Although the well-being of elephants in captivity is of paramount importance, the confinement of these long-lived, highly intelligent, and socially complex animals continues to present significant challenges. Here, we provide an overview of the current state of elephant confinement (primarily in the West) by examining captive facilities, improvements, and continuing problems, and the clinical/behavioral/neural issues that remain. Specifically, we examine quantitative and qualitative aspects of the enclosed space, sociocognitive factors, dietary differences, and health/welfare concerns (e.g., stereotypies, physical health, nutrition, reproduction, life expectancy). The challenges of the captive environment become especially salient when juxtaposed next to the complex, multifaceted characteristics of the elephant’s natural environment. Despite the best efforts of some facilities to improve the captive environment, serious welfare challenges remain. Such confinement issues thus raise important welfare and ethical concerns with regards to captive elephant well-being.
Modern zoos and entertainment parks have vastly improved over the decades. However, they still retain some of the old menagerie-style characteristics, such as restrictive space, lack of stimulation, and artificial social conditions. Highly intelligent species that are wide-ranging with complex social lives are at a greater risk for poor welfare in captive settings than others. Here, we explore the shared characteristics and welfare challenges of captive elephants and cetaceans, focusing on those characteristics such as space, sociality, and cognitive complexity, found to be important factors in coping with captivity across many species. We discuss the implications for whether elephants and cetaceans can thrive in zoos and marine parks and offer an alternative in the form of sanctuaries.