Vanessa Ashall

Dr. Vanessa Ashall


Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

18Years (2009-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
19 February 2020 in Medical Humanities
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
GDGail Davies
Gail Davies
RGRichard Gorman
Richard Gorman
BGBeth Greenhough
Beth Greenhough
PHPru Hobson-West
Pru Hobson-West
RKRobert G W Kirk
Robert G W Kirk
TSTess Skidmore
Tess Skidmore
Animals used in biological research and testing have become integrated into the trajectories of modern biomedicine, generating increased expectations for and connections between human and animal health. Animal research also remains controversial and its acceptability is contingent on a complex network of relations and assurances across science and society, which are both formally constituted through law and informal or assumed. In this paper, we propose these entanglements can be studied through an approach that understands animal research as a nexus spanning the domains of science, health and animal welfare. We introduce this argument through, first, outlining some key challenges in UK debates around animal research, and second, reviewing the way nexus concepts have been used to connect issues in environmental research. Third, we explore how existing social sciences and humanities scholarship on animal research tends to focus on different aspects of the connections between scientific research, human health and animal welfare, which we suggest can be combined in a nexus approach. In the fourth section, we introduce our collaborative research on the animal research nexus, indicating how this approach can be used to study the history, governance and changing sensibilities around UK laboratory animal research. We suggest the attention to complex connections in nexus approaches can be enriched through conversations with the social sciences and medical humanities in ways that deepen appreciation of the importance of path-dependency and contingency, inclusion and exclusion in governance and the affective dimension to research. In conclusion, we reflect on the value of nexus thinking for developing research that is interdisciplinary, interactive and reflexive in understanding how accounts of the histories and current relations of animal research have significant implications for how scientific practices, policy debates and broad social contracts around animal research are being remade today.

5 April 2023 in Veterinary Anaesthesia and Analgesia
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
VAVanessa Ashall
Vanessa Ashall
DMDavid Morton
David Morton
ECEddie Clutton
Eddie Clutton
This article examines the ethical principles underlying the Declaration of Helsinki as an internationally agreed justificatory framework for human medical research. The aim of the analysis is to consider the potential usefulness of these principles for defining an internationally agreed ethical 'best practice' in clinical veterinary research (CVR). It is suggested that the specific ethical responsibilities of the clinician to protect the interests of their patient when conducting medical research may be translated into the veterinary setting. Through exploring risk and harm, unproven interventions, vulnerability and informed consent, the article identifies the ethical risks of CVR. It is shown that veterinary regulators in the UK and the European Union have addressed these concerns to varying degrees; however, disagreements over the appropriateness of specific CVR practices are identified. A commitment to collaborative exploration of the benefits and challenges of implementing a Declaration of Helsinki for Animals is proposed.

6 February 2017 in Sociology of Health & Illness
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
VAVanessa Ashall
Vanessa Ashall
PHPru Hobson-West
Pru Hobson-West
This article demonstrates the relevance of animals to medical sociology by arguing that pet owners’ accounts of veterinary decision‐making can highlight key sociological themes which are important to both human and animal health. Based on semi‐structured interviews, the article argues that interspecies ‘kinship’ allows for the extension of sociological claims regarding altruism, self‐interest and mutuality from human blood donation to companion animal blood ‘donation’. Furthermore, this study extends sociological understanding of the human‐animal bond by showing how the dog's status as kin meant they were expected to donate blood, and that the act of donation itself represents an important opportunity for family ‘display’. However, owners who do not or cannot donate blood themselves describe pet blood donation as an opportunity to lessen associated feelings of guilt or obligation through ‘doing good by proxy’. These findings raise critical sociological and ethical questions concerning the risks and benefits of donation, and for how we understand third‐party decision making. Finally, the article argues for the close entanglement of human and animal health, and concludes that sociologists of health and medicine should explore the radical possibility that decision‐making in healthcare more generally might be influenced by experiences at the veterinary clinic, and vice versa. (A Virtual Abstract of this paper can be viewed at: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC_979cmCmR9rLrKuD7z0ycA)

17 March 2022 in Frontiers in Veterinary Science
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
VAVanessa Ashall
Vanessa Ashall
I can still see the dog's face as its eyes connected with mine, framed by the black bin bag it had been carried in. I can still hear the clicking sound, louder than the animal's shrill cries, made by a mass of maggots moving against one another beneath the dogs matted fur, moistened by fluids leaking from its damaged flesh. My hands were shaking with panic and rage and I could hardly draw up the euthatal into the syringe quickly enough. I wanted to put an end to this, immediately. As the lethal fluid flowed into the tiny vein the dog's body finally relaxed. At my hand, like so many others, she had ceased to exist. Through the window I could see her owners waiting outside in the sunshine to pay me and I thought about the silky feel of the fur which covered an expensively shaped head. I knew this dog was loved once.This paper develops two neglected areas of veterinary thought; anthropological studies of the veterinary profession and feminist care approaches in veterinary ethics. I argue that the development of veterinary anthropology is crucial to advancing our understanding of veterinary lived experiences, through highlighting the previously under acknowledged emotional, relational and contextual realities of veterinary practice. I further propose that an ethic of care for the veterinary profession, which meaningfully connects with veterinary lived experiences, may provide a valuable approach through which to further develop veterinary ethical thinking. I share an autoethnographic account of a difficult veterinary encounter, which I then analyse using a novel feminist care approach. Through analyses centered on both emotional and relational aspects of veterinary care, I challenge the boundaries of traditional veterinary ethical approaches in terms of the scope, scale and complexity of veterinary ethical decision making. I describe the concept of emotional sponge work in veterinary practice and outline its potential impact for advancing understanding of both veterinary well-being and the profession's societal role. Finally, I propose that a feminist ethic of care might provide a framework for redefining the focus of veterinary professional responsibility, beyond animal health and toward the maintenance of healthy relationships between humans and animals.

17 May 2023 in Animals
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
VAVanessa Ashall
Vanessa Ashall
This study examines experiences of veterinary moral stress in charity veterinary practice and qualitatively evaluates the role of ethical discussion in reducing veterinary moral stress. Results are drawn from a thematic data analysis of 9 focus groups and 15 individual interviews with veterinary team members from 3 UK charity veterinary hospitals. Moral stress is described as an everyday experience by participants and is caused by uncertainty about their ability to fulfill their ethical obligations. Moral stress is shown to be cumulative and can interact with other forms of stress. Distinct practical and relational barriers to ethical action are identified and proposed as contributors to moral stress, and different team members experience different barriers within their roles. The potential impact of moral stress on team members’ quality of life and mental health is highlighted. Results show that regular facilitated ethical group discussions may reduce moral stress in the hospital setting, particularly through familiarization with others’ roles and ethical perspectives and through supporting one another’s ethical decision-making. The article concludes that moral stress is an important and poorly understood problem in veterinary practice and that further development of regular facilitated ethical group discussion may be of considerable benefit to team members.

9 October 2025 in Human-Animal Interactions
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
RMRenelle McGlacken
Renelle McGlacken
Rebecca SmithRebecca Smith
Rebecca Smith
TKTammie King
Tammie King
VAVanessa Ashall
Vanessa Ashall
In the expanding field of human-animal interaction (HAI) research, studies examining the relationship between pet ownership and human health and wellbeing have struggled with inconsistent and inconclusive findings around whether interacting with a pet has a positive, negative, or even a significant impact. These inconsistencies have driven efforts to interrogate methodological approaches and strengthen scientific rigor in HAI research, aiming to develop a clearer and fuller understanding of how pet ownership can affect human health and wellbeing. This article examines whether prominent approaches to understanding both relationships between humans and companion animals, and the concept of wellbeing itself, can adequately capture the complexity of their interrelations. We surmise that the disciplinary traditions within HAI research have shaped the treatment of the key subjects – humans, animals, and wellbeing – in ways that lead to the issues presented in the literature today. Aiming to contribute to addressing this challenge, we propose that embracing a relational approach would help generate a more holistic understanding of human-animal relationships and the ways in which they affect human wellbeing. A relational approach, which sees humans, animals, and wellbeing not as fixed entities but emerging through fluid interrelationships and contexts, can help us better understand the dynamic nature of the ‘pet-effect’ question. Taking the concept of the ‘multispecies family’ as an example, we illustrate how relational thinking can reveal both the complexity and significance of modern pet-owner relationships, going beyond a simple ‘pet-effect’. Finally, we end with future directions for relational HAI research and its impact beyond academia. While significant expertise already exists in the HAI space, diversifying the concepts and approaches we use, while being sensitive to their differing methodological and philosophical roots, will enhance our collective efforts to better understand how people and pets can create wellbeing together. Overall, rather than attempting to conclude the existence of a generic ‘pet-effect’ at large, we advocate for further attention to the specific ways in which understandings and experiences of wellbeing emerge within these frequently profound, yet diverse, human-animal relationships.