All humans deal with acute psychological stress periodically. Some individuals are affected by needle phobia in which a heightened sense of arousal is precipitated by venepuncture. Acute psychological stress invokes a range of physiological changes including activation of the sympathetic-adrenal-medullary and hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axes. In this review article, we first examine the human response to acute stress. We then provide an overview of how psychological stress in a subject is likely to be a source of pre-analytical variability for certain measurands, and the major biochemical markers that have been studied in research aiming to quantify stress. As such, we highlight how stress can be a hindrance to the accurate interpretation of certain laboratory results (particularly cortisol, prolactin, metanephrines and growth hormone), and point out the role that biochemical analysis might play in future studies looking at the effects of stress on human behaviour.
2 June 2023 in International Journal of Healthcare Simulation
Introduction Student stress is well-documented within the field of simulation-based medical education. However, current research is unclear as to what level of stress is optimal for an enhanced educational experience. This ambiguity may partly be due to the use of one or a small number of stress metrics in study designs. Objective Our study will aim to evaluate the feasibility of measuring the human stress response during medical simulation, using a suite of techniques. Methods Audiovisual (video spectacles), biochemical (serum cortisol and plasma metanephrine/normetanephrine), physiological (blood pressure, galvanic skin response and heart rate) and psychological (State-Trait Anxiety Inventory and Big Five Inventory-2) markers of stress will be monitored during two randomized medical simulations of differing complexities. Introduction Student stress is well-documented within the field of simulation-based medical education. However, current research is unclear as to what level of stress is optimal for an enhanced educational experience. This ambiguity may partly be due to the use of one or a small number of stress metrics in study designs. Objective Our study will aim to evaluate the feasibility of measuring the human stress response during medical simulation, using a suite of techniques. Methods Audiovisual (video spectacles), biochemical (serum cortisol and plasma metanephrine/normetanephrine), physiological (blood pressure, galvanic skin response and heart rate) and psychological (State-Trait Anxiety Inventory and Big Five Inventory-2) markers of stress will be monitored during two randomized medical simulations of differing complexities.
27 October 2022 in International Journal of Healthcare Simulation
In recent years simulation has gained popularity as an educational tool to shield learners from real-world consequence. However, the inherent risks levied upon those involved have largely remained unaddressed; psychological stress being one of the most potent. Research over the last two decades has shown us that an increase in simulation-related stress goes hand-in-hand with diminishing performance. It is, however, becoming more apparent that there is a solution to this problem, namely in the form of stress-reduction interventions. As educators the time has come to stop abandoning our learners at the edge of their limits, but instead support them in an environment free of the anxieties, stresses and worries that are all too real in the world around them. In recent years simulation has gained popularity as an educational tool to shield learners from real-world consequence. However, the inherent risks levied upon those involved have largely remained unaddressed; psychological stress being one of the most potent. Research over the last two decades has shown us that an increase in simulation-related stress goes hand-in-hand with diminishing performance. It is, however, becoming more apparent that there is a solution to this problem, namely in the form of stress-reduction interventions. As educators the time has come to stop abandoning our learners at the edge of their limits, but instead support them in an environment free of the anxieties, stresses and worries that are all too real in the world around them.
In recent years, simulation has come to prominence as an educational method within the healthcare professions, aiming to shield learners from real-world consequences. However, the associated risks of this educational method have largely remained unaddressed. One of the most potent risks of simulation is felt to be the experience of psychological stress. Over the last two decades, researchers have suggested that an increase in simulation-related stress goes hand-in-hand with diminishing performance, but the evidence base for this claim is lacking. A medical educator thus has no robust scientific steering on which to gauge how ‘hard to push’ a trainee in a simulation environment to best assist their learning. In this review we systematically analyse the literature to further understand the impact of simulation-related stress on learner performance and report that inducing a high-stress environment during simulation is generally associated with impaired performance.
6 June 2025 in Global Surgical Education - Journal of the Association for Surgical Education
Research on stress in surgical simulation education (SSE) is growing, driven by recognition of its impact on learning. Measuring stress is complex, given the range of wearable devices and biomarkers. Effective investigation of the human stress response (HSR) requires careful tool selection. This commentary reviews key device-based markers, their strengths and limitations, and advocates a triangulated, multi-modal approach to stress evaluation.
15 September 2023 in International Journal of Healthcare Simulation