In this paper, we discuss the role of dialogue in two layers; first, in relation to two self-organised communities of science teachers in which we participated and, second, our process of coming together during our PhDs to analyse these communities, a dialogue about the dialogue. Regarding the first layer, there is much to learn from science teachers and science teacher educators when they are organised in sites of learning that can be spaces of hope, beginnings, and becoming, as is illustrated in the case of these two self-organised communities. Regarding the second layer, we discuss the value of dialogue and the possibilities it offers to develop ideas for science education in a way that might be democratising, emancipatory, and offering counter-narratives in a neoliberal Chile. By engaging in this dialogue revisiting the practices of our communities, we gained a sense of agency within the field of science education. However, we realised that we need to move towards a critical view within our communities, and more contextual and transformative science education by translating these sites of hope to our educational praxis today. For us, this relates both to developing a collective view of how to make science education provide pedagogical conditions and experiences for critical and engaged citizenship and thinking how we can act and engage with different settings in solidarity. One way of moving towards this is by developing a political knowledge of our disciplines through a collective scientific conscientisation. Our communities are the departure points to achieve this.
15 March 2023 in Cultural Studies of Science Education
In this introductory manuscript, we present our vision for this special issue as a space for cultivating collective becomings in/with love, critical hope, and solidarity. We also contemplate our intentions and goals for putting together a special issue such as this one. We then take a position as insider–outsiders of science education, moved by values such as attention, humility, and risk, and vulnerability, and to learn and be taught by others. After developing those ideas, we draw from the critical imaginations of authors in this special issue to reflect on what a praxis of radical love looks like as/for science and education. Finally, we present the four themes that form this special issue: Science curriculum for conscientização: counter-narratives from the field; transgressing and building solidarities across borders in science education; grassroots and collective becomings; dialogues with Freire; and intersections of critical pedagogy with other critical philosophical approaches.
16 April 2022 in Journal of Research in Science Teaching
This study examines the sense of agency developed through the hybrid identities of two Chilean educators working across a university physics department (as teacher educators), a secondary school (as part‐time teachers), and a self‐organized professional community to which they belong. A Freirean conceptualization of agency together with border crossing and hybridity was used as theoretical frameworks. Data were collected through biographical interviews and follow‐up conversations. A critical narrative approach was used for analysis. Findings suggest that the two physics educators encountered a hegemonic culture of physics education characterized by different hierarchies and tensions, such as the devaluation of pedagogy, lack of spaces for dialogue, and a punitive view of assessment. Nonetheless, evidence showed that by crossing the borders of different communities, the participants problematise their boundaries. Through their hybrid identities position, the participants enact their agency to contest such boundaries bringing new practices particularly to the physics department, such as offering spaces for collaboration, allowing others to cross boundaries between the school and the university, and across science disciplines. It is argued that such identities can provide new learning opportunities for their students and their colleagues. Moreover, evidence showed that the community to which participants belong acts as a space for cultivating hope, stressing the need for collective spaces for rethinking our practices. As such, their hybrid identity position offers a counter‐narrative to the idea that university physics departments hold only a traditional and banking view of physics teaching and knowledge. Hence, this study offers evidence of how the two physics educators disrupt the boundaries that limit who the teacher educators are and the practices they engage with, highlighting the need for more schoolteachers contributing to initial teacher education. Such a new actor could offer more narratives for future physics teachers to negotiate their ideas about pedagogy and physics.
This paper theorizes transformative agency and its potential to promote justice‐oriented science teacher education. We argue that science education often acts as a disimagination machine, constraining possibilities for envisioning and enacting transformative change. To contest this reality, we draw on critical perspectives in science education, specifically Paulo Freire's and Simone Weil's philosophies to theorize transformative agency as encompassing three dimensions: a) reading the world to identify injustices, b) imagining untested feasibilities, and c) writing the world anew. In doing so, we act upon the belief that inherited practices of science education that negate collective joy must be challenged. We expand current conceptualizations of transformative agency by proposing critical imagination as one of its core components, enabling the envisioning of possibilities for change. We propose three pedagogical approaches for cultivating critical imagination: a) facilitating practices that move beyond the self to recognize multiple human and nonhuman others; b) adopting a planet‐centred orientation to education transcending human‐centered approaches; and c) troubling dominant spatial and temporal scales of thinking. We argue for the need to develop liberatory pedagogies that bring critical scientific questions to justice issues while nurturing critical imagination. This entails conceiving agency as more than responsive classroom practices but rather as achieving justice‐oriented commitments, agendas and visions that center the world and its necessities.