In construction projects, a significant part of construction work is done by subcontractors (SCs). Therefore, their management by main contractors (MCs) becomes an important issue as the density of SCs is created at the construction sites. In recent years, more focus on SC evaluation and selection in bidding process has been on the agenda whereas the subject of SC performance appraisal on-site during the project execution phase has been untended in the literature. Thus, this study aims to focus on the measurement and evaluation of the performance of SCs in the project execution phase, and to provide a tentative performance-based dynamic management framework that MCs will use in the management of SCs in order to take proactive measures. In line with the aim, a total number of 23 performance measurement criteria (PMC) under 7 main groups were determined as a result of a comprehensive literature review and expert evaluations. Knowing that not every criterion will have the same effect in performance measurement, pairwise comparisons of the criteria were made using the Pythagorean Fuzzy Analytic Hierarchy Process (PFAHP) method and their importance weights were determined. The PFAHP method was obtained by integrating the Pythagorean fuzzy set into the AHP method and chosen with the aim of improving the fuzzy AHP method and obtaining more consistent results by eliminating the uncertainty since Pythagorean fuzzy sets is more capable than fuzzy sets at expressing and handling uncertainty in uncertain environments. Lastly, a framework for SC performance measurement and evaluation on project execution phase is presented. It is believed that the presented framework will allow for a proactive management style that will enable effective decisions to be made while the project is ongoing, and a dynamic way of working instead of static and conventional work.
4 June 2025 in Engineering, Construction and Architectural Management
Purpose: There is a necessity for a dynamic tracing, controlling, and process of decision-making for on-site subcontractor (SC) performance management during the project execution phase. Therefore, this study presents a dynamic model that offers a new way to SC management with the integration of machine learning (ML) for faster and more effective evaluation of on-site performance data of SCs. Design/methodology/approach: A literature review on both on-site SC performance evaluation and ML use in construction management practices was conducted. Then, in line with the gap in the literature, the model developing phase begins with the “On-Site SC performance measurement (PM)” and continues with the “subcontractor average weighted performance,” where criterion weights were considered through the Pythagorean fuzzy analytic hierarchy process and used in data entry for ML. The development of the model continues with “machine learning algorithm selection.” The last stage consists of “the action plan” that constitutes the decision-making processes and is supported by expert support. Findings: For the ML-based model, six ML algorithms were tested individually, and decision tree algorithms were chosen among them and validated. The validation of the ML-based developed model was carried out on a superstructure project, and it was determined that the proposed model provided accurate results. The action plans suggested by the proposed model would help practitioners to determine corrective and/or precautionary actions in a faster and more accurate way regarding the real performance of SCs. Originality/value: This study lays stress on developing an ML-based dynamic performance management model based on the actual and continual PM of the SCs for the construction execution stage. Unlike existing literature that primarily focuses on selecting SCs based on their past performance during the bidding phase, this model enables real-time assessment of SC performance. In addition, with the help of ML integration, the dynamic structure of the model, which allows immediate identification of SCs who fall below the expected performance standards during the implementation phase and the derivation of relevant action plans, distinguishes the proposed model from other performance evaluation models.