Purpose: It is questioned whether the exposure–response relation for the onset of vibration-induced white finger (VWF) in ISO 5349-1:2001 needs to be revised based on the epidemiologic studies identified by Nilsson et al. (PLoS One https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0180795, 2017), and whether the relation they derive improves the prediction of VWF in vibration-exposed populations. Methods: A pooled analysis has been performed using epidemiologic studies that complied with selection rules and reported a VWF prevalence of 10% or more, and exposure constructed according to the provisions of ISO 5349-1:2001. The lifetime exposures at 10% prevalence were calculated for various data sets using linear interpolation. They were then compared to both the model from the standard and that developed by Nilsson et al. Results: Regression analyses reveal excluding extrapolation to adjust group prevalences to 10% produce models with 95-percentile confidence intervals that include the ISO exposure–response relation but not that in Nilsson et al. (2017). Different curve fits are obtained for studies involving daily exposure to single or multiple power tools and machines. Studies with similar exposure magnitudes and lifetime exposure durations but markedly different prevalences are observed to cluster. Conclusions: A range of exposures and A(8)-values is predicted within which the onset of VWF is most likely to occur. The exposure–response relation in ISO 5349-1:2001, but not that proposed by Nilsson et al., falls within this range and provides a conservative estimate for the development of VWF. In addition, the analyses suggest that the method for evaluating vibration exposure contained in ISO 5349-1:2001 needs revision.
The objectives of the Workshop are addressed using epidemiologic data from population groups in occupations involving exposure to hand-transmitted vibration and/or shocks. Pooled analyses demonstrate the limitations of the exposure–response relation in ISO 5349-1:2001, and that A(8) is inappropriate for calculating the daily exposure to shocks as well as to continuous vibration. Alternative frequency weightings and metrics for daily exposure are explored.
An invertible, generalisable population model for the time course of the prevalence of a health effect resulting from habitual exposure to a physical agent, such as vibration, and noise, is proposed. The model includes a time-dependent factor representing the daily exposure, expfac(t), applied to a polynomial fit of prevalence-time data recorded in a population group and one additional numerical parameter, a'1, to adjust the model for exposure-specific conditions. A model is constructed for the prevalence of vibration-induced white finger (VWF) to confirm and validate its performance. A 4th-order polynomial fits representative data recorded in a population group from the commencement of exposure. Using the same polynomial coefficients and solely adjusting expfac(t) enables the model to fit period prevalence data for VWF from all available population groups as a function of time. Adjusting a'1 enables the model to predict the point prevalence. If expfac(t) is specified in terms of the daily 8-h, energy-equivalent, frequency-weighted triaxial acceleration, the prevalences observed in different populations groups can be interrelated and interpolated to a common value (e.g., 10%) by inverting the model. This will enable tolerable daily exposures suitable for occupational environments to be defined for hand-transmitted vibration.
21 September 2023 in Annals of Work Exposures and Health
A pooled analysis of vibration-induced white finger (VWF) in population groups of workers has been performed using the results of a published meta-analysis as source material (Nilsson T, Wahlström J, Burström L. Hand-arm vibration and the risk of vascular and neurological diseases a systematic review and meta-analysis. PLoS One. 2017:12(7):e0180795. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0180795). The methods of data selection follow those described previously by Scholz et al. (in Scholz MF, Brammer AJ, Marburg S. Exposure-response relation for vibration-induced white finger: inferences from a published meta-analysis of population groups. Int Arch Occup Environ Health. 2023a:96(5):757–770. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00420-023-01965-w) to enable comparison with the results of the present work. The analyzed epidemiologic studies contain different prevalences of VWF observed after different durations of employment involving exposure to the vibration of power tools and machines. These prevalences are transformed to 10% prevalence by either linear or polynomial (i.e. “S”-shaped curvilinear) interpolation in order to compare with the exposure–response relation contained in the relevant international standard (ISO 5349-1:2001). An exposure–response relation is constructed using regression analysis for the time (in years) to reach 10% prevalence in a population group, when subjected to a daily vibration exposure calculated according to the procedures specified in the standard, A(8). Good fits to the data are obtained when polynomial and linear prevalence interpolation is used. The 95-percentile confidence intervals (CIs) of the exposure–response relation predicted by polynomial prevalence interpolation lie at somewhat larger lifetime exposures than those obtained by linear prevalence interpolation. Uncertainty in the precision of polynomial prevalence interpolation is mitigated by giving equal weight to linear interpolation when interpreting the results. When the 95-percentile CIs of the exposure–response models obtained by linear and polynomial prevalence interpolation are used to define the most probable exposure–response relation, the resulting common range of values includes the ISO exposure–response relation. It is proposed that an exposure–response relation for the onset of VWF derived from a regression analysis is specified in terms of the lower limit of its CI. Hence, when exposure measures are constructed according to the ISO standard and equal weight is given to the results of the 2 methods for interpolating prevalence described here, the ISO exposure–response relation would be considered to provide a conservative estimate for a 10% prevalence of VWF to develop in a population group, at least for A(8) > 4 m/s2. It thus remains the relation to use for assessing exposure to hand-transmitted vibration in the workplace. Additional research is needed to resolve inconsistencies in the ISO method for calculating daily exposures.
2 May 2026 in International Archives of Occupational and Environmental Health
Purpose: It is analyzed whether differences in how the daily usage time is determined in a population exposed to hand-transmitted vibration are the cause of discrepancies between exposure-response models constructed for vibration-induced white finger (VWF). The predictions of the models are then used to evaluate the one in ISO 5349-1:2001. Methods: Pooled analyses employing data from epidemiologic studies of vibration-exposed occupations deemed the most reliable, together with published ratios between daily tool or machine usage times determined by questionnaire or interview and measured values, are used to construct exposure-response relations. These models are compared to those in which the daily usage time is not compensated. Results: Of 17 data points, for 7 the usage time ratio is greater than 1, and for the rest the ratio is equal to 1. Adjusting daily vibration exposures, expressed as A(8)-values, by means of such ratios, results in reductions of varying magnitude. However, the exposure-response models show minor changes, and the scatter in the data points previously observed remains. Conclusions: Methods for estimating 10% prevalence of VWF from the prevalence recorded in a population study are found to have more effect on the models than different methods for estimating the daily usage time. Yet, the spread and clustering in the data remain and point to issues in the constituents of the A (8)-value. The ISO relation is generally consistent with the lower 95-percentile confidence limit of the models and so provides a conservative exposure limit at least for A (8)-values greater than about 3 $$\frac{m}{s^2}$$ .
Purpose It is questioned whether the exposure-response relation for the onset of vibration-induced white finger (VWF) in ISO 5349-1:2001 needs to be revised based on the epidemiologic studies identified by Nilsson et al., (2017) (https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0180795), and whether the relation they derive improves the prediction of VWF in vibrationexposed populations. Methods A pooled analysis has been performed using pidemiologic studies that complied with selection rules and reported a VWF prevalence of 10% or more, and exposure constructed according to the provisions of ISO 5349-1:2001. The lifetime exposure at 10% prevalence was calculated for various data sets using linear interpolation. They were then compared to both the model from the standard and that developed by Nilsson et al. Results Regression analyses reveal excluding extrapolation to adjust group prevalences to 10% produce models with 95-percentile confidence intervals that include the ISO exposure-response relation but not that in Nilsson et al. (2017). Different curve fits are obtained for studies involving daily exposure to single or multiple power tools and machines. Studies with similar exposure magnitudes and lifetime exposure durations but markedly different prevalences are observed to cluster. Conclusions A range of exposures and A(8)-values is predicted within which the onset of VWF is most likely to occur. The exposure-response relation in ISO 5349-1:2001, but not that proposed by Nilsson et al., falls within this range and provides a conservative estimate for the development of VWF. Additionally, the analyses demonstrate that the method for evaluating vibration exposure contained in ISO 5349-1:2001 needs revision.