The problem of predicting profitability is exceptionally relevant for investors and company owners. This paper examines the factors affecting firm performance and tests and compares various methods based on linear and non-linear dependencies between variables for predicting firm performance. In this study, the methods include random effects regression, individual machine learning algorithms with optimizers (DNN, LSTM, and Random Forest), and advanced machine learning methods consisting of sets of algorithms (portfolios and ensembles). The training sample includes 551 retail-oriented companies and data for 2017–2019 (panel data, 1653 observations). The test sample contains data for these companies for 2020. This study combines two approaches (stages): an econometric analysis of the influence of factors on the company’s profitability and machine learning methods to predict the company’s profitability. To compare forecasting methods, we used parametric and non-parametric predictive measures and ANOVA. The paper shows that previous profitability has a strong positive impact on a firm’s performance. We also find a non-linear positive effect of sales growth and web traffic on firm profitability. These variables significantly improve the prediction accuracy. Regression is inferior in forecast accuracy to machine learning methods. Advanced methods (portfolios and ensembles) demonstrate better and more steady results compared with individual machine learning methods.
Purpose: The purpose of this study is the detection and comparison of distinctive features of Gazelle firms (GFs) at three stages evolution outside the typical boundaries.Design/methodology/approach: The study uses Analysis of Variance and logistic regression to tests the performance of 2427 gazelles for (GFs) a five-year period (2015–2020).Findings: The study found that GFs prediction probability is low. In their second and third stages of evolution (initial growth and continuing growth), the gazelle growth effects appear. They are more effective in terms of profitability and turnover due to increasing sales and size.Practical implications: This study shows that stakeholders should give preference to GFs that demonstrate long-term (steady) growth. Such firms are more efficient and financially stable than firms with high short-term growth.Originality/value: The present study identifies patterns in the generation and development of GFs in high-tech industries outside the typical boundaries.
The problem of predicting profitability is exceptionally relevant for investors and company owners making decisions about investment and business development. The global literature contains a number of studies where researchers predict the profitability of firms using various methods, including modern machine learning. However, these works hardly take advantage of panel data. This paper takes advantage of additional capabilities offered by panel data and proposes hybrid forecasting methods based on panel data, which allow significantly improving the accuracy of predicting the profitability. Our calculations show that when predicting the profitability, investors and company owners should take into account the profitability of the previous years and the trend in its change. The work shows that this approach can be successfully applied to high-tech companies whose profitability is characterised by increased volatility. Prediction forecasting includes STL-decomposition of time series, regression with random effects and machine learning (LSTM and CatBoost), and clustering. The training sample includes 1811 companies and data for 2013–2018 (panel data, 10,866 observations). The test sample contains data for these companies for 2019. As a result, the authors propose an approach significantly improving the accuracy of predicting ROA and ROE based on the panel nature of the data. The panel data allowed using the profitability of the previous years in forecast models and applying the STL-decomposition of the profitability of the previous years into three variables (Trend, Seasonal, and Residual), considerably improving the quality of the constructed forecast models (STL-CatBoost, STL-LSTM, and STL-RE hybrid models).
12 January 2022 in Journal of the Knowledge Economy
The importance of well-established and customer-friendly firms' websites has increased in the context of the digitalization of the economy. The COVID-19 pandemic has become a new driver for the development of Internet communications between manufacturers and consumers. This article explores the relationship between the Internet traffic of companies' websites of and their sales volumes and profitability. We apply panel data regression analysis and model of Prais-Winsten regression with panel standard error adjustment, which provides conservative and reliable estimates. In the sample of 268 observations drawn from 67 Russian firms operating in the big-ticket industries of car manufacturing and real estate development during the period of 2017-2022 characterized by a major exogenous shock, we demonstrate that internet traffic exerts a positive effect on firm sales. At the same time, this positive effect on sales is accompanied by a negative effect of internet traffic on firm profitability. The negative effect on profitability is particularly pronounced for younger firms that are likely to face severe resource constraints and can thus be said to sacrifice profitability to ensure sales. In such situation, application of cost-effective strategies may be critical for younger firms. Younger firms should pay particular attention to the contents of their websites to ensure that they provide enough adequate information that will help win the trust of new customers.