smart services is a new and complex task that challenges manufacturing companies in many regards. One core issue is to design concepts and offers in a way that customers perceive as high value so they will accept collection of their data. However, academic research on industrial smart services is still in its infancy and contributes limited knowledge about customer expectations and requirements. Understanding how customers perceive the quality of smart services and understanding which determinants influence these perceptions can support manufacturing companies in developing successful offers. In this paper, the authors provide an integrative framework for understanding and structuring quality perceptions of industrial smart services. The framework integrates quality categories of existing concepts in related research fields (e.g., digital services, personal services, or technologies) and introduces new insights gained from a qualitative study of 20 academic experts. The structure of the framework and relevant categories of quality perceptions are explained in detail.
In recent years, a complex set of dynamic developments driven by both the economy and the emergence of digital technologies has put pressure on manufacturing companies to adapt. The concept of servitization, i.e., the shift from a product-centric to a service-centric value creation logic, can help manufacturing companies stabilize their business in such volatile times. Existing academic literature investigates the potential and challenges of servitization and the associated development of data-based services, so-called smart services, with a view to external market performance. However, with the increasing use of digital technologies in manufacturing and the development of internal smart services based on them, we argue that the existing insights on external servitization are also of interest for internal transformation. In this paper, we identify key findings from service literature, apply them to digital factory transformation, and structure them into six fields of action along the dimensions of people, technology, and organization. As a result, recommendations for designing digital factory transformation in manufacturing companies are derived from the perspective of servitization and developing internal smart services.